What patients are saying
Overall rating
4.84
Average wait time
4.63
Bedside manner
4.87
“Dr. Siegel is an amazing Podiatrist! In the distant past had tried a few others, but she absolutely stands out for her very gentle and excelleny technical skill, compassion, and my feet always leave her office in a pain free, happy and more attractive appearance. The office is very clean and pleasant and the rest of her team is also always a pleasure to deal with. ”
susan B.March 27, 2026
“The office is very clean. The staff is very nice. He took me in quickly. Did the x-rays quickly and then I met with the doctor Wendy is a wonderful doctor and she has an excellent bedside manner. I would recommend this to anybody.”
Melissa C.March 5, 2025
About Dr. Wendy Siegel
Dr. Wendy Siegel is a compassionate, analytical podiatrist treating patients in the Smithtown and greater New York areas. She operates out of Gold Cost Podiatry and combines a caring approach with the latest technology to ensure that her patients receive the highest quality of care. Her office is also flexible, allowing patients to receive care whenever it is most convenient for them.
For her undergraduate degree, Dr. Siegel attended the University of Pennsylvania, which led her to a position as a systems engineer for the IBM Corporation. She pursued her medical degree at the New York College of Podiatric Medicine. She received her surgical training at St. Barnabas Hospital.
Patients visiting Dr. Siegel can receive a full range of podiatric care. She offers some of the latest procedures, including laser treatment of toenail fungus, external fixation, bone-lengthening procedures, and joint replacements. Surgical care for hammertoes and bunions is also available. When she is not treating patients, Dr. Siegel enjoys classical music and learning to fly airplanes. She is also a New York Rangers fanatic.
Is this doctor in your insurance network?
Enter your insurance carrier and plan
choose insurance
In-network insurances
99% of patients have successfully booked with these insurances
Aetna
BlueCross BlueShield
Cigna
Emblem Health
Medicare
UnitedHealthcare
UnitedHealthcare Oxford
Office location
Dr. Wendy Siegel, DPM also offers online video visits for patients
Education and background
Practice names
Education and training
- New York College of Podiatric Medicine, Doctor of Podiatric Medicine
- Saint Barnabas Hospital, Residency in Surgery
- University of Pennsylvania (Bachelor’s)
Professional memberships
- American College of Foot and Ankle Surgeons
- Association for the Advancement of Wound Care
Languages spoken
- English
- Spanish
- Italian
Provider's gender
Female
NPI number
1184622763
Patient reviews
All reviews have been submitted by patients after interacting with the practice.
Overall rating
4.84
Wait time
4.63
Bedside manner
4.87
Your trust is our top concern, so providers can't pay to alter or remove reviews. We also don't publish reviews that contain any private patient health information. Learn more here
178 reviews
Most relevant
Great experience! Very compassionate and great listener. I feel very confident that I finally have a wonderful podiatrist!
December 5, 2024Mia D.Verified patient
Dr Siegel was very pleasant and took the time to explain options to me regarding the foot issues I am experiencing.
October 15, 2024Patricia M.Verified patient
No wait at all. Staff took me back and did all the prep before I saw the doctor. Doctor was very attentive and personable.
March 3, 2022Lorna W.Verified patient
Dr. was very thorough and took the time to explain. Personable. Staff was very friendly and caring. I had a good experience.
July 24, 2017Linda Y.Verified patient
Dr. Siegel was professional. Her staff is courteous and friendly. I've already recommended Dr. Siegel to family and friends.
July 28, 2014Eileen K.Verified patient
She is very friendly. Very professional. Easy to talk to, and would tell others about her. Office clerks also very nice.
September 25, 2015Janet C.Verified patient
Dr. Siegel is an excellent doctor. Her knowledge combined with her "bedside" manner are a true credit to her profession.
January 6, 2013Robert M.Verified patient
No pain! Very, very compassionate Dr. Very professional, by doctor, staff, admins. Wish I'd watched here a long tim
January 13, 2021Mary K.Verified patient
Very professional and thorough during examination, very pleased will definitely stay with her as my new foot care Dr.
September 16, 2020Luis M.Verified patient
It was my first visit to a DPM. It was informative and useful.
The staff was friendly and Dr.Seigel was very helpful.
February 2, 2013Initials hidden
It was an excellent experience. Dr. Siegel is truly knowledgeable and her skills and bedside manner was excellent.
September 29, 2014Derrick W.Verified patient
Dr. Siegel and her staff are extremely professional and friendly. I would highly recommend to anyone needing care.
More than 1 year agoMS
WAS CONFIDENT THAT DR. SIEGEL WOULD BE ABLE TO HELP
December 17, 2025Initials hidden
Great doctor, knows the latest medical procedures, kind and wants to help. Wait time was very long, however.
More than 1 year agoInitials hidden
They were very friendly and professional. