Book an Appointment
Qualifications and Experience
Awards and Publications
I am delighted to work with adults who are ready to gain insight into their behaviors and begin to make positive changes in their lives!
Please read carefully:
-Please contact me DIRECTLY for an 8am or 9pm appointment time
-You must give 72 hours notice if you need to cancel your first appointment to avoid being charged the full rate of $200.
-New patients will be asked to leave a credit card on file in the event of a no-show and will not be granted an appointment if this is not left on file.
-Please do not consider your appointment confirmed unless you hear from me personally by phone and/or email.
-All new patients will need to complete the forms prior to your appointment located at www.therapywithkeeley.com/forms. These can be faxed or emailed to me, or simply print and bring to your appointment. Patients who do not complete the forms will not be seen.
Keeley Teemsma is a New York State Licensed Clinical Social Worker and Psychotherapist. Ms. Teemsma holds graduate degrees in Sociology and Clinical Social Work from CUNY Queens College and New York University, respectively. She is often an “expert consultant” for various televised and print media. In addition to publication in TIME, she has conducted original research on attitudes and behaviors of law enforcement personnel, as well as political polling, and public opinion research on a variety of topics including religion, family life, finance, and risk-taking behaviors. Ms. Teemsma has worked as a Clinical Quality Improvement consultant and has had direct clinical experience with adults, youth, & families. She has extensive experience in working with adults with severe personality disorders, persistent mental illnesses, hoarding, obesity, and law enforcement & public service personnel, & the LGBT communities.
Verified Patient Reviews
Dr. Keeley really knows her stuff- very thorough, very clinical. She even called my psychiatrist to resolve an medication issue. She went above and beyond.
Delightful! Will certainly be returning.
My intake appointment with Keeley was pretty standard. More clinical than I'm used to with therapists, but overall I'm looking forward to working with her!
Keeley is an incredibly understanding, empathetic, and effective therapist. She has been extremely helpful and I would recommend her to anyone.
sense of humor, takes her work very seriously but expects you do work hard on yourself, available between sessions by text and email
Felt comfortable pretty much instantly, will be returning!
Keely was very welcoming and understanding.
It was a waist of time. She said the same thing over and over, kept on watching the clock and picking her nose. Very unprofessional.
Great & very comfortable experience.
She's really good. Didn't know what to expect, but she's very mellow and allows you to tell her/show her what the problem is. It was very cathartic.
It wasn't what I expected, it was better. She's very sweet and kind. I can see her helping me with many of my ailments.
I was seen exactly at my scheduled time. The office was quiet and furnished with two very comfy arm chairs. The other therapists on the floor said hello and seemed pleasant. I appreciated the doctor's insights and thought she kept it real. I like that she is honest.
I arrived early, but Dr. Keeley took me exactly at my appointment time. She has a lot of rules, but I thought it was helpful to have clarity RE: her policies, expectations, etc. I think this is meant to ensure that each person is treated equally. She asked questions and I thought she was thoro. She gave me feed back and some ideas to research on my own. I went to Bay Ridge today. The couch was the most comfortable couch I've ever sat on in my life, but I am going to go to Park Slope next time since I live exactly the same distance from each office. I think it was a helpful first visit.
I thought she was wonderful. She was very attentive and made me feel comfortable
I had a vastly different experience from what all the great reviews here describe. First of all, her Carroll Gardens office is a tiny single room (literally just enough room for two chairs) in another company's office space. There is absolutely no waiting area. I had to awkwardly stand in an office kitchen that random employees were in until Keeley opened her door. The session made me feel worse than before I came. She asked me questions that I had already answered extensively in the paperwork she made me fill out, which demonstrated she hadn't bothered to look at any of it before we met. And when I gave my answers, she would just say "huh...", sometimes looking surprised, and then move on to the next question. She also, MULTIPLE times while I was talking, checked her phone and even texted more than once during my session. It all felt very weird and unprofessional. Although my first session was terrible, I wanted to give her one more shot because of all her great reviews. I scheduled another appt for three weeks later, and about three hours before the appointment she cancelled abruptly on me, saying she would call me back to reschedule. It is almost a week later and I have yet to get a call back from her.
She doesn't take her job seriously enough. If you want to complain and vent feelings, she'll listen and her skills are enough for that. Did not show any skills in CBT or any other serious form of therapy. If you want to get real therapy, yoi are better off finding a psychologist or psychiatrists, or a better SW.
