What patients are saying
Overall rating
4.89
Average wait time
4.78
Bedside manner
4.96
“Dr. Nagaya spent most of our appointment just asking questions and listening. She presented different options for treatment and encouraged me to take my time deciding what was the best fit for me, and to write back to her with any questions. When I did write back with some follow up questions, she responded so quickly and thoroughly.”
Initials hiddenApril 5, 2026Video visit
“I have struggled with no being heard before and experienced the complete opposite with the doctor. Super thankful and looking forward to continuing to work with them. ”
Initials hiddenApril 4, 2026Video visit
About Dr. Fatima Nagaya
Focus areas
Anxiety Disorder
Mood Disorders
Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)
Bipolar Disorder
Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD)
Schizoaffective Disorder
Depression
Panic Disorder
Clientele seen
Young adults (18-24)
Adults (25-64)
Individuals
Identity
Gender
FemaleLanguages spoken
English, Hausa
Getting to know Dr. Fatima Nagaya
DISCLAIMER: Unfortunately, I CANNOT prescribe controlled medications/substances in Texas. However, I CAN still see patients there, offer alternative treatment plans, and prescribe NON-CONTROLLED medications.
I am an adult psychiatrist and Board Certified by the American Board of Psychiatry and Neurology. My qualifications include a medical degree from the Albert Einstein College of Medicine in New York and a four-year residency in adult psychiatry at Zucker Hillside Hospital in Queens New York. My medical education and training has given me a broad experience on mental health care in one of the most diverse counties in the U.S.
I have worked as an outpatient adult psychiatrist at Zucker Hillside Hospital and served as an Assistant Professor at the Donald and Barbara Zucker School of Medicine at Hofstra University. In these roles, I focused on evaluating, diagnosing, and treating adults with various mental health symptoms and conditions. My academic responsibilities included educating third-year medical students during their core psychiatry rotations and participating in the psychiatry residency selection committee.
My approach to psychiatry is holistic and evidence-based, aiming to improve overall wellbeing. I prioritize comprehensive evaluations, empathy, and a collaborative approach with my patients. In my practice, I integrate medication management with psychotherapy, including supportive, cognitive-behavioral, and interpersonal therapy, to provide well-rounded mental health care.
Languages spoken? English, Hausa
What should a new client know about working with you?
I provide thoughtful and individualized medication management in a supportive and respectful environment. I take the time to conduct a thorough evaluation of your symptoms, medical history, and treatment goals to ensure an accurate diagnosis and effective plan of care. My approach is collaborative—I value your input and aim to create a space where you feel comfortable discussing your experiences and concerns.
What is your typical process for working with clients?
I utilize evidence-based practices while considering the full picture of your mental and physical health. When recommending medications, I carefully review the benefits, potential side effects, and alternatives, making adjustments as needed to optimize your outcomes. My goal is to provide clear guidance, close follow-up, and a personalized treatment approach that supports your stability, functioning, and overall well-being.
Is this doctor in your insurance network?
Enter your insurance carrier and plan
choose insurance
In-network insurances
Aetna
BlueCross BlueShield
Cigna
UnitedHealthcare
UnitedHealthcare Oxford
Education and background
Practice names
Board certifications
- American Board of Psychiatry and Neurology
- Psychiatry (American Board of Psychiatry and Neurology)
Education and training
- Medical School - Albert Einstein College of Medicine of Yeshiva University, Doctor of Medicine
- Zucker Hillside Hospital, Residency in Adult Psychiatry
NPI number
1316300536
Patient reviews
All reviews have been submitted by patients after interacting with the practice.
Overall rating
4.89
Wait time
4.78
Bedside manner
4.96
Your trust is our top concern, so providers can't pay to alter or remove reviews. We also don't publish reviews that contain any private patient health information. Learn more here
170 reviews
Most relevant
She was phenomenal, genuinely listens and is very competent on diagnosis. Far above other psychiatrists I’ve seen.
November 22, 2025Theodore W.Verified patientVideo visit
Dr. Fatima Nagaya is an excellent Psychiatrist—compassionate, attentive, thorough, knowledgeable, patient, and kind.
