Browse specialtiesSee all specialties A-Z
Chiropractors
Dentists
Dermatologists
Ear, Nose & Throat Doctors
Endocrinologists
Eye Doctors
OBGYNs
Ophthalmologists
Optometrists
Orthopedic Surgeons
Podiatrists
Primary Care Doctors
Psychiatrists
Psychologists
Therapist-Counselors
Discover
Are you a top doctor or health service?
For providers
Discover
Are you a top doctor or health service?
Keatley Medical Nutrition Therapy
4.79
Patient reviews
All reviews have been submitted by patients after interacting with the practice.
Overall rating
4.79
Wait time
4.90
Bedside manner
4.83
Insurances accepted
99% of patients have successfully booked with these insurances
Aetna
BlueCross BlueShield
Cigna
Emblem Health
Medicare
Book an appointment for freeThe office partners with Zocdoc to schedule appointments
Scheduling details
All procedures
See if they’re in-network
Available appointments
All provider availability
Keatley Medical Nutrition Therapy
596 Broadway, Ste 302, New York, NY 10012
Today, Aug 26 – Tue, Sep 8
Insurances accepted
99% of patients have successfully booked with these insurancesAetnaBlueCross BlueShieldCignaEmblem HealthMedicare
1 office location
Providers at Keatley Medical Nutrition Therapy (0)
No results
This practice has no doctors that match your search criteria.
Keatley Medical Nutrition Therapy
Keatley Medical Nutrition Therapy (Keatley MNT) is a clinical nutrition practice specializing in conditions where nutrition plays a central role in treatment and management, including obesity, diabetes, prediabetes, hypertension, high cholesterol, metabolic syndrome, and heart health. Our focus is on improving metabolic and cardiometabolic health through Medical Nutrition Therapy (MNT), patient education, and sustainable lifestyle strategies.
We believe nutrition care is most effective when it is evidence-based, collaborative, and centered around the patient’s goals and daily reality. Every individual arrives with different health challenges, cultural backgrounds, and lifestyle constraints—and our care model honors that complexity.
Our Mission
Our mission is to help patients understand and benefit from targeted nutrition interventions that improve health, support chronic disease management, and reduce long-term risk. We apply the best available scientific evidence, align treatment plans with patient goals, and support readiness for change.
We recognize that meaningful progress requires not only clinical guidance, but also education, practical tools, and behavioral support. For that reason, we emphasize:
• Evidence-based treatment plans
• Patient participation in decision-making
• Self-management skills
• Sustainable lifestyle strategies
• Long-term health outcomes
Achieving nutrition-related goals is a team effort, and patients are considered active partners in their care.
How We Approach Nutrition Care
At Keatley MNT, we use Medical Nutrition Therapy (MNT), which includes:
Assessment – reviewing labs, health history, medications, dietary patterns, symptoms, and lifestyle factors.
Diagnosis & Intervention – identifying nutrition problems and developing individualized treatment plans.
Monitoring & Evaluation – adjusting strategies over time and measuring progress through clinical and behavioral outcomes.
This clinical approach is supported by education and counseling, so patients understand not just what to do, but why certain strategies work and how to implement them sustainably.
Conditions We Specialize In
We commonly support patients with:
• Obesity & weight management
• Diabetes (Type 1, Type 2, Prediabetes)
• Metabolic syndrome
• Hypertension
• High cholesterol / dyslipidemia
• Heart disease / cardiometabolic risk
• Fatty liver disease (NAFLD)
• PCOS-related metabolic concerns
• Emotional or behavioral eating patterns
What to Expect During Visits
Initial Visits focus on understanding your medical history, symptoms, labs, medications, eating patterns, and daily lifestyle. We discuss goals and create a starting plan aligned with your health priorities.
Follow-Up Visits focus on adjusting strategies, reviewing obstacles, integrating education, and building sustainable habits over time. Chronic conditions often require multiple visits to ensure long-term improvement.
Our Care Philosophy
We believe patients benefit most from care that is:
Evidence-Based — grounded in current scientific research, not fad diets or misinformation.
Personalized — tailored to medical needs, cultural preferences, and daily life.
Empowering — built on education and skills, not restriction or shame.
Collaborative — often coordinated with primary care, cardiology, or endocrinology teams.
Sustainable — focused on long-term success rather than quick fixes.
Our Clinical Provider
Keatley MNT is led by Scott Keatley, MPPD, RD, CDN, FAND, a Registered Dietitian-Nutritionist and Fellow of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics.
Scott has extensive experience in obesity management, diabetes care, and cardiometabolic health, and has provided nutrition expertise across clinical, digital health, and media environments. He values clinical accuracy, clear communication, and patient-centered care.
