What patients are saying
Overall rating
4.86
Average wait time
4.57
Bedside manner
4.91
“Highly recommended this doctor since she is affable and really cares about the patient. Overall, amazing office and amazing staff. 10/10 highly recommended.”
Jasskirat S.February 21, 2026
“Karlyn Nafey is an amazing and caring provider who genuinely cares about her patients and listens to their concerns and provides quality patient care. It is evident that she is a provider that entered her career to do her absolute best to provide comfort, empathy, and actually help people, unlike other providers who enter their careers in healthcare solely for personal gain and status. She is not just a wonderful provider, but a wonderful human being in her ability to empathetically and emotionally connect with her patients, as she's done with me in times I sat in fear in regard to my health. ”
Joan K.January 28, 2026
About Karlyn Nafey
Karlyn Nafey is a physician assistant at Jeffrey Nakhjavan in West Babylon, NY. She earned her bachelor's degree in Physician Assistant Studies from Touro College and University System, Bay Shore.
Ms. Nafey provides thorough medical care for a variety of conditions, including asthma, arthritis, allergies, hyperactive disorder, and pneumonia. She consistently delivers comprehensive care to her patients with a strong emphasis on preventative measures.
Her philosophy of practice is to assess all possible contributory factors to an illness. Ms. Nafey's clear explanations help patients better understand their treatment procedures, fostering a collaborative and informed approach to healthcare.
Is this doctor in your insurance network?
Enter your insurance carrier and plan
choose insurance
In-network insurances
99% of patients have successfully booked with these insurances
Aetna
BlueCross BlueShield
Cigna
Emblem Health
Medicare
UnitedHealthcare
UnitedHealthcare Oxford
Office location
Education and background
Practice names
Education and training
- Touro College and University System, Bay Shore, Bachelor's in Physician Assistant Studies
Awards and publications
- Bethpage Best Of Long Island 2022- Physician Assistant
Languages spoken
- English
Provider's gender
Female
NPI number
1568618460
Patient reviews
All reviews have been submitted by patients after interacting with the practice.
Overall rating
4.86
Wait time
4.57
Bedside manner
4.91
Your trust is our top concern, so providers can't pay to alter or remove reviews. We also don't publish reviews that contain any private patient health information. Learn more here
379 reviews
Most relevant
Love this office, Love Karlyn and all the PA’s. Dr. NAkhjavan is the best! You can’t go wrong no matter who you see.
October 2, 2025Nina W.Verified patient
Super amazing staff and easy to get to office. There was parking in the back and the wait time was short.
November 3, 2025Maira M.Verified patient
The doctor had great bedside manner and was very professional. She was great at explaining.
February 21, 2026Zachary V.Verified patient
I had a great experience. From the girls at the front desk to the nurse. Super sweet and kind
November 18, 2025Karen G.Verified patient
Dr. Nafey is always kind and understanding and listens to my concerns. I am so grateful that she is my doctor
March 3, 2025Initials hidden
Had the best experience. Wait time was short. Everyone was super nice and went above and beyond for me.
April 1, 2025Taylor W.Verified patient
Racist doctor. Did not want to treat me they were scared to treat me and did not have any experience
May 7, 2025Initials hidden
Karlyn Nafey goes above and beyond to make her patients feel heard and cared for.
November 17, 2025Mary H.Verified patient
Karlyn is amazing. She listens and she is empathetic. She always helps me when I’m not feeling well.
March 17, 2025Natalie V.Verified patient
She was extremely kind and attentive. Knowledgeable as well, always appreciative to find caring providers.
August 28, 2024Jessica J.Verified patient
I had a great visit today. The PA Karlyn was very attentive, a great listener and communicator.
January 20, 2025Initials hidden
The best doctors visit I’ve been to in years! Everyone is so sweet, everything was said so clear to me. 100% recommend
May 16, 2023Initials hidden
K Nafeyt is not a Doctor but PA I was not able to see
Dr.Nakahjavan who is the actual Doctor. l be seeing him on Nov. 15th.
More than 1 year agoTaj N.Verified patient
Karlyn was incredibly warm, thoughtful, and professional. I immediately felt comfortable and that I was receiving great care.
More than 1 year agoCourtney O.Verified patient
She is very attentive, friendly, and almost magnetic! Loved my experience with her.
June 13, 2025Alexandra R.Verified patient
Karlyn is an amazing provider, treats you like a human being and not just another chart to look at.
October 6, 2024Randi E.Verified patient
Karlyn was very warm and welcoming, she took her time listening to me and was very helpful
September 24, 2024Saeeda R.Verified patient
Wait was a long one but understandably so due to the current situation.
She was spectacular as were the staff.
September 29, 2020Christen O.Verified patient
I highly recommend this doctor, very friendly and professional.
August 2, 2025Daniel R.Verified patient
Very Friendly staff. Listened and made me feel very comfortable.
I highly recommend this office.
April 25, 2023David F.Verified patient
She was amazing. Would recommend to anyone looking for a great PCP
March 18, 2025Melissa N.Verified patient
Karlyn nafey is excellent, she always makes you feel comfortable and its a pleasure too see her
January 18, 2022Joan T.Verified patient
Exactly how you would want your pcp to handle a check up or we'll being.
More than 1 year agoInitials hidden
Collaborative environment. Great listener. Friendly and respectful staff. I would go back.
May 16, 2023Deenise R.Verified patient
Actually had a lot of laughs, but also, Karlyn was very thorough and took her time with the visit.
August 23, 2020Krista H.Verified patient
It was a very good experience. Office was friendly and knowledgeable.
