What patients are saying
Overall rating
4.94
Average wait time
4.61
Bedside manner
4.97
“I received full and candid explanations of my injury. I would return if I had any more orthopedic issues.”
Initials hiddenJanuary 18, 2026
“Friendly staff. I had a similar injury before. They listened, examined and communicated the next steps in alignment with what I’ve gone through in the past”
Initials hiddenLess than 6 months ago
About Madeline Myrtetus
Madeline Myrtetus, PA-C, is a nationally certified and New York State licensed physician assistant specializing in orthopedics. Under the direction of Dr. Sameh Elguizaoui, Madeline manages all aspects of patient care, including diagnosis, treatment, patient education, interpreting diagnostic tests, and assisting Dr. Elguizaoui in surgery.
Madeline completed her undergraduate education at the University of Virginia, earning a Bachelor of Science in Kinesiology. While at UVA, she participated in the Sports Medicine Student Athletic Training program and worked with several athletic teams. After graduation, she worked as an Emergency Department technician in Doylestown, PA. Madeline furthered her education at Arcadia University, where she earned a Master of Science in Physician Assistant Studies.
Is this doctor in your insurance network?
Enter your insurance carrier and plan
choose insurance
In-network insurances
99% of patients have successfully booked with these insurances
Aetna
BlueCross BlueShield
UnitedHealthcare
UnitedHealthcare Oxford
Office locations
NY Orthopedics - Lenox Hill Greenwich Village (1 of 6)
200 W 13th St, 6th Fl, New York, NY 10011
NY Orthopedics - Scarsdale Orthopedics (2 of 6)
2 Overhill Rd, Ste 310, Scarsdale, NY 10583
1 of 6
Education and background
Practice names
Board certifications
- National Commission on Certification of Physician Assistants
Education and training
- Arcadia University, Master's in Physician Assistant Studies
- University of Virginia (Bachelor's)
Languages spoken
- English
Provider's gender
Female
NPI number
1902590953
Patient reviews
All reviews have been submitted by patients after interacting with the practice.
Overall rating
4.94
Wait time
4.61
Bedside manner
4.97
Your trust is our top concern, so providers can't pay to alter or remove reviews. We also don't publish reviews that contain any private patient health information. Learn more here
449 reviews
Most relevant
I received full and candid explanations of my injury. I would return if I had any more orthopedic issues.
January 18, 2026Initials hidden
A great doctor!! Made me feel so comfortable and informed me of my condition while answering all my questions thoroughly.
July 21, 2025Jessica S.Verified patient
The office staff was great when I booked the appointment then sent a email & a tex the doctor was super
November 26, 2025Shlomo W.Verified patient
I rally appreciated how quickly she got back to me when I sent a question the day after my appointment.
October 20, 2025Nancy R.Verified patient
Super clear in communication, easy to understand and feel like I was listened to / thoroughly evaluated. Thanks!
July 21, 2025Initials hidden
Very sweet, funny and relatable. Listened to my concerns and set me up to get checked properly
January 6, 2026Aaron W.Verified patient
Great and quick visit, have all my questions answered with clear treatment plan and future injury preventions!
May 11, 2025Karina T.Verified patient
Great listener, understood my lifestyle & injury for a clear recovery process!
March 17, 2026Anna B.Verified patient
I highly recommend Maddie. She is so knowledgeable. And extremely pleasant. A good listener. I highly recommend her.
December 2, 2024Ann S.Verified patient
Great place, friendly staff, and the Doctor answered all my questions with good bedside manner.
Less than 1 year agoPhillip A.Verified patient
Overall great experience but the wait time for an xray took a lot longer than expected.
September 3, 2025Anjelica C.Verified patient
The wait time was about 25 minutes, and it was the only slightly negative experience. Overall, I recommend it.
September 3, 2024Initials hidden
Super quick and easy diagnosis! I felt listened to and reassured
March 26, 2026Zoe H.Verified patient
I was extremely happy with PA Marilyn’s knowledge, bedside manner, and efficiency.
September 15, 2025Cathy S.Verified patient
It was an amazing experience, everyone from the front end to the back were soo polite!
July 29, 2025Natasha S.Verified patient
Quick appointment, prompt service, friendly support and professional staff, convenient X-ray, it was great.
July 22, 2024Johnny A.Verified patient
This was the best experience I've had in a doctor's office. Madeline Myrtetus was such a pleasure!
January 30, 2025Michael K.Verified patient
everyone was kind and worked efficiently, no wait time. i felt seen and heard. will go back for sure.
More than 1 year agoJulia K.Verified patient
Great experience, was able to be diagnosed and given medical advice on how to treat my issue.
More than 1 year agoInitials hidden
Great! Attentive and knowledge about my condition. Huge help
November 20, 2025Initials hidden
Very nice process, very thorough, and has a good bedside manner. I have no complaints
September 19, 2024Julius G.Verified patient
Great experience! Super straightforward, helpful and empathetic. Highly recommend.
November 7, 2024Daisy L.Verified patient
Good questions, active listening, thoughtful explanations, sympathetic expertise!
April 3, 2024John R.Verified patient
Very efficient office. Everything is done just right.
July 3, 2025Jennifer P.Verified patient
everyone there was very nice and respectful. they call fast and treat you well
March 14, 2024Freddy G.Verified patient
Highly recommended. Very professional. Very knowledgeable.
