New York Health logo with link
Secure

Dr. Colleen McCloy, MD

Surgeon
226 N Belle Mead Rd, Ste C, Setauket- East Setauket, NY
4.90
“Dr. McCloy performed a medical procedure for me and I was absolutely blown away how kind, compassionate, through and excellent medical service that I received. She is a real doctor who genuinely care about her patients. Staff and nurse are very friendly and kind. The whole experience was the best that I’ve ever had with Dr’s visit. I was so grateful and touched by her most caring and humble manner. Thank you very much Dr. McCloy. It was heavenly experience! When I walked out, I had a full-blown smile over her kindness and excellent treatment! ”
Sunyoung J.January 13, 2026

Highly recommended

98% of patients gave this doctor 5 stars

Excellent wait time

91% of patients waited less than 30 minutes

New patient appointments

Appointments available for new patients

In-network insurances
Aetna, BlueCross BlueShield, Cigna, Medicare, UnitedHealthcare

Book an appointment

Are you new to this practice?
Patient type
  1. Insurance carrier and plan

Tomorrow, Nov 17 – Mon, Nov 30

About Dr. Colleen McCloy

Colleen McCloy, MD, FACS, is Board Certified by the American Board of Surgery and a Fellow of the American College of Surgeons. Dr. McCloy, also known as “Corky” McCloy, grew up in Texas and attended the University of Texas Medical School in Houston. She completed her Surgical Residency at the Ochsner Medical Foundation in New Orleans. Since 1999, Dr. McCloy has been serving Long Island as an Attending General Surgeon at both John T. Mather Memorial Hospital and St. Charles Hospital and Rehabilitation Center for almost 20 years. She is an active member of the Breast Program Leadership Committee and participates in the Breast Cancer Conferences held at John T. Mather Memorial Hospital.

In-network insurances

99% of patients have successfully booked with these insurances

Aetna
BlueCross BlueShield
Cigna
Medicare
UnitedHealthcare

Areas of expertise

This doctor's experience enhances their expertise in similar cases. Below are the conditions or surgeries they treat most frequently.
Gallbladder removal
Mastectomy
Groin hernia surgery
Gallbladder removal
Mastectomy
Groin hernia surgery

Practice

New York Health

**Please note that the name of your insurance company and your ID number are required. Thank you for your understanding and we look forward to seeing you.

Office locations

New York Health (1 of 2)
226 N Belle Mead Rd, Ste C, Setauket- East Setauket, NY 11733
New York Health (2 of 2)
226 N Belle Mead Rd, Ste C, East Setauket, NY 11733
1 of 2

Education and background

Board certifications

  • American Board of Surgery

Education and training

  • University of Texas, Houston, Doctor of Medicine
  • Ochsner Medical Center, Residency in Surgery

Professional memberships

  • American College of Surgeons

Awards and publications

  • Castle Connolly Top Doctor

Languages spoken

  • English

Provider's gender

Female

NPI number

1568411387

Patient reviews

Overall rating
4.90
Wait time
4.45
Bedside manner
4.64
Your trust matters. All reviews have been submitted by verified patients after seeing the provider. Any content containing private health information is not published.

41 reviews

Filter results based on frequently mentioned key words

Dr McCloy is thorough and has a wonderful caring bedside manner!
Verified patient
My appointment was at 12:45pm. I had arrived around 12:25. Signed in and waited for about 15 minutes. Next my copayment amount was taken. Sat back down and waited. Around 1:10 pm I went up to the desk to see how much longer it would be until I could see the doctor. They were unsure and had to go check. Came back saying it would be at least another 15-20 minutes. I ended up asking for my copayment to be refunded because I had another appointment later on and only allowed an hour and a half for this appointment. They could not refund me and said someone would call. No one has called. My copayment has not been refunded. I have called and emailed them. Still waiting. Not a good experience for a first time patient.
Verified patient
Dr. McCloy performed a medical procedure for me and I was absolutely blown away how kind, compassionate, through and excellent medical service that I received. She is a real doctor who genuinely care about her patients. Staff and nurse are very friendly and kind. The whole experience was the best that I’ve ever had with Dr’s visit. I was so grateful and touched by her most caring and humble manner. Thank you very much Dr. McCloy. It was heavenly experience! When I walked out, I had a full-blown smile over her kindness and excellent treatment!
Verified patient
Great experience. Easy. Comfortable.
Verified patient
Friendly staff. Dr. McCloy was very nice.
Verified patient
Office efficient & friendly, Dr McCloy was as highly recommended, friendly and very through. Extremely pleased with my consult.
Verified patient
Verified patient
Verified patient