November 21, 2024Claudia C.Verified patient
Friendly personnel and helpful
The provider is very efficient and finds the solutions.
September 6, 2022Marta H.Verified patient
fabulous staff and no wait time. Really made you feel comfortable
November 4, 2024Danielle G.Verified patient
Entire staff were very nice and made me feel confident and comfortable
April 30, 2024Anthony F.Verified patient
I already have another appt booked! I felt listened to!
More than 1 year agoInitials hidden
I absolutely loved Karlyn. She was amazing and I think my new primary!
October 7, 2023Melissa M.Verified patient
Very friendly staff .. was called in with very little wait time
November 25, 2023Jason L.Verified patient
Very friendly office staff and my PA was amazing and
June 14, 2024Stacey L.Verified patient
Great office staff, easy in easy out, & they called to follow up.
September 4, 2022Aiyanna W.Verified patient
Very professional, very courteous & caring. A very good experience.
More than 1 year agoRG
She was very pleasant and knowledgeable,she was great
December 13, 2023Joseph R.Verified patient
Amazing, warm, compassionate! The whole office is amazing
June 5, 2023Initials hidden
Highly recommended this doctor since she is affable and really cares about the patient. Overall, amazing office and amazing staff. 10/10 highly recommended.
February 21, 2026Jasskirat S.Verified patient
Great
Less than 3 months agoInitials hidden
Karlyn Nafey is an amazing and caring provider who genuinely cares about her patients and listens to their concerns and provides quality patient care. It is evident that she is a provider that entered her career to do her absolute best to provide comfort, empathy, and actually help people, unlike other providers who enter their careers in healthcare solely for personal gain and status. She is not just a wonderful provider, but a wonderful human being in her ability to empathetically and emotionally connect with her patients, as she's done with me in times I sat in fear in regard to my health.
January 28, 2026Joan K.Verified patient
I love this practice?
January 11, 2026Nina W.Verified patient
Definitely would go back, she is amazing.
December 19, 2025Michael M.Verified patient
This provider and all other providers are top notch. They genuinely care about how you’re doing and go above and beyond to give you the best care.
November 26, 2025Marlene F.Verified patient
Amazing job I went in for symptoms I had and told her she was amazing listening to me very sweet and she ran test immediately 10/10 she the best ever
November 25, 2025Mya T.Verified patient
Karlyn is wonderful. Great bedside manner & a great listener. Always greets me with a smile & makes me feel at ease. The office is always friendly & there’s little to no wait.
November 21, 2025Michele S.Verified patient
My first appointment with PA Karlyn Nafey was outstanding. She surpassed all of my expectations with her extensive knowledge, down-to-earth demeanor and compassionate approach. I was especially impressed with the way she took the time to listen and carefully address each one of my concerns. I truly felt heard. Plus, I was able to get blood work, a pulmonary function test, EEG, etc., right in the office. I had an overall amazing experience and I'm happy to say that I found my new PCP. I highly recommend PA Karlyn Nafey, she is the whole package!
September 23, 2025Gloria D.Verified patient
She took the time to listen to me, dove into my family history in order to properly check me. Half the staff is really nice, the others don’t say much (like night and day) no one is rude or mean. Wait time varies but never been more than 30 min.
September 23, 2025Isaias A.Verified patient
Dr. Nafey is truly amazing! She made me feel comfortable right away, took the time to listen without rushing, and put me at ease about my health concerns. She explained everything clearly and provided a thoughtful care plan moving forward. She made me feel like she genuinely cares about my health and well-being. I’m so grateful to have found her and would highly recommend her to anyone looking for a compassionate, thorough provider.
Less than 1 year agoInitials hidden
The PA and staff announced a private concern of mine and the entire staff was laughing at me. I was completely embarrassed and would never go back to the office again.
August 19, 2025Cameron B.Verified patient
The doc was super knowledgeable, kind, down to earth… everything you want in a doctor! Immediately became my primary moving forward.
July 31, 2025Isaias A.Verified patient
Loading...
How soon can I make an appointment with Karlyn Nafey?
Generally, Karlyn Nafey has appointments available on Zocdoc within 1 week. You can see Karlyn Nafey's earliest availability on Zocdoc and make an appointment online.
Is Karlyn Nafey accepting new patients?
Karlyn Nafey generally accepts new patients on Zocdoc. You can see Karlyn Nafey's earliest availability on Zocdoc and schedule an appointment online.
Does Karlyn Nafey accept my insurance?
Choose your insurance plan to verify if Karlyn Nafey is in-network.
Can I make an appointment with Karlyn Nafey online?
Yes, you can make an appointment online with Karlyn Nafey using Zocdoc. It’s simple, secure, and free.
What practice does Karlyn Nafey work with?
Karlyn Nafey works with Jeffrey Nakhjavan.
Where is Karlyn Nafey's office located?
Karlyn Nafey's office is located at 760 Sunrise Hwy, West Babylon, NY 11704.
What are common reasons for patients to see Karlyn Nafey?
Karlyn Nafey frequently sees patients for Annual Physical, Arthritis, Illness, Sleep Problems, and Sports Injury. You can see other visit reasons for Karlyn Nafey on their profile.
What languages does Karlyn Nafey speak?
Karlyn Nafey speaks English.
How do patients rate Karlyn Nafey in reviews?
379 patients have reviewed Karlyn Nafey. The overall rating for this doctor is 4.86/5. They have a 4.91/5 rating for bedside manner and a 4.57/5 rating for wait time. You can read individual reviews and ratings on their profile.