Browse specialtiesSee all specialties A-Z
Chiropractors
Dentists
Dermatologists
Ear, Nose & Throat Doctors
Endocrinologists
Eye Doctors
OBGYNs
Ophthalmologists
Optometrists
Orthopedic Surgeons
Podiatrists
Primary Care Doctors
Psychiatrists
Psychologists
Therapist-Counselors
Discover
Are you a top doctor or health service?
Discover
Are you a top doctor or health service?
Sicklerville Smiles
2 specialties423 Sicklerville Rd, Winslow Township, NJ4.88
Patient reviews
All reviews have been submitted by patients after interacting with the practice.
Overall rating
4.88
Wait time
4.89
Bedside manner
4.96
Insurances accepted
99% of patients have successfully booked with these insurances
Aetna
Cigna
Delta Dental
UnitedHealthcare
Book an appointment for freeThe office partners with Zocdoc to schedule appointments
Scheduling details
All procedures
See if they’re in-network
Available appointments
All provider availability
All provider availabilityToday, Apr 4 – Fri, Apr 17
Insurances accepted
99% of patients have successfully booked with these insurancesAetnaCignaDelta DentalUnitedHealthcare
1 office location
Providers at Sicklerville Smiles (0)
No results
This practice has no doctors that match your search criteria.
Sicklerville Smiles
At Sicklerville Smiles, we understand that dental care is about more than just procedures—it’s about building lasting relationships with our patients. We are committed to providing personalized care to help you achieve and maintain a healthy, beautiful smile for life.
Our office is designed to be a warm and welcoming environment where you can feel at ease. From the moment you walk through our doors, you’ll experience our dedication to making your visit as comfortable and stress-free as possible. We offer a variety of amenities to help you relax, such as a cozy blanket to snuggle up with, Bose noise cancellation headphones to block out noise, a warm lavender-scented moist towel to refresh your face and hands, and a coffee bar where you can grab a cup of coffee or tea to go. These thoughtful amenities are just a few of the ways we strive to make every visit to Sicklerville Smiles a comfortable and stress-free experience. We also believe in providing our patients with the latest dental technology and techniques to ensure they receive the highest standard of care.
Patient reviews
All reviews have been submitted by patients after interacting with the practice.
Overall rating
4.88
Wait time
4.89
Bedside manner
4.96
Your trust is our top concern, so providers can't pay to alter or remove reviews. We also don't publish reviews that contain any private patient health information. Learn more here
96 reviews
Most relevant
Great office, smooth process for all of the procedures I had, and AMAZING staff! Highly recommend!
AWVerified patient
Everyone in the office was friendly. Appreciated the kindness. They couldn't have been nicer if they tried.
December 15, 2025Valerie M.Verified patient
Amazing so thorough and gentle it was a great experience Dr. Modesto is the best of the best!
TSVerified patient
This place is great! Everyone is so friendly and communicated every step during the procedure.
CHVerified patient
The doctor was wonderful, I love this office. I was seeing quickly and efficiently. It was painless and a great experience.
January 31, 2025Maria Z.Verified patient
Amazing bed side manner and one of the softest touches of a dentist I’ve ever had !
ILVerified patient
Wonderful visit! The team was so kind and talked me through every step. So glad I found them on Zocdoc!
MMVerified patient
Great friendly staff very nice place over all, will be going back !
Amanda R.Verified patient
The staff and the dentist were very professional. I have found my new dentist
WBVerified patient
Highly recommend, very friendly staff, felt extremely comfortable.
November 6, 2024Marie J.Verified patient
Perfect dentist experience! Clean office and gentle kind and efficient staff!
January 22, 2024Maria Z.Verified patient
Staff was very nice, understanding and helpful to my needs.
BTVerified patient
Doctor and staff were professional and very friendly.
July 1, 2024Stephenie K.Verified patient
Trudy and Dr. Isaac were fabulous! Great experience.
BBVerified patient
Went well. Informed of the whole process. Pain free.
GMVerified patient
Staff are very nice and professional
JFVerified patient
10 out of 10! I’m so happy I came across this Dentist on ZocDoc. The staff were extremely friendly and the Dr was exceptional.
December 9, 2025Regina B.Verified patient
Dr Modesto, Jillian and Devaughn (sorry if misspelt) have calmed my anxiety through each step of getting my dental health back in order. I went from major anxiety to tapping along with the soft music!
SWVerified patient
Extremely happy with my experience at this practice! The whole staff was very friendly and professional from the moment I walked in. The office was very clean and had a comfortable waiting area. Didn’t have to wait more than a few mins before being taken back for my exam. Jillian and Dr Modesto were very personable and made my overall appointment very easy and pleasant. I will definitely be recommending this practice!
October 11, 2025Joseph P.Verified patient
I’ve been going to Sicklerville Smiles for a while now, and I even take my mom! Dr. Modesto is so kind, patient, and professional. The whole team is friendly, the office is spotless, and they always send helpful reminders. I also love the warm towel they offer at the end—it’s such a thoughtful touch that makes every visit feel special.
BRVerified patient
Excellent experience ??
September 29, 2025kevin S.Verified patient
It was just an overall WONDERFUL experience. I was very nervous and anxious about my oral situation and they didn't make me feel terrible about it and was very casual and positive about my dental plan, moving forward. Very awesome.
September 25, 2025Terrence W.Verified patient
Super helpful and kind staff, I needed a last minute dental exam for a pre employment job qualification and they were able to see me right away
September 16, 2025Isaac L.Verified patient
Staff was very welcoming, and did excellent work on my daughters teeth, even saved one from a root canal, different from a prior dentist, it looks great and was on a front tooth can’t tell at all
August 28, 2025Alayna S.Verified patient
I lucked up and found a great dentist and office. My first visit was exceptional with Dr Modesto! All of the staff was great!
July 31, 2025Sherri G.Verified patient
Such an amazing experience, Dr. Modesto and entire staff were so friendly and helpful! They were also very professional and I could tell they genuinely cared about me. It was my very first appointment, I was able to get my x-rays done, cleaning, retainer cleaned, 5 cavities filled, and my teeth whitened in less than 2 hours! Will definitely be back in 6 months!
June 30, 2025Alexis H.Verified patient
Such an amazing experience, Dr. Modesto and entire staff were so friendly and helpful! They were also very professional and I could tell they genuinely cared about me. It was my very first appointment, I was able to get my x-rays done, cleaning, retainer cleaned, 5 cavities filled, and my teeth whitened in less than 2 hours! Will definitely be back in 6 months!
AHVerified patient
Dr. Modesto was so kind. She was very efficient in my care, explaining every step along the way. Everyone from the front office team to the dental assistant were so nice and welcoming. Highly recommend!!
CPVerified patient
I have seen Dr. Isaac for all of my appointments, he makes you feel very comfortable. Staff is very friendly and helpful. Highly recommended!
January 13, 2025Marie J.Verified patient
It was a great experience
September 16, 2024Caurice C.Verified patient
Theywere amaing and did everything I wanted
RCVerified patient
Takes concerns seriously, a rare trait.
July 29, 2024Joana R.Verified patient
Trudy and Dr. Isaac were great!
Initials hidden
My visit was great. All of the staff were very professional and pleasant. The environment was very clean and my wait time was less than 5 minutes. I would recommend this practice if one is looking for a new dentist.
MRVerified patient
It was one of the best experiences Ive had in a dentist office in a long time. The entire team was friendly and professional from the start. I could not recommend Dr. Modesto and her team enough!
MBVerified patient
Great office Great people. I was afraid of the dentist because they always talked down to me about my teeth. The doctors were great Trudy and Issac were fantastic. The front desk made sure they were clear about cost. Couldn’t have been better.
June 20, 2024Marcus T.Verified patient
I’ve aways been afraid of dentists. I can’t say enough great thins about my entire experience at Sicklerville Smiles. I’d highly recommend them to everyone
AAVerified patient
Wonerful experience
VKVerified patient
It was a great experience! I was super nervous to come to a dentist after years, but they were so accommodating and comforting.
BBVerified patient
I made an appointment to see Dr. Modesto but ended up seeing one of their colleagues instead who was professional and reasonably communicative about issues I came in with. The practice as a whole was wonderful though. Everyone was very nice, communicated who they were and what they were doing. The hygienist was incredible, she was very thorough and addressed all my issues. I felt very comfortable here and confident I was in good hands.
AGVerified patient
It was great! The staff was friendly and extremely pleasant. Today was my first day as their patient and they were just the upgrade I needed. They were informative and I am thankful to have such an amazing new dentist!
TJVerified patient
Dr. Modesto and her team are all amazing! They all make you feel very welcomed and the atmosphere is nothing short of peaceful.
March 14, 2024Dejhanae T.Verified patient
Greet
JMVerified patient
Very kind and straight to the point, told me what I needed and was easy to communicate with! Highly recommend this location and this doctor :)
March 4, 2024Initials hidden
Great dentist
February 4, 2024Tyrone M.Verified patient
Its excellent words can't explain.
TMVerified patient
10/10
HKVerified patient
Nice and friendly staff
SHVerified patient
Welcoming environment. Comfortable waiting room and friendly staff!
The cleaning was quick and the Dr was thorough and understanding of my needs.
Initials hidden
March 30, 2026Melanie W.Verified patient
Loading...