As patient call volumes grow and expectations for seamless access increase, healthcare leaders are replacing older technologies such as IVR and chatbots with cutting-edge AI voice agents like Zo. Understanding the differences is key to improving patient satisfaction, maximizing staff efficiency, and driving increased revenue.
If you’re just starting to evaluate AI-powered communication, this guide will help you understand each tool’s strengths and weaknesses, and how an AI voice agent like Zo can help you modernize phone operations and accelerate practice growth.
IVR: The Legacy Menu
Interactive Voice Response (IVR) systems are the clunky phone menus we all know and do not love –– “Press 1 for appointments, Press 2 for billing.” These systems are often used to route calls, share basic information, or collect simple inputs like date of birth or patient ID numbers.
But IVR systems are locked into an impersonal, scripted, menu-driven path. If patients get confused, press the wrong button, or have questions that don’t fit the prompts, the system can’t help, leading to frustration, dropped calls, and long hold times. Many patients attempt to bypass IVRs by immediately asking for a human, assuming it will be faster. But instead of streamlining operations, this often creates more work for staff, who must manually triage and transfer calls to the appropriate person. While IVRs were once seen as a path to greater efficiency, they often contribute to poor patient experiences and added administrative burden.
Chatbots: Text-Only Tools With Limited Reach
Chatbots are text-based tools embedded into websites, patient portals, and apps. Some are powered by AI, but most are limited to fixed scripts or decision trees. They can be helpful for quick, simple tasks such as answering FAQs, collecting patient intake forms, or sending reminders. However, chatbots only work if the patient is already on a practice’s website, and if they don’t get the answer they need quickly, they’re likely to pick up the phone instead. Similarly, when patient questions become complex or sensitive, such as checking appointment availability across multiple locations or resolving billing issues, chatbots often require handoff to a team member. This creates additional work for staff and introduces operational challenges, especially during peak hours or when staffing is limited.
Chatbots cannot make it easier for patients to access your practice by phone. They aren’t integrated with your phone systems, and they can’t answer or route incoming calls. In other words, they don’t reduce inbound call volumes, and for patients who prefer to pick up the phone, they offer no support at all.
AI Voice Agents: The Future of Patient Support
AI phone call bots are built with natural language processing to handle live phone calls. Unlike IVRs or chatbots, they’re voice-first, context-aware, and programmed to complete tasks, not just collect inputs. Speaking with an AI call answering service is like interacting with a digital front desk team member. These AI call bots respond instantly with a conversational, human-like voice, understand complex patient questions, and continually adapt to the way people actually speak, regardless of speed, tone, or phrasing. Whether it’s a parent calling during their lunch break to reschedule their child’s appointment or a new patient inquiring about office locations at 10 PM, the patient experience is efficient and intuitive, and available around the clock.
What’s more, AI phone bots route patient calls correctly on the first try and escalate complex calls to staff who are better equipped to service them. This not only saves staff the time of manual transfers, but it also greatly enhances patient satisfaction.
By replacing outdated menus and long hold times with responsive, task-completing conversations, AI phone assistants transform the way patients access care and give staff time back to focus on more valuable tasks. For many practices, this type of AI call bot is the missing link to streamlining front-desk operations, without expanding call center footprints.
Comparing AI Healthcare Communication Tools
| Feature | IVR | Chatbot | AI Voice Agent |
| Patient experience | Menu navigation | Typing | Natural conversation |
| Supports live voice conversations | ✗ | ✗ | ✅ |
| 24/7 availability | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ |
| Phone integration | ✅ | ✗ | ✅ |
| Automates tasks | ✗ | ✅ | ✅ |
| Scales for peak volume | ✗ | ✅ | ✅ |
| Replaces hold times | ✗ | ✗ | ✅ |
| Supports staff efficiency | ✗ | ✅ | ✅ |
The bottom line: Only an AI voice agent combines real-time voice automation, intelligent decision-making, and seamless phone integration to truly modernize phone operations.
Meet Zo: Zocdoc’s AI Voice Agent
At Zocdoc, we’re dedicated to helping millions of patients find and book care. This gives us a unique lens into provider and patient needs and pain points. We built our AI phone assistant, Zo, specifically for healthcare practices.
Unlike generic phone bots, Zo is designed to handle healthcare’s complexity with speed, accuracy, and nuance. It can collect insurance, follow your unique scheduling rules across providers and locations, and integrate seamlessly with EHRs like Athena, ModMed, AdvancedMD, and more.
What makes Zo different:
-
- Engages like a human: Conversational, friendly, and context-aware
- Answers on the first ring: Handles unlimited calls, instantly
- Reduces staff burden: Resolves up to 70% of scheduling calls without human involvement
- Fast and frustration-free: No menus, no hold times
- Customizable: Works with your practice’s scheduling rules
- Seamless integration: Integrates with your phone systems and EHRs
- Smart escalation: Routes sensitive or complex issues directly to staff
- Trusted at scale: One integration powers everywhere patients search
- High patient satisfaction: Patients say it’s “easy to use,” “fast,” and “natural sounding”
Whether you’re seeing call volumes spike on Monday mornings or need after-hours coverage, phone answering services like Zo help practices meet demand, without increasing payroll. The best part? Patients love it. Zo maintains a CSAT score of 83, with patients praising its swiftness, precision, and lifelike voice.
Ready to modernize your phone operations?
Learn how Zo can help your practice
FAQs
What makes an AI voice agent different from a chatbot or IVR?
AI voice agents like Zo go far beyond text-based chatbots or rigid, scripted IVR menus. AI phone answering services like Zo offer a natural, real-time phone experience 24/7 –– no hold music, no pressing buttons. Built to understand conversational speech (and adapt to different accents and phrases), they can complete tasks like scheduling appointments or collecting insurance more efficiently, without human intervention.
Can an AI phone bot really reduce staff workload?
Not all conversational AI is created equal, which is why it’s important to validate performance. A recent study comparing Zo to other AI agents found that Zo converted new patient calls to appointments at a rate of 50.9%, far outpacing the competition. Zo handles up to 70% of routine scheduling calls without human involvement, freeing up front-desk staff to focus on more complex patient needs. This not only boosts team efficiency but also helps practices scale without expanding call center capacity.
Is an AI call answering service secure enough for healthcare?
Yes, if it’s built specifically for healthcare privacy and adheres to the strictest compliance standards. Zo is HIPAA-compliant, SOC 2 certified, and uses enterprise-grade encryption, ensuring every patient interaction is protected.
How does Zo handle complex or sensitive patient questions?
Zo is trained to know its limits and when human escalation is essential. If the AI answering service is asked a question outside its scope –– such as a billing dispute or medical advice request –– it automatically escalates the call to the appropriate staff member. This ensures patients always get the right level of support as fast as possible.
Does Zo work with my practice’s existing systems?
Zo is built for fast, seamless deployment. It integrates with your existing phone systems and EHRs like Athena, ModMed, AdvancedMD and more
What makes Zo different from other phone answering systems?
Zo is an AI voice agent that understands medical terminology and healthcare nuances. It’s customizable to your practice’s scheduling rules and preferences, like which providers serve which locations, their in-network insurances, and the length of time required for each appointment.