Patient-Centered, Evidence-Based Nutrition Care
Patients often come to Keatley MNT because:
• They want help managing a chronic medical condition
• Their physician recommended Medical Nutrition Therapy
• They have tried general nutrition advice without results
• They are confused by conflicting diet information online
• They want clear, science-based guidance they can trust
• They are ready to build healthier habits for the long term
Our goal is to provide clarity, confidence, and clinical support in an area where misinformation is common and personalization matters.
Education & Self-Management
A core part of our mission is to provide education and tools so patients can better understand:
• how nutrition affects their condition
• what changes matter most for their goals
• how to navigate real-world eating situations
• how to build habits that last
We believe sustainable progress happens when patients feel informed, understood, and supported.
Patient reviews
All reviews have been submitted by patients after interacting with the practice.
Overall rating
4.79
Wait time
4.90
Bedside manner
4.83
Your trust is our top concern, so providers can't pay to alter or remove reviews. We also don't publish reviews that contain any private patient health information. Learn more here
387 reviews
Most relevant
Super knowledgeable about how to gradually & tweak your eating habits to make a life long change for a healthier lifestyle!
March 16, 2022Initials hidden
I received a lot of information from her I did not know, and she seems to want me to win.
March 6, 2024Selena W.Verified patient
My first session was great. A plan was put in motion and I’m excited for my next visit.
January 17, 2024Briana A.Verified patient
Dr Keatley is so kind, looking forward to seeing her again.
October 8, 2020Meranda S.Verified patient
He was very insightful and didn’t make me feel bad with my diets. If anything told me that I can do better and showed me how.
August 19, 2024Chelsea A.Verified patient
Like all the other reviews, I wasn’t sent an email for the video call and when I call the office, there was no help
February 25, 2025Alana P.Verified patient
Professional and empathic. Great find. Would absolutely recommend him for people who want a sustainable approach to health.
TBVerified patient
Professional and empathic. Great find. Would absolutely recommend him for people who want a sustainable approach to health.
TBVerified patient
He was very informative and friendly, he also listened and I didn't feel rushed at all. I really enjoyed my appointment.
January 11, 2021Initials hidden
Loved Dr. Keatly! He is very I formative, friendly, and has some really great approaches. I'd highly recommend.
June 24, 2023Erica C.Verified patient
First time video visit, he cares so much about his patient. I know I won't regret my weight loss journey
October 28, 2020Sarata T.Verified patient
Very friendly, very informative, great listener
Would recommend to others
July 15, 2025Initials hidden
Great communicator gave me great advice to move forward
February 18, 2026Initials hidden
Great dietitian! He very professionally saved my fathers life! Im very happy we chose to go to Mr Scott!
LPVerified patient
Don’t recommend, poor communication, doctor did not log on for scheduled appointment.
July 26, 2024Ochienzes G.Verified patient
Scott was such a pleasure to meet with. He is open, relatable, and made my visit quite fun!
October 26, 2022Natasha S.Verified patient
Scott is a top referral for my psychotherapy clients. He is thorough and compassionate.
MRVerified patient
Very knowledgeable. Clear communication. Attainable personalized goals.
May 24, 2024Alcides E.Verified patient
fantastic! I learned more in an hour than I'd learned in a lifetime.
May 30, 2024Jacques S.Verified patient
Easy to talk and gave me actionable tips to address my concerns
August 26, 2024Maryann K.Verified patient
Original review: Ummm… he kinda dosnt listen and he steamrolls you so that he can prescribe you with the plan he makes everyone go on. It’s very basic and not very helpful at all. He kinda talks down to you. Save your money and go on YouTube for better advice.
Edit: He unexpectedly called my personal phone weeks after I left this original review. He wanted me to go back to ZocDoc and change my review. He was clearly upset and claimed that he never steam rolled me. He also was upset claiming that there was no diet for Lyme disease (one of my conditions) which isn’t even true. Also, my main concern was a diet for PCOS and that was never addressed (which there are diets for). His original plan was that I should just use my plate, divide it in sections and make sure I had carbs, fiber, protein. (Which was entirely unhelpful because I could do that myself with the help of YouTube). I was so uncomfortable that he called me over a month after the appointment. Harassment behavior.
June 19, 2026Mackenzie P.Verified patient
Before my appointment, they contacted me by email to collect my information, including my weight and other detailed information. I filled out the forms and also provided my insurance information.
Then, shortly before the appointment time, I received a reminder message. After that, I waited for the appointment and expected to receive a link. I also downloaded the app they asked me to use.
My appointment was scheduled for 1:00 PM, but no one showed up or contacted me until 2:00 PM. I then called their office again and informed them about the situation.
