Browse specialtiesSee all specialties A-Z
Chiropractors
Dentists
Dermatologists
Ear, Nose & Throat Doctors
Endocrinologists
Eye Doctors
OBGYNs
Ophthalmologists
Optometrists
Orthopedic Surgeons
Podiatrists
Primary Care Doctors
Psychiatrists
Psychologists
Therapist-Counselors
Discover
Are you a top doctor or health service?
Discover
Are you a top doctor or health service?
Toothology
5 specialties42A Broadway, Brooklyn, NY4.79
Patient reviews
All reviews have been submitted by patients after interacting with the practice.
Overall rating
4.79
Wait time
4.82
Bedside manner
4.90
Insurances accepted
Aetna
Cigna
Metlife
Book an appointment for freeThe office partners with Zocdoc to schedule appointments
Scheduling details
All procedures
See if they’re in-network
Available appointments
All provider availability
Today, Apr 4 – Fri, Apr 17
Insurances acceptedAetnaCignaMetlife
1 office location
Providers at Toothology (0)
No results
This practice has no doctors that match your search criteria.
Patient reviews
All reviews have been submitted by patients after interacting with the practice.
Overall rating
4.79
Wait time
4.82
Bedside manner
4.90
Your trust is our top concern, so providers can't pay to alter or remove reviews. We also don't publish reviews that contain any private patient health information. Learn more here
255 reviews
Most relevant
Very professional, honest and does an amazing job. Never a wait time, always true to appointment time. Highly recommend him.
November 13, 2019Lizeth V.Verified patient
Incredible dentist, unbelievably kind and patient - as someone with anxiety his team made me feel so comfortable and safe
December 11, 2021Erin L.Verified patient
Skilled, friendly and helpful dentist.Tries his utmost to give best care possible. Best dentist I’ve ever been to.
June 24, 2020Initials hidden
Great visit!!! The doctor spends time with you and answers all your questions..
I knew I was in great hands!!
Initials hidden
Dr Shaffer made me feel completely relaxed. He explains everything and has alternative options for care.
Michele S.Verified patient
Michael and his partner Lauren are kind, caring and professional! I highly recommend Polished Dental Care!
July 20, 2021Stefanie G.Verified patient
I have dental anxiety so going to a new dentist is never easy, Dr. Shaffer was very nice and professional.
June 3, 2020Lauren G.Verified patient
Courteous, caring and extremely thorough! Dr. Shaffer takes great care to not make you feel like a number.
July 11, 2017Michele P.Verified patient
Excellent experience. He was so honest and personable. I am sending all my relatives to him!
September 7, 2022Chelsea B.Verified patient
I love Dr. Shaffer! He is professional, thorough and makes a trip to the dentist not a chore.
December 27, 2017Nicole6 O.Verified patient
Very caring upon pain ! Totally recommend if you don’t like pain and fast accurate results
November 7, 2018Diana L.Verified patient
Very nice and knowledgeable. He was recommended from a family member. I will return.
May 13, 2021Joseph W.Verified patient
By far the best dentist I’ve even been to. I highly recommended him to everyone.
Bheskar K.Verified patient
Best dentist ever! Was very patient and super helpful. Would highly recommend
December 16, 2019Surujpaul L.Verified patient
My cleaning was painless and thorough. I will definitely go back.
May 27, 2022Francesca D.Verified patient
he's awesome, you don't feel any pain while getting your teeth clean
July 31, 2019Megan C.Verified patient
Very professional and friendly team. Love them. Amazing doctor.
June 18, 2021Melina R.Verified patient
They send u a text messag to fill out paper work via link.
January 7, 2022Zeshan H.Verified patient
Professional, honest, informative
I would highly recommend!
October 2, 2020Michele R.Verified patient
He is the best doctor I’ve ever been to. Highly recommend
August 1, 2018John G.Verified patient
Very professional !
I highly recommend this place.
October 28, 2021Tiago P.Verified patient
Dr. Shaffer was just very nice all the way around.
Judith K.Verified patient
Dr. Shaffer is the best dentist! He answers all my questions clearly and explains everything so I understand the work that needs to be done . His bedside manner is amazing. HIGHLY RECOMMEND
June 22, 2023Sara T.Verified patient
I was nervous but the doctor put me at ease. He was thorough and listened to my concerns and very gentle on me. I must of recommended him to everyone I spoke to since.
