Book an Appointment
Qualifications and Experience
Antoinette Notaro, MD is a board-certified dermatologist practicing in our Mattituck, Long Island dermatology office. Dr. Notaro has been in private practice for over 25 years in Long Island. She is also a clinical assistant professor of Dermatology at SUNY Stony Brook. Dr. Notaro received her medical degree from SUNY Brooklyn and completed her dermatology residency at Albert Einstein College of Medicine in New York City. Dr. Notaro has performed many clinical research studies and is a member of various dermatology societies, including Suffolk County Dermatology Society, Women’s Dermatologic Society and the New York State Medical Society. Dr. Notaro has been voted as the “Best of the Best” in Dan’s Papers as well as a Top Doctor in the Castle-Connelly Guide.
Verified Patient Reviews
Had the first appointment in the morning so she was right on time, The office is usually crowded and wait not only in the waiting room but get called back to an examination room and wait there also. She is usually about 30 minutes behind as the day goes on but after many years I have learned to be first in the morning or first after lunch! Staff always very friendly and supportive attitudes. Office is supper clean. Doctor Notaro always is right on with diagnosis and treatment plans.
It addressed my problem with a thorough explanation and plan for continued healing. The staff and Dr. Notaro are very smiley, happy people who understand your concerns and take the time to make sure you understand what is prescribed for you. Your visit is always pleasant. A very caring doctor. More like a friend.
My visit was great. She is friendly and considerate. My only concern is my prescription not being sent to my pharmacy right away.
Dr, Notaro is very caring and thorough she is also very calming and pleasant,I would highly recommend her.I have been going to her quite a few years.
I felt rushed and that my cosmetic concerns were not taken seriously or addressed in a professional manner.
Felt like it was a rushed appt with not much personal care, more like general information that I've heard before.
Always a great experience. That's why I continue to go there.
Dr Notaro is wonderful. Please consider offering a discount on cosmetic procedures with the Zocdoc birthday email. That would be an awesome gift!! Versus a discount on lotions & potions. Thank you
Very nice visit overall - professional and friendly.
It was my first visit with Dr. Notaro. She immediately put me at ease and worked efficiently and professionally. I was out of the office in under 45 minutes, including a brief wait time in the reception area.
My spouse and I have been patients of Dr Notaro for many years now and we have every confidance being under her care.
Great doctor. Great bedside manner.
Exactly as always: professional, knowledgeable, pleasant and reassuring.
A pleasant visit. I have full confidence in dr notaro. Visits are friendly and non stressful
Great as usual.
Very friendly, plus explained everything
She's a professional very thorough . She's also very cut and dry . Tells you like it is not always what you want to hear .
Great visit as always ...Dr. Notaro is a pleasure to visit with - and the constant reminder to wear sunblock never gets old ??!
I was treated as a person and not a number. The Dr and her assistant took their time and explained everything clearly to me. I had a small surgical procedure which was thankfully completely painless. I would highly recommend anyone to Dr Notaro!
everyone in the office is extremely friendly, helpful and professional. Dr. Notaro was thorough and great as usual.
Reassuring,professional and courteous, and the staff is wonderful!!!!
Very satisfied. She's knowledgeable and has a pleasant bedside manner
Friendly staff..Dr was extremely friendly and professional, easy to talk to....a real down to earth doctor!!,
ACCEPTABLE... She only handled the one directive I addressed. Unless I asked a question there was no opinion of my overall skin issues. I thought she could have suggested additional treatment while I was there.
I appreciate the time she takes with me. No rushing. Thorough explanation of procedures and she answers my questions completely.
The visit was quicker then usual for a full body scan.
Didn't have to wait a long time and Dr Notaro is very pleasant and informative. Also got down to business right away. She keeps you informed as she goes along.
Our visit to Dr. Notaro was excellent. Both my husband and I had squamous cell cancers removed from our face and this was out 6 month follow up visit. Not only did she address the areas that we were there for, but she also visually checked other areas of our skin. I was concerned about an area on my thigh that had been looking different and she agreed. She took a specimen to send for biopsy. Dr Notaro is very knowledgeable, professional and pleasant. Her staff is very courteous and helpful and the office is very comfortable. We were seen within a few minutes of our arrival. We would highly recommend Dr. Notaro!
Very positive experience. Long wait due to system upgrade. Very thorough and happy with result.