September 13, 2025Yolanda A.Verified patientVideo visit
We had some technical difficulties on both of our ends at the beginning, but once it was all sorted everything went smoothly.
May 26, 2024Crystal Nicole W.Verified patientVideo visit
Quick and efficient. She was very kind and understanding but also straightforward and informative.
June 21, 2025Leslie B.Verified patientVideo visit
It was a very pleasant experience. The energy and interactions made me feel at ease. I felt heard.
May 22, 2025Peter O.Verified patientVideo visit
Dr. Natalya took into account my whole experience as a psychiatric patient and recommended what I wanted and needed.
June 16, 2024Carlos A.Verified patientVideo visit
Really wonderful clinician. Felt heard and understood. Not a drop of dismissiveness. Thank you Dr.
April 27, 2024Sean K.Verified patientVideo visit
Dr. Nagaya is a great listener, very respectful, and extremely knowledgeable.
Less than 1 year agoInitials hiddenVideo visit
was very clear and concise! an amazing communicator and helped me immensely
May 20, 2025Alexis A.Verified patientVideo visit
great listener, asked directed questions and educated me on the my diagnosis.
More than 1 year agoInitials hiddenVideo visit
Amazing! Very good bedside manner and I felt heard
November 29, 2025Brady B.Verified patientVideo visit
Dr. Nagaya was extremely compassionate and empathetic. I am glad I found her!
April 26, 2024Heather W.Verified patientVideo visit
It’s been a great experience with Dr. Fatima and your system.
More than 1 year agoInitials hiddenSource: Partner
She’s kind and knowledgeable. It was so nice meeting her
December 27, 2024Brittany M.Verified patientVideo visit
Recommended. Made the right questions and listened carefully.
June 7, 2024Daniela A.Verified patientVideo visit
Dr. Nagaya spent most of our appointment just asking questions and listening. She presented different options for treatment and encouraged me to take my time deciding what was the best fit for me, and to write back to her with any questions. When I did write back with some follow up questions, she responded so quickly and thoroughly.
April 5, 2026Initials hiddenVideo visit
I have struggled with no being heard before and experienced the complete opposite with the doctor. Super thankful and looking forward to continuing to work with them.
April 4, 2026Initials hiddenVideo visit
Dr. Nagaya is one of the best psychiatrists I’ve met. Great listener and communicator. I did not feel rushed and she made sure I understood her advise well.
Less than 3 months agoInitials hiddenVideo visit
Super nice and wonderful experience
December 3, 2025Brooke B.Verified patientVideo visit
Dr. Nagaya was lovely. I felt heard and understood when explaining how I was feeling. She is very knowledgeable and gave me options. Highly highly recommend.
October 8, 2025Lourdes H.Verified patientVideo visit
I went into the appointment looking for an opinion about whether medications may help me with my longstanding depression. She listened and asked lots of questions, and answered all of my questions and ultimately recommended against them. I left the appointment still feeling like something was not quite right and not fully satisfied, but I still can’t quite place why. Not every psychiatrist is going to be a good fit I suppose.
July 28, 2025Olivia L.Verified patientVideo visit
She’s a fantastic active listener who asks great questions and makes her patients feel heard, her bedside manner is fantastic, and she is solution-oriented and immediately initiated a treatment plan after first visit.
March 30, 2025Drake B.Verified patientVideo visit
Amazing, this provider made me feel comfortable and that I was not alone. I would recommend her to anyone looking for an understanding provider to get them the help they need.
March 9, 2025Liza M.Verified patientVideo visit
I really appreciated Dr. Nagaya's straightforward yet compassionate demeanor during our appointment, but would may not recommend as she was 9 minutes late to our scheduled appointment and didn't mention or apologize for this. I'm always running late so this wasn't a huge deal but it didn't make for a great first impression.
Also, the communication from her office was inconsistent and frustrating. Prior to my appointment, her office called me 3 times, emailed me 5 times, and texted me 12 times from 4 different phone numbers. The automated text messages were rarely relevant to me: they directed me to fill out a form and pay my balance before those were available. The day after I filled out the form and paid, I got several texts with an action item to fill out the intake form and pay my balance. I did ask them to communicate whether Dr. Nagaya could fill my prescription and never received that email, which makes the over-communication about other things all the more baffling.
