What patients are saying
Overall rating
4.77
Average wait time
4.65
Bedside manner
4.83
“Doctor Notaro Was compassionate,Explaining everything to me!Very professional!I felt very comfortable and confident with her!Would definitely recommend this Doctor ??”
Claire C.Less than 6 months ago
“As a seasoned skin cancer sufferer, I found her extremely knowledgeable, and she analyzed and found the area of concern, and treated it promptly. She also provided me solid advice in trying mitigate issues in the future. Would be confident in recommending her!”
William G.April 22, 2025
About Dr. Antoinette Notaro
Antoinette Notaro, MD is a board-certified dermatologist practicing in our Mattituck, Long Island dermatology office. Dr. Notaro has been in private practice for over 25 years in Long Island. She is also a clinical assistant professor of Dermatology at SUNY Stony Brook. Dr. Notaro received her medical degree from SUNY Brooklyn and completed her dermatology residency at Albert Einstein College of Medicine in New York City.
Dr. Notaro has performed many clinical research studies and is a member of various dermatology societies, including Suffolk County Dermatology Society, Women’s Dermatologic Society and the New York State Medical Society. Dr. Notaro has been voted as the “Best of the Best” in Dan’s Papers as well as a Top Doctor in the Castle-Connelly Guide.
Is this doctor in your insurance network?
Enter your insurance carrier and plan
choose insurance
In-network insurances
99% of patients have successfully booked with these insurances
Aetna
BlueCross BlueShield
Cigna
Emblem Health
Medicare
UnitedHealthcare
UnitedHealthcare Oxford
Office locations
Schweiger Dermatology Group - Smithtown (1 of 3)
260 Middle Country Rd, Ste 208, Smithtown, NY 11787
Schweiger Dermatology Group - East Hampton (3 of 3)
300 Pantigo Pl, Ste 117, East Hampton, NY 11937
1 of 3
Education and background
Practice names
Board certifications
- American Board of Dermatology
Education and training
- Medical School - State University of New York, Downstate Medical Center, Doctor of Medicine
- Albert Einstein College of Medicine of Yeshiva University, Montefiore Hospital and Medical Center, Residency in Dermatology
- New York University (Bachelor's)
Awards and publications
- Castle Connolly Top Doctor
- 2024 Castle Connolly Top Doctor
Languages spoken
- English
Provider's gender
Female
NPI number
1922003920
Patient reviews
All reviews have been submitted by patients after interacting with the practice.
Overall rating
4.77
Wait time
4.65
Bedside manner
4.83
Your trust is our top concern, so providers can't pay to alter or remove reviews. We also don't publish reviews that contain any private patient health information. Learn more here
601 reviews
Most relevant
I have been seeing Dr. Notaro for many years and have always been pleased with the visit.
October 22, 2025Joan D.Verified patient
Dr Notaro was on time with her schedule, compassionate , and communicative. I am very happy that I went to see her today.
January 4, 2024Gina T.Verified patient
I had such a great experience there. He addressed all my concerns. Such a friendly staff. I would recommend to everyone!!!
September 18, 2021Donna B.Verified patient
Dr Notaro is lovely, but was unable to tell me anything conclusive about the appearance of my mole over video appointment.
More than 1 year agoInitials hiddenVideo visit
She's a professional very thorough . She's also very cut and dry . Tells you like it is not always what you want to hear .
More than 1 year agoJoann S.Verified patient
My spouse and I have been patients of Dr Notaro for many years now and we have every confidance being under her care.
March 22, 2017Sharron G.Verified patient
everyone in the office is extremely friendly, helpful and professional. Dr. Notaro was thorough and great as usual.
January 12, 2016Linda V.Verified patient
Felt like it was a rushed appt with not much personal care, more like general information that I've heard before.
April 12, 2017John E.Verified patient
Dr Notaro was pleasant, professional, listened to my concerns, and explained findings and procedure.
September 20, 2023Amy W.Verified patient
I was very pleased with my visit. she is very through. answers all questions and I was very happy with my visit
July 8, 2020Annette J.Verified patient
Friendly staff..Dr was extremely friendly and professional, easy to talk to....a real down to earth doctor!!,
November 24, 2015Maureen B.Verified patient
Was able to book an appointment online. Very friendly and accommodating staff. Highly recommend this office.
June 24, 2021Initials hidden
The office ensured that my time spent was quick and efficient. I was in and out, great experience.
April 14, 2023Dwight A.Verified patient
I felt rushed and that my cosmetic concerns were not taken seriously or addressed in a professional manner.
More than 1 year agoClaudia C.Verified patient
Would definitely go back. Very professional, clean and professional office. Couldn't be happier!
April 5, 2023Robert W.Verified patient
First time patient. I felt like I had known Dr. Notarro my whole life. Very knowledgeable.
September 7, 2023Mark A.Verified patient
It was a very comfortable visit. Everyone was friendly. The communication was
excellent.
March 6, 2023Sharon K.Verified patient
Very positive experience. Long wait due to system upgrade. Very thorough and happy with result.
September 22, 2015Dan L.Verified patient
I saw Dr. Kimberly McCosker at the Smithtown Office today. I reaLLY LIKED HER VERY MUCH..