March 28, 2025Ian W.Verified patient
Perfect experience. I would recommend this office.
June 4, 2025Jennifer P.Verified patient
Madeline was very thorough and staff very attentive. Highly recommend
June 13, 2024Manuel S.Verified patient
Everyone was so nice and I had a great experience!
August 5, 2024Nicholas D.Verified patient
Everyone was extremely friendly and accommodating!
July 30, 2024Ivan D.Verified patient
I had a great experience. Madeline was very helpful!
March 21, 2024Initials hidden
Maddie was great! Kind, attentive, and personable.
April 5, 2024Hunter W.Verified patient
Excellent experience !!!!
March 28, 2026Alice H.Verified patient
Smart efficient and caring 100%
February 4, 2026Christopher F.Verified patient
Friendly staff. I had a similar injury before. They listened, examined and communicated the next steps in alignment with what I’ve gone through in the past
Less than 6 months agoInitials hidden
They were great. I had an appointment for 9 AM and my excessive ride came very late called them up and they rescheduled me for 945 and I was able to keep the appointment for today. I mean that was amazing. Keep up the great work thank you.
December 8, 2025Shlomo W.Verified patient
My visit was very pleasant. The staff was very warm and friendly. The Doctor (PA) was very knowledgeable and explained her findings to me clearly. My wait time was less than 10 minutes. I would definitely recommend family and friends to her.
November 22, 2025Loretta P.Verified patient
Madeline was nice and helpful. All the staff I interacted with were helpful and polite. Imaging floor was a little backed up but not too crazy.
November 6, 2025Initials hidden
I hurt my knee and had a same day appointment, knee X-rays and both an exam and knee injection. Very professional and efficient!
November 4, 2025james E.Verified patient
Everyone was so kind and very professional, knowledgeable, and helpful. I wish I could take them all back to my hometown. Madeline has an exceptional manner,, so caring and informative . She answered all my questions and helped me with next steps once I get back home. Thank you.
November 2, 2025Gail G.Verified patient
I was not informed by the office that the insurance company denied the claim for the cortisone injections and then later approved them.
November 2, 2025Patricia E.Verified patient
Patient, thorough, kind.
October 18, 2025Leah M.Verified patient
NY Orthopedics is such an efficiently run office! The staff are so friendly, and Madeline Myrtetus, PA was awesome. I felt comfortable, listened to, and I'll definitely be coming back.
October 17, 2025Initials hidden
Proximity to work made travel easy. All prior paperwork was done thru the app and only thing was to pay my copay and wait for my appointment. Everyone was friendly and got the necessary treatment with proper explanation.
October 14, 2025Liju A.Verified patient
Dr. Myrtetus was incredibly kind and warm, with an excellent bedside manner. She saw my 11-year-old son and was able to connect with him right away, making him feel comfortable and open to talking. I truly appreciated how clearly she explained her approach and the time she took with us. Doctors with such warmth and a genuine spirit are hard to find, I can’t recommend her highly enough.
October 10, 2025Bronx M.Verified patient
Good
October 9, 2025Liudmila M.Verified patient
Dr. Myrtetus was extremely sweet, personable, and extremely helpful. She made me feel comfortable, listened to me, and solved my problem very quickly. I was thrilled with my visit.
October 3, 2025Julia F.Verified patient
The doctor is a friendly and caring individual and treated me with kindness and was happy to answer all my questions and discuss options for treatment.
September 26, 2025Joshua D.Verified patient
Excellent. Very well cared for.
September 19, 2025Jane Tainow F.Verified patient
Great experience.
Less than 1 year agoInitials hidden
Loading...
How soon can I make an appointment with Madeline Myrtetus?
Generally, Madeline Myrtetus has appointments available on Zocdoc within 1 week. You can see Madeline Myrtetus's earliest availability on Zocdoc and make an appointment online.
Is Madeline Myrtetus accepting new patients?
Madeline Myrtetus generally accepts new patients on Zocdoc. You can see Madeline Myrtetus's earliest availability on Zocdoc and schedule an appointment online.
Does Madeline Myrtetus accept my insurance?
Choose your insurance plan to verify if Madeline Myrtetus is in-network.
Can I make an appointment with Madeline Myrtetus online?
Yes, you can make an appointment online with Madeline Myrtetus using Zocdoc. It’s simple, secure, and free.
What practice does Madeline Myrtetus work with?
Madeline Myrtetus works with NY Orthopedics.
Where is Madeline Myrtetus's office located?
Madeline Myrtetus has 6 office locations, including in New York, Scarsdale, and Brooklyn, view full addresses on Madeline Myrtetus's profile.
Which board certifications does Madeline Myrtetus have?
Madeline Myrtetus is certified by National Commission on Certification of Physician Assistants.
What are common reasons for patients to see Madeline Myrtetus?
Madeline Myrtetus frequently sees patients for Hand Problems, New Patient Visit, Orthopedic Consultation, Sports Injury, and Surgery Consultation. You can see other visit reasons for Madeline Myrtetus on their profile.
What languages does Madeline Myrtetus speak?
Madeline Myrtetus speaks English.
How do patients rate Madeline Myrtetus in reviews?
449 patients have reviewed Madeline Myrtetus. The overall rating for this doctor is 4.94/5. They have a 4.97/5 rating for bedside manner and a 4.61/5 rating for wait time. You can read individual reviews and ratings on their profile.