Easy to talk to, super helpful. Sense of humor and adaptable to your needs. Nice comfortable court street office and Cobble hill convenient. I give it two apples. ????
It was a consultation so hard to say for sure. But I left feeling better which has never happened before.
I only had a consultation with Keeley, but in no time, I could tell that she was a wonderful therapist! She's patient, a great listener and someone who I believe you can become comfortable talking to, especially if you're not too social or have difficulty socializing in general. I would definitely recommend her! She has her own nice little practice. Honestly, she's probably one of the best (and coolest) therapists I've ever visited -- it seems so upscale, too. Not that it matters, but it gives you a safe feeling. I can't recommend her enough. She saw me for a full hour and with such great services, I'm surprised she accepts insurance.
We have only seen her for our initial visit but think she is a good fit for our family and our needs. She was open and attentive and had a lot of insight to offer. She has made an excellent impression on us.
Keeley is an excellent therapist. It was a perfect fit. I've seen a few therapists in Brooklyn and she was the most professional and easiest to talk to. I look forward to our future sessions.
Just had my first appointment with Keeley. I really appreciated the way she integrated the importance of being self-aware not only of our mental health but also to be aware of our body and physical health. I went to see Keeley specifically because of her experience in working with transgendered people, like myself. She had a lot of knowledge surrounding trans issues, HRT, discussing transitions with family, and other aspects of transitioning. She was not judgmental at all. Her office is comfortable and inviting. I enjoyed the appointment and will be returning. Thanks!
This therapist seems shocked whenever you disclose your issues. She doesn't follow up or check in on patients so if you don't request to see her, you'll never hear from her again.
She is a wonderful therapist. It is no wonder she has many patients. After searching for so long I very much appreciate having found Dr. Keeley.
I brought my teen daughter to see Keeley for anxiety and depression. Keeley was wonderful, she's very professional, candid, and compassionate. Keeley communicates regularly through phone, SMS text and email, which is a huge plus for me and my daughter. Her office is a cozy, relaxing private practice space in a nice residential pre-war building in Bay Ridge.
I was one of Keeley's patients at the medical practice that she worked in some time ago. I had only worked with her for a couple of months, but found that I had made significant progress with her in therapy. About a month ago, I was thinking of resuming therapy again, but was informed that she was no longer there. :( I was assigned to another female therapist who, in addition to speaking so loudly that the entire clinic could hear, was cold and didn't seem to be up-to-date on treatment approaches. I was disheartned. I looked Keeley up shortly thereafter, essentially crossing my fingers that she was accepting new patients, and she did her best to squeeze me into her schedule that same day. There is no doubt in my mind that she is the best. I'm also really glad that I am able to book my appointments online-- this is just so convenient.
Keeley is great. That is all.
She is very friendly . I think I had good confidence with doctor . Also I took another appointment . I want to come back .
It was a very productive first session. I look forward to future sessions.
Keeley took me right away and saw me for a full hour. Since I'm paying out of pocket, I appreciate that she spends more time with her patients that other therapists do. I also was really impressed with the fact that she does not like to be called "Doctor" or "Miss", and when I complimented her credentials (and she has an entire wall full of them) she flat out said, "they don't make me better or worse than anyone else. We all choose different paths and that is fine." She wasn't condescending in the least bit and I felt like I was in control of the session. She asked me where I wanted to start, what I expect from her, and what my goals for therapy are. She also encouraged me to give her honest feedback about our work together going forward. I would definitely recommend her to others.
Dr. Teemsma was absolutely brilliant. She seems to have a great working knowledge of diagnostics and psychopharmacology. I feel that after seeing several professionals, I've finally received a correct diagnosis. Apart from that, she comes off as personable and very relateable. Her office is warm and inviting, not cold and institutional. I felt at ease. I also briefly met her therapy cat, Emmett, which was a delight. I will most certainly be continuing my treatment with her.
Keeley is a fantastic therapist. She creates a comfortable setting and is one of those people you will quickly trust. She provides good insight and is extremely professional. Highly recommend!
This therapist sees patients in her apartment, not very professional in my opinion. Also seemed to want to blame everything on menstruation... seriously? Would not recommend.
Very comforting, nonjudgmental, and insightful ear that listens to you and thoroughly takes time to give you the best therapeutic session. I highly recommend!