More than 1 year agoInitials hiddenVideo visit
Felt heard and accepted, she was able to help me understand some feelings or thoughts better and put things into words and or perspectives. Also helped me choose a path I’m most comfortable with on continuing treatment.
June 21, 2024Jade H.Verified patientVideo visit
She is very easy to talk to. She asked questions I didn't think about as well as everything I asked. I have an office number to call if I need something (something I didn't have with other providers). I will be continuing to see her as long as my insurance doesn't change again.
June 7, 2024Jacalyn P.Verified patientVideo visit
Dr Nagaya is a breath of fresh air compared to other psychiatrists i’ve seen. She was prompt and asked the questions I needed to feel as though she understood and cared about why I was coming to her. It was not long, but felt like she was genuinely interested in what I was saying and the context behind it. She also asked me the frequency in which I wanted to see her instead of insisting on a specific time frame, which struck me as thoughtful and genuinely patient focused. Some people need to see a psychiatrist more frequently, some less, and her recognition of that was great. Overall she is new to me but i definitely foresee her being my psychiatrist going forward.
June 1, 2024Initials hiddenVideo visit
The collaborative nature of our therapeutic relationship extends to the exploration of underlying issues. Dr. Nagaya's insights into patterns and behaviors have been illuminating, contributing to a deeper understanding of myself.
More than 1 year agoLR
Choosing Dr. Nagaya as my psychiatrist has been a transformative decision. Her comprehensive approach, considering both the medical and psychological aspects of my well-being, has been key to my progress.
More than 1 year agoWS
Dr. Fatima Nagaya's commitment to cultural competence is commendable. Her respectful and understanding approach to diversity and individual differences has created an inclusive environment where I feel seen and valued.
More than 1 year agoLT
Dr. Nagaya's emphasis on holistic well-being is refreshing. Beyond medications, she explores therapeutic interventions and lifestyle factors, contributing to a more comprehensive and sustainable approach to mental health.
More than 1 year agoEM
Dr. Fatima Nagaya's commitment to creating a safe and inclusive space is evident in every interaction. Her acceptance and understanding foster an environment where vulnerability is met with compassion, promoting healing and growth.
More than 1 year agoCS
Dr. Fatima Nagaya, MD, is a compassionate and dedicated psychiatrist who has been instrumental in my mental health journey. From the initial consultation, Dr. Nagaya's warmth and professionalism created a safe space where I felt heard and understood.
More than 1 year agoMB
Dr. Fatima Nagaya's encouragement of self-compassion and self-care has been transformative. Her emphasis on holistic well-being extends beyond medication, providing practical tools and strategies for managing the challenges of daily life.
More than 1 year agoTP
Choosing Dr. Fatima Nagaya as my psychiatrist has been a transformative decision. Dr. Nagaya's diagnostic skills are truly exceptional, and her ability to explain complex concepts in a clear and compassionate manner has enhanced my understanding of my mental health condition.
More than 1 year agoJO
Dr. Nagaya's genuine concern for potential challenges and setbacks has instilled a sense of resilience. her guidance has been pivotal in developing coping strategies, fostering a positive mindset in navigating life's complexities.
More than 1 year agoHC
Dr. Fatima Nagaya's medication management has been a crucial component of my mental health care. Her expertise in prescribing and adjusting medications is paired with a genuine concern for potential side effects.
More than 1 year agoDH
I am grateful for Dr. Nagaya's commitment to personalized care. She takes the time to tailor treatment approaches to my unique needs, considering not only the medical aspects but also the psychological and social factors that contribute to my well-being.
More than 1 year agoJC
I've found in Dr. Nagaya not just a psychiatrist but a genuine advocate for mental health. Her efforts to reduce stigma and create a culture of openness align with my own values, contributing to a larger conversation about mental well-being.
More than 1 year agoJM
As a patient of Dr. Nagaya, I appreciate her dual role as a medical doctor and a compassionate listener. She has a gift for active listening, making each session feel like a collaborative effort in understanding and addressing my mental health concerns.