December 5, 2022Initials hidden
I'm not a fan of video dr. visits, but Dr. Notaro adapted well to the situation and helped me.
More than 1 year agoInitials hiddenVideo visit
Efficient friendly clean organized and answered all my questions. Easy to speak to
August 3, 2023Ronald S.Verified patient
great friendly staff. iss resolved very quickly and professionally. highly recommend!
April 12, 2023Vincent P.Verified patient
For an appointment that i set up last night last minute this was great very friendly staff
More than 1 year agoInitials hidden
A pleasant visit. I have full confidence in dr notaro. Visits are friendly and non stressful
February 17, 2017Edward G.Verified patient
Awesome people and care provided! I highly recommend. I felt seen heard and helped
More than 1 year agoInitials hidden
Professional, thorough and pleasant. It is always a positive experience seeing Dr. Notaro
More than 1 year agoHelen M.Verified patient
She was so sweet and understanding and asked all the right questions. Highly recommend!
More than 1 year agoKathryn P.Verified patientVideo visit
Friendly doctor and assistant that put you at ease. Definitely would return.
October 13, 2023Virginia I.Verified patient
A wonderful experience as always! Thorough exam and answered all my questions.
June 29, 2023Christine C.Verified patient
Highly recommended! Staff is friendly and professional!
September 18, 2024Oscar Santiago A.Verified patient
Very professional doctor, overall great experience.
December 19, 2024Initials hidden
She is a wonderful person with her knowledge and polite behavior
October 10, 2023Aysel M.Verified patient
Very nice, easy to talk to, helped me with all my questions and concerns
September 28, 2021Initials hidden
The staff was kind and walked me through the procedure step by step.
December 9, 2021Anna K.Verified patient
Sh is a wonderful and warm person who makes very comfortable immediately
More than 1 year agoAchilles S.Verified patient
Exactly as always: professional, knowledgeable, pleasant and reassuring.
February 22, 2017Kathryn L.Verified patient
Dr Notaro was very thorough and her staff treated me well too.
July 6, 2023Initials hidden
She is very friendly and Very professional.
I’m Glad I went to see her
June 20, 2018Brian W.Verified patient
Staff and the physicians was very professional and very informative.
January 27, 2021Manmohan R.Verified patient
Very satisfied. She's knowledgeable and has a pleasant bedside manner
December 15, 2015Denise D.Verified patient
Reassuring,professional and courteous, and the staff is wonderful!!!!
January 8, 2016William H.Verified patient
This was great to be able to see the doctor during the pandemic.
More than 1 year agoInitials hidden
She’s professional and extremely competent.
Glad I found her.
May 7, 2019Jo M.Verified patient
Very good. Staff was friendly and professional, as always
October 12, 2021Tricia H.Verified patient
Always a great experience. That's why I continue to go there.
April 7, 2017Thomas S.Verified patient
The visit was quicker then usual for a full body scan.
October 21, 2015Phyllius R.Verified patient
Very nice visit overall - professional and friendly.
April 6, 2017Kenneth R.Verified patient
See prior star ratings
March 18, 2026Peter M.Verified patient
Doctor Notaro Was compassionate,Explaining everything to me!Very professional!I felt very comfortable and confident with her!Would definitely recommend this Doctor ??
Less than 6 months agoClaire C.Verified patient
I would highly recommend Dr. Notaro.
Less than 1 year agoInitials hidden
Loading...
How soon can I make an appointment with Dr. Antoinette Notaro?
Generally, Dr. Antoinette Notaro has appointments available on Zocdoc within 1 week. You can see Dr. Notaro's earliest availability on Zocdoc and make an appointment online.
Is Dr. Antoinette Notaro accepting new patients?
Dr. Antoinette Notaro generally accepts new patients on Zocdoc. You can see Dr. Notaro's earliest availability on Zocdoc and schedule an appointment online.
Does Dr. Antoinette Notaro accept my insurance?
Choose your insurance plan to verify if Dr. Notaro is in-network.
Can I make an appointment with Dr. Antoinette Notaro online?
Yes, you can make an appointment online with Dr. Notaro using Zocdoc. It’s simple, secure, and free.
What practice does Dr. Antoinette Notaro work with?
Dr. Antoinette Notaro works with Schweiger Dermatology Group.
Where is Dr. Antoinette Notaro's office located?
Dr. Antoinette Notaro has 3 office locations, including in Mattituck, Smithtown, and East Hampton, view full addresses on Dr. Notaro's profile.
Which board certifications does Dr. Antoinette Notaro have?
Dr. Antoinette Notaro is certified by American Board of Dermatology.
What are common reasons for patients to see Dr. Antoinette Notaro?
Dr. Antoinette Notaro frequently sees patients for Acne, Annual Skin Screening, Dermatology Consultation, Hair Loss, and Rash. You can see other visit reasons for Dr. Antoinette Notaro on their profile.
What languages does Dr. Antoinette Notaro speak?
Dr. Antoinette Notaro speaks English.
How do patients rate Dr. Antoinette Notaro in reviews?
601 patients have reviewed Dr. Antoinette Notaro. The overall rating for this doctor is 4.77/5. They have a 4.83/5 rating for bedside manner and a 4.65/5 rating for wait time. You can read individual reviews and ratings on their profile.