Initials hidden
LOVED IT!
April 20, 2022Joelle M.Verified patient
First appointment was great. Doctor took full set of x-rays (“whether insurance pays for it or not”) and gave me a VERY thorough cleaning (long overdue). Follow up in four weeks to see how the questionable areas look after cleaning. He explained everything he saw on the x-rays and what he thinks may need to be done in the future. Glad he’s not pushing me into anything that may turn out to be unnecessary. Couldn’t be happier with my new dentist!
November 29, 2021Teresa R.Verified patient
First time in my life I actually like going to the dentist. Dr. Shaffer is excellent at what he does. Very nice, down to earth guy.
William N.Verified patient
Excellent ,
September 1, 2021Kevin S.Verified patient
Only had a cleaning done so far but his bedside manner is impressive. I felt like I was talking to one of my colleagues, He puts you at ease and minimizes your anxiety with dental visits. Did a great job!!
August 5, 2021Tamika R.Verified patient
Always a pleasure being Dr, Shaffer's patient. He genuinely cares for all his patients and takes his time in anything he does to make sure you get the best service.
July 16, 2021Ronnel P.Verified patient
I feel lucky to have a great doctor caring for my dental health. Highly recommend, and highly regarded, setting industry standards for professionalism and quality service, care, and compassion.
July 7, 2021Alexander K.Verified patient
Fantastic dentist. Probably the best in Long Island. He listened to all my concerns and we had a direct conversation about my tooth health. Put me as ease right away.
July 2, 2021Elisabeth R.Verified patient
Outstanding Dentist
July 1, 2021Thomas O.Verified patient
Dr. Shaffer is a fabulous dentist. He saved several of my adult son's teeth when poor dentistry by another dentist made for a bleak situation. My husband and I feel very fortunate to have found Dr. Shaffer. He cares for our teeth and we recommend him highly! Anita L.
June 2, 2021Anita L.Verified patient
Excellent treatment!
May 11, 2021Ximena D.Verified patient
Dr. Shaffer is the best !
March 3, 2021John G.Verified patient
Highly recommend. Great bedside manner, willing to discuss your issues in detail. Highly knowledgeable and makes going to the dentist a pleasure.
February 28, 2021Initials hidden
He’s very knowledgeable and a delightful person to deal with and tells you the pros and cons of everything he does or recommends
February 13, 2021Greg B.Verified patient
He always is on time, patient, and professional! He really knows how to comfort me when I’m feeling nervous and he always takes good care of my Mouth! Highly recommend and now my entire family goes here!
January 18, 2021Samantha S.Verified patient
Dr Shaffer is extremely kind, direct, and personable. As a new patient he explained everything to me and asked if I had any concerns before beginning.
January 7, 2021Initials hidden
He was great, explained everything that was happening, made sure I was comfortable. He worked fast but made sure it was done perfectly.
January 7, 2021Jacqueline W.Verified patient
Dr Shaffer goes above and beyond .
December 15, 2020Jacob M.Verified patient
Amazing , made my experience pain free!
November 20, 2020Kaitlynn M.Verified patient
It was great. Everybody is nice and professional.
October 27, 2020Nennette M.Verified patient
Thank You so much Dr Shaffer for the amazing work and the outstanding patient care!!! Dr shaffer is very personal and will always be there for me whenever i need him!!!!
October 26, 2020Blimie W.Verified patient
This was our second family (3 people) visit to Dr Shaffer's practice. Checkin was fast (with an online form prior to visit due to COVID atm). Dr Shaffer is very through, highly skilled, professional and personable. He's good with kids too! We're coming back in 6 months!
September 26, 2020Vlad L.Verified patient
He’s great!
August 29, 2020John G.Verified patient
Professional, honest and caring
August 25, 2020G VVerified patient
Great with little kids (and adults), friendly, and knowledgeable. Treatment is conservative, and he thoroughly, patiently explains all the options if you're on the fence. Highly recommend Dr. Shaffer.
August 18, 2020Initials hidden
Dr. Shaffer is great. Have been seeing him over a year now. Have had at least 6 visits. He and the rest of practice are professional, communicative, and don’t rush their work. They put quality first even if it means more unexpected time.
July 1, 2020Jason K.Verified patient
Loading...