More than 1 year agoJM
As a patient of Dr. Fatima Nagaya, MD, I have experienced a level of care and expertise that has truly made a difference in my life. Dr. Nagaya's thorough assessments and diagnostic acumen have provided clarity and a roadmap for my treatment.
More than 1 year agoPW
Dr. Nagaya's expertise in medication management is evident in the thoughtful and personalized approach to my prescriptions. Her attention to detail and consideration of potential side effects showcase her commitment to my well-being.
More than 1 year agoCR
Dr. Fatima Nagaya's unwavering support has extended beyond the confines of our sessions. Her encouragement of self-help resources and mindfulness practices has enhanced the practical tools available to me for managing daily challenges.
More than 1 year agoRM
Dr. Nagaya's commitment to ongoing collaboration with other healthcare professionals has contributed to a comprehensive approach to my mental health care. Her ability to work seamlessly with therapists and other specialities reinforces a sense of teamwork in my overall well-being.
More than 1 year agoMH
The balance Dr. Nagaya strikes between medical expertise and compassionate care is truly remarkable. She approaches each session with a genuine interest in my well-being, fostering a therapeutic relationship built on trust and understanding.
More than 1 year agoMD
In Dr. Fatima Nagaya, I've found not just a psychiatrist but a compassionate guide who has played an integral role in my journey towards mental well-being. Her commitment to individualized care, continuous learning, and advocacy is truly commendable.
More than 1 year agoCB
Dr. Fatima Nagaya, MD, has been an invaluable guide on my mental health journey. Her comprehensive understanding of the interplay between biology and psychology has provided me with a holistic perspective on my mental well-being. From our initial consultation, Dr. Nagaya's warmth and professionalism immediately created a safe space for open dialogue.
More than 1 year agoLK
I appreciate Dr. Nagaya's dedication to psychoeducation. She ensures that I have a clear understanding of my mental health condition, treatment options, and potential outcomes. This transparency has empowered me to actively participate in my own mental health journey.
More than 1 year agoVB
Collaborating with Dr. Nagaya has been a collaborative and empowering experience. She values my input in the decision-making process, creating a sense of agency in my mental health care. This partnership has been instrumental in my progress.
More than 1 year agoLG
I find Dr. Nagaya's involvement in research particularly inspiring. Knowing that she contributes to advancements in psychiatric care adds an extra layer of confidence in her expertise. Her commitment to staying informed about the latest developments is evident in our discussions.
More than 1 year agoMA
Loading...
How soon can I make an appointment with Dr. Fatima Nagaya?
Generally, Dr. Fatima Nagaya has appointments available on Zocdoc within 1 week. You can see Dr. Nagaya's earliest availability on Zocdoc and make an appointment online.
Is Dr. Fatima Nagaya accepting new patients?
Dr. Fatima Nagaya generally accepts new patients on Zocdoc. You can see Dr. Nagaya's earliest availability on Zocdoc and schedule an appointment online.
Does Dr. Fatima Nagaya accept my insurance?
Choose your insurance plan to verify if Dr. Nagaya is in-network.
Can I make an appointment with Dr. Fatima Nagaya online?
Yes, you can make an appointment online with Dr. Nagaya using Zocdoc. It’s simple, secure, and free.
What practice does Dr. Fatima Nagaya work with?
Dr. Fatima Nagaya works with BlueSky Telepsych.
Which board certifications does Dr. Fatima Nagaya have?
Dr. Fatima Nagaya is certified by American Board of Psychiatry and Neurology and Psychiatry (American Board of Psychiatry and Neurology).
What are common reasons for patients to see Dr. Fatima Nagaya?
Dr. Fatima Nagaya frequently sees patients for Anxiety, Attention-Deficit / Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD), Bipolar Disorder, Depression, and Psychiatry Consultation. You can see other visit reasons for Dr. Fatima Nagaya on their profile.
What languages does Dr. Fatima Nagaya speak?
Dr. Fatima Nagaya speaks English and Hausa.
How do patients rate Dr. Fatima Nagaya in reviews?
170 patients have reviewed Dr. Fatima Nagaya. The overall rating for this doctor is 4.89/5. They have a 4.96/5 rating for bedside manner and a 4.78/5 rating for wait time. You can read individual reviews and ratings on their profile.