Browse specialtiesSee all specialties A-Z
Chiropractors
Dentists
Dermatologists
Ear, Nose & Throat Doctors
Endocrinologists
Eye Doctors
OBGYNs
Ophthalmologists
Optometrists
Orthopedic Surgeons
Podiatrists
Primary Care Doctors
Psychiatrists
Psychologists
Therapist-Counselors
Discover
Are you a top doctor or health service?
Discover
Are you a top doctor or health service?
Natalie Gayle Psychiatric NP
Adult Psychiatric & Mental Health Nurse Practitioner555 Broadhollow Road, Melville, NY4.83
Patient reviews
All reviews have been submitted by patients after interacting with the practice.
Overall rating
4.83
Wait time
4.96
Bedside manner
4.81
Insurances accepted
99% of patients have successfully booked with these insurances
Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts
Cigna
UnitedHealthcare Oxford
Aetna
Oscar Health Insurance Co.
Book an appointment for freeThe office partners with Zocdoc to schedule appointments
Scheduling details
All procedures
See if they’re in-network
Available appointments
All provider availability
Natalie Gayle Psychiatric NP
555 Broadhollow Road, Ste. 305, Melville, NY 11747
All provider availabilityToday, Apr 3 – Thu, Apr 16
Insurances accepted
99% of patients have successfully booked with these insurancesBlue Cross Blue Shield of MassachusettsCignaUnitedHealthcare OxfordAetnaOscar Health Insurance Co.
1 office location
Providers at Natalie Gayle Psychiatric NP (0)
No results
This practice has no doctors that match your search criteria.
Patient reviews
All reviews have been submitted by patients after interacting with the practice.
Overall rating
4.83
Wait time
4.96
Bedside manner
4.81
Your trust is our top concern, so providers can't pay to alter or remove reviews. We also don't publish reviews that contain any private patient health information. Learn more here
29 reviews
Most relevant
Dr. Gayle is extremely knowledgable and easy to talk to. I would highly recommend her to all new patients!
JDVerified patient
Nataly is empathetic and professional
Very knowledgeable and understanding of our mental struggles
EBVerified patient
Just didn’t listen to my needs .. cut me off Everytime I spoke .. would not recommend
Initials hidden
good recommendations.
Initials hidden
Our appointment went very smoothly. The staff were very nice. The communication prior to the appointment was thorough and clear. Natalie Gail was very nice, professional, and she had a kind and fun manner with our daughter. We feel very fortunate to have found this healthcare provider! Highly recommended!!
November 24, 2025Kimberly W.Verified patient
Natalie Gayle, NP, is excellent! Very professional, yet warm and easy to talk to. She took her time and really explained everything clearly. You can tell she puts her patients first. I highly recommend her if you're looking for quality, compassionate care.
MCVerified patient
I thought that my first visit went splendidly. Dr. Gayle spent the time to not only understand my history but also to listen to what really was happening to me that day. She got to know me and what my goals were for medication and therapy. I’m very happy to have her as my provider.
PGVerified patient
"She is very smart and has excellent knowledge of psychiatry and psychotherapy. I highly recommend her. Her approach to patients is thoughtful, professional, and deeply informed."
ARVerified patient
Ms. Gayle is patient and understanding. She knows her stuff and is easy to talk to. I appreciate her open mindedness and ability to be compassionate about situations. Highly recommend. I also like the fact that she is reliable and responsive.
AHVerified patient
Although I filled out the intake forms twice, they were not in the system. There was also a mix-up about which “waiting room” I was in, so our meeting started 10 minutes late. The entire session consisted of the therapist’s asking me the same questions from the intake forms and entering them herself. There was no personal connection, nor did she even finish all the questions. Natalie Gayle seems like a warm and compassionate woman, and I considered going for a subsequent in-person visit, but when she told me we would be finishing the intake forms at that time, I declined. For me, the fact that paperwork outweighs personal connection makes it quite clear, I will never again search for a therapist (or any doctor) on Zocdoc.
Susan S.Verified patient
Dr Gayle is very attentive to your needs and I especially like that she always asks how you would like to proceed. I felt heard at every appointment.
KJVerified patient
Natalie changed my life! She is a great listener and has changed my life for the better. She has allowed me time to express my feelings and concerns. She is an excellent provider! 10/10 recommend!
CGVerified patient
Natalie changed my life! She helped me and she is a great listener. She has allowed me time to express my feelings and concerns. She is an excellent provider! 10/10 recommend!
CGVerified patient
Ms. Gayle is caring, and thorough, she is patient, knowledgeable and attentive to my needs. Easy to talk to. She has made a significant impact on improving my symptoms.
Would strongly recommend for anxiety.
JGVerified patient
I highly recommend Natalie Gayle! She is incredibly attentive, knowledgeable about medications and mental health conditions, and always takes the time to listen and address my concerns. I feel completely comfortable and supported during our sessions, and her expertise has made a real difference in my care.
KPVerified patient
Natalie is an excellent NP. She has helped me tremendously and I’m grateful to have her as my NP. Her professionalism, knowledge of the field and overall positivity, makes me look forward to each of our sessions. I have made great progress in the time that Natalie has been my NP and I owe it to her expertise. Natalie is also highly empathetic and thorough in her treatment approach. I would strongly recommend her!
ASVerified patient
Nathalie is very experienced and knowledgeable. She really cares about my wellbeing. I am very grateful for her accuracy and ability to make decisions that are meaningful for my health.
JMVerified patient
February 22, 2026Kesha-Monique C.Verified patient
Initials hidden
Initials hidden
November 30, 2025Nancy B.Verified patient
November 25, 2025Elizabeth D.Verified patient
November 17, 2025Vineeth R.Verified patient
September 13, 2025Karen T.Verified patient
Initials hidden
June 16, 2025Emilio D.Verified patient
May 19, 2025Edren W.Verified patient
April 30, 2025Kymberly S.Verified patient
Victor T.Verified patient