New York Health logo with link
Secure

Dr. Randall Schrager, MD

Surgeon
69 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY
5.00
“The experience with this Dr. and office was absolutely seamless. The staff was attentive. The doctor was lovely and I felt reassured and ready to proceed with my procedure. Would highly recommend this office and Dr. ”
Melissa J.October 21, 2026

Highly recommended

100% of patients gave this doctor 5 stars

Excellent wait time

100% of patients waited less than 30 minutes

New patient appointments

Appointments available for new patients

In-network insurances
Aetna, Cigna, Medicare, UnitedHealthcare

Book an appointment

Are you new to this practice?
Patient type
  1. Insurance carrier and plan

Fri, Dec 4 – Thu, Dec 17

About Dr. Randall Schrager

Randall E. Schrager, MD FACS, is a board-certified surgeon with over 29 years of experience providing quality, compassionate care to patients in the Port Jefferson area. Dr. Schrager is an accomplished breast surgeon, having pioneered minimally invasive, image-guided breast biopsy procedures in Suffolk County in 1996. His expertise encompasses a range of breast-conserving techniques, including mammosite brachytherapy, sentinel lymph node biopsy, and oncoplastics. He was a founding member of the Physician advisory committee for the Fortunato Breast Center and continues to serve as a member of Mather Hospital’s Breast Program Leadership Committee. Dr. Schrager continues to perform a wide range of general surgical procedures with extensive experience in standard laparoscopy and robotic surgery. Aside from procedures for colon diseases, he is particularly interested in gallbladder surgery and all types of hernia repairs. Dr. Schrager graduated from Thomas Jefferson University School of Medicine in 1988 and completed his surgical residency at Pennsylvania Hospital in 1993. He achieved his Board Certification from the American Board of Surgery in 1994. He is a Fellow of the American College of Surgeons. He serves as Director of Surgery at John T. Mather Memorial Hospital. In addition, he holds privileges at St. Charles Hospital and Rehabilitation Center and St. Catherine of Siena Medical Center. Dr. Schrager holds the honor of receiving the distinguished "Theodore Roosevelt Award" for outstanding dedication to the community. He has been serving the community for 29 years.

In-network insurances

99% of patients have successfully booked with these insurances

Aetna
Cigna
Medicare
UnitedHealthcare

Areas of expertise

This doctor's experience enhances their expertise in similar cases. Below are the conditions or surgeries they treat most frequently.
Groin hernia surgery
Abdominal hernia repair surgery
Gallbladder removal
Groin hernia surgery
Abdominal hernia repair surgery
Gallbladder removal

Practice

New York Health

**Please note that the name of your insurance company and your ID number are required. Thank you for your understanding and we look forward to seeing you.

Office locations

New York Health (1 of 2)
69 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706
New York Health (2 of 2)
226 N Belle Mead Rd, Ste C, East Setauket, NY 11733
1 of 2

Education and background

Board certifications

  • American Board of Surgery

Education and training

  • Medical School - Philadelphia University + Thomas Jefferson University, Doctor of Medicine
  • Pennsylvania Hospital, Residency in Surgery

Professional memberships

  • American College of Surgeons

Awards and publications

  • Castle Connolly Top Doctor
  • Theodore Roosevelt Award

Languages spoken

  • English

Provider's gender

Male

NPI number

1922058072

Patient reviews

Overall rating
5.00
Wait time
5.00
Bedside manner
5.00
Your trust matters. All reviews have been submitted by verified patients after seeing the provider. Any content containing private health information is not published.

52 reviews

Filter results based on frequently mentioned key words

The experience with this Dr. and office was absolutely seamless. The staff was attentive. The doctor was lovely and I felt reassured and ready to proceed with my procedure. Would highly recommend this office and Dr.
Verified patient
Friendly, prompt, professional and human!!
Verified patient
The doctor explained the procedure step by step and was very thorough made me feel comfortable that I made a good choice going there was ready to answer any questions I may have The office staff was very nice and friendly great experience I would definitely recommend this doctor
Verified patient
outstanding!
Verified patient
Very attentive and made me feel very comfortable
Verified patient
Great confidence in Dr and staff
Verified patient
Verified patient
Verified patient
Verified patient
Verified patient
Verified patient
Verified patient
Verified patient
Verified patient