No consultation took place at all. I simply ended up wasting my time.
May 26, 2026Gaye Nur K.Verified patient
Great personality, easy to talk to and get along with. Explained all the answers to my questions in ways that were easy to understand.
May 22, 2026Courtney S.Verified patient
He was so kind and saw me despite insurance mix up. He was willing to come on and explain he couldn’t accept my insurance and still gave me a free consultation with free advice. Great guy.
May 8, 2026Naomi S.Verified patient
This was my first virtual appointment. It was amazing. I was surprised on how well it went and I can see myself preferring virtual to in person. The provider was amazing. Thank you.
May 4, 2026Christine H.Verified patient
It was a video visit and the dietician was very informative. The only slight hiccup was that when I signed up it said that it took my health insurance. Since my digestive issues were not due to diabeties the insurance company would not cover it. Fortunately, the doctor's rate was reasonable. Rather than have a full session I was given things to do such as keep a photo journal and we would have a full session in a few weeks.
April 21, 2026Heidi G.Verified patient
He gets it - Scott was really great at finding the limits of my own knowledge and filling in those gaps well. He has a great approach.
January 12, 2026Jesus V.Verified patient
Very positive interesting and I learned a lot
May 5, 2025Joan A.Verified patient
Very knowledgeable and insightful on what my major concerns were. Provided me with the ease that I will meet my goals. Very happy I met with him.
April 3, 2025Angelica W.Verified patient
Excellent experience.
February 14, 2025Kathryn C.Verified patient
I never received a video link and did not have an appointment. The phone number did not work and my email was not responded to.
January 21, 2025Adam A.Verified patient
I always get a great experience with him.
January 13, 2025Christine T.Verified patient
Never received login information for the scheduled call. Called the office to ask for login information and never received any communication.
Initials hidden
Terrible experience! Had booked days in advance, took time off work and never got a call or a video link from them for the appointment. Called the practice 4 times and all they can say is “ we can ping the doctor, but thats all we can do”.
November 7, 2024Initials hidden
He is very personable and humorous. It made the appointment that much more enjoyable and allowed for more comfortable conversation. He’s thorough in his explanations, which are easy to understand, and makes the journey to building towards a better healthy lifestyle that much easier and more attainable. Highly recommend!
September 25, 2024Sofia R.Verified patient
They canceled my appointment two days before.
September 14, 2024Shirin M.Verified patient
So far I’m loving the service I’m being provided. Dr. Keatley is smart kind and patient. I’ve struggled with food for many years but I’m hopeful that will change now that we’re working together.
August 21, 2024Lillian Q.Verified patient
I made an online appointment but never received a link to join the meeting so I called the office and spoke to someone who said he would have Scott paged and reach out since my appointment was supposed to be starting, but no one called or sent me an email link. VERY unprofessional.
August 8, 2024Jodi J.Verified patient
Scott has absolutely a lovely personality and makes everything easy to understand. He is patient and caring about your needs. I had already a consultation session and a follow up and I’ve been happy getting help from him.
I definitely recommend him
May 26, 2024Tanaz D.Verified patient
The doctor was so personable, knowledgeable, and productive.
She is not only a very good dietitian but a great individual.
August 17, 2021Michael B.Verified patient
Colleen is lovely and supportive. I look forward to continuing to work together on my wellness lifestyle changes.
October 15, 2021Lauren G.Verified patient
Love her- very professional and knowledge dietician/nutritionist! Looking forward to our next session!
March 2, 2023Aisha R.Verified patient
A wonderful initial appointment! I’m so excited to continue to work with Colleen.
November 24, 2020Mazal B.Verified patient
Fantastic & very knowledgeable about all topics in relation to various foods.
April 21, 2022Angelo P.Verified patient
She was so understanding and so friendly is making my journey filled with joy
May 8, 2021Sunny A.Verified patient
Friendly and welcoming. Looking forward to my next appt
September 11, 2021Heather L.Verified patient
Great nutrition advice and great bedside manner!!
December 15, 2021Victoria S.Verified patient
Very nice !
October 21, 2024Tanaea N.Verified patient
Dr. Colleen McGibney was amazing. She listened, was insightful, great interpersonal skills, very down to earth and a clear communicator. She gave valuable suggestions and advice based upon the information provided. I would definitely recommend her.
August 15, 2024Tyheesha R.Verified patient
Colleen was pleasant and knowledgeable. She asked the right questions, listened to me intently and offered her expert opinion. I came away from my appointment with a much more thorough understanding of those concrete things I can do to change my health. There were a few questions she said she would have to research further, and she did and she sent me the results of her research that same evening! She's an excellent dietitian!
Initials hidden
Loading...