Browse specialtiesSee all specialties A-Z
Chiropractors
Dentists
Dermatologists
Ear, Nose & Throat Doctors
Endocrinologists
Eye Doctors
OBGYNs
Ophthalmologists
Optometrists
Orthopedic Surgeons
Podiatrists
Primary Care Doctors
Psychiatrists
Psychologists
Therapist-Counselors
Discover
Are you a top doctor or health service?
For providers
Discover
Are you a top doctor or health service?
Suffolk Foot & Ankle
4.95
Patient reviews
All reviews have been submitted by patients after interacting with the practice.
Overall rating
4.95
Wait time
4.80
Bedside manner
4.99
Insurances accepted
99% of patients have successfully booked with these insurances
Aetna
BlueCross BlueShield
Cigna
Medicare
UnitedHealthcare
Book an appointment for freeThe office partners with Zocdoc to schedule appointments
Scheduling details
All procedures
See if they’re in-network
Available appointments
All provider availability
Today, Aug 31 – Sun, Sep 13
Insurances accepted
99% of patients have successfully booked with these insurancesAetnaBlueCross BlueShieldCignaMedicareUnitedHealthcare
1 office location
Providers at Suffolk Foot & Ankle (0)
No results
This practice has no doctors that match your search criteria.
Suffolk Foot & Ankle
TO ALL PATIENTS- When Booking An Appointment Please Provide A Copy Of Your Insurance Card To Help Speed Up The Process Of Confirming Your Appointment. If you choose not to upload your insurance card you risk losing the appointment. Thank You!
Patient reviews
All reviews have been submitted by patients after interacting with the practice.
Overall rating
4.95
Wait time
4.80
Bedside manner
4.99
Your trust is our top concern, so providers can't pay to alter or remove reviews. We also don't publish reviews that contain any private patient health information. Learn more here
139 reviews
Most relevant
The time the medical assistant took to fit me with the correct cam boot was awesome ??
Initials hidden
Very good experience . My first time but I was very happy with my experience
January 20, 2026Robert W.Verified patient
Dr. Zehentner was great! Quick and easy to schedule, no wait, and very professional!
Will definitely be returning.
March 30, 2023Sophia D.Verified patient
Five Stars. On time. Knowledgeable. Friendly. Why can't all doctors be this good?
August 19, 2025Michelle H.Verified patient
Highly recommend, very knowledgeable and happy with my diagnosis and treatment plan.
June 17, 2025David K.Verified patient
Very friendly and helpful Doctor! Highly recommend for anyone seeking any type of medical help with their feet.
July 25, 2022Bethany F.Verified patient
He was very attentive and genuinely concerned. He spent a lot of time and answered all my questions.
RSVerified patient
Dr. was very attentive. Listened to my concerns. Thorough examination. Little to no wait time.
KEVerified patient
Great cool Doctor and is willing to help and get your feet neat again just perfect.
August 15, 2022Jose C.Verified patient
Quick, friendly and clean. X-rays on spot and clear directions on treatment.
November 2, 2022Joe F.Verified patient
I was greeted, paid my copay and I was only sitting maybe 2 minutes when I was called into a room. I was seen by the nurse and shortly there after by the doctor. The office was nice and clean. The staff was nice as well
July 30, 2026Frederick S.Verified patient
I liked everything; everyone was very kind and helpful with my needs. I was very happy, and the doctor was very nice and friendly.
January 29, 2026Cinthia P.Verified patient
Was able to get an appointment for the next day and when arrived at office I had minimal wait time. The Dr was very thorough and diagnosed and corrected the problem. I would definitely go back.
December 19, 2025Demetria P.Verified patient
Office scheduling is well managed and I have typically been seen within 5 minutes of scheduled appointment time. Dr. Zehentner has been helpful with asking good questions as well as answering mine. He’s also been helpful with explanations about causes for my issue and remedies to address them. I highly recommend the practice and him in particular.
JMVerified patient
Friendly office staff, practically no wait time, thorough treatment by Dr. Karlic. I enjoy coming here!
LMVerified patient
Real down to earth staff & doctor.
Friendly & make you feel at ease.
Glad I went with them
August 11, 2025John V.Verified patient
Amazing experience! Very happy. Very attentive and friendly staff. Wonderful experience.
August 12, 2025Anthony D.Verified patient
Very nice office doctor was very friendly and took care of my issue immediately
June 20, 2025Lisa C.Verified patient
Took the time to explain to
Her and She listened! Never felt rushed!
Initials hidden
Staff is friendly. The doctor is gentle. Didn’t have a long wait.
April 23, 2025Evelyn S.Verified patient
Beyond happy. Love Dr. Karlic, shes great and amazing.
JWVerified patient
Dr karlic is the best foot doctor on Long Island. The staff at Suffolk foot and ankle are very polite an efficient. Highly recommended
LCVerified patient
Very efficient, friendly office
February 3, 2026Initials hidden
The office & exam rooms are spotless.
The staff is very pleasant and friendly.
Dr. Karlic is a sweetheart. Listens and shows true concern for your issues. She is a people’s person.
Glad I found her.
November 13, 2025John V.Verified patient
Everyone that helped me today is so wonderful and Dr. Karlik helped me so much with my problem. this is my favorite practice to come to thank you very much
MFVerified patient
Courteous staff. Very brief wait time (less than 5 minutes). Dr. Karlic listened to everything that I had to say regarding my pain (as a new patient, there were no records to review) and together we came up with a treatment plan that I am on board with.
August 26, 2025Heather C.Verified patient
The staff are all 100% ready, willing, and able to assist however possible. No complaints! So happy to have found this provider!
Susan C.Verified patient
Highly recommend!! Wow! When I say the doctor was spot on I literally praised God I chose to see her! I wish I had come sooner! Not only does she know exactly what she is doing, she expressed love and compassion and was very kind! I’m so thankful!
August 12, 2025Yolanda D.Verified patient
Everything was fine. Quick & easy.
JLVerified patient
The best - Great doctor & staff.
JCVerified patient
Fast a great.
MWVerified patient
Staff was lovely and made my 8 year old daughter very comfortable. Dr Karlic was wonderful and explained everything thoroughly. Great experience!
IAVerified patient
Very helpful.
PFVerified patient
Comforting.
JDVerified patient
Karlic genuinely nears concerns addresses them quickly ang goes it with grace. Wonderful front staff consistantly as well. Love them.
JCVerified patient
Prompt, professional thorough.
JOVerified patient
As always fine.
PSVerified patient
Great, as usual. Very thorough.
FMVerified patient
Quick and effective.
CPVerified patient
Excellent care.
GMVerified patient
Nice friendly staff. Dr. Karlic is amazing.
MGVerified patient
It was excellent. Very thorough. Best doctor.
TLVerified patient
Fast/easy.
KDVerified patient
Great!
EZVerified patient
Quick & efficient.
SBVerified patient
She wonderful! The best foot Dr I've ever had!!
DTVerified patient
Dr Karli is amazing. I have had surgery with her three times and I can’t say enough about her. She definitely cares about her patience.I would highly recommend her.
DSVerified patient
Everyone in the office are wonderful, specially Irma at the front desk. Dr. Karlic is great Dr. helped me with my foot problem.
SMVerified patient
I sustained an ankle injury while training for a marathon and saw Dr. Karlic based on the recommendation of a friend. I couldn’t be more impressed with the care I received. Dr. Karlic was thorough, knowledgeable, and clearly explained my injury, treatment options and a recovery plan that worked for me, my training and my home/work life.
The entire staff was excellent—warm, professional, and incredibly personable from the moment I walked in. From the front desk to the medical assistants, everyone made the experience smooth as copied be. Highly recommend
July 16, 2025Brian C.Verified patient
It was great. Very fast & efficient.
CMVerified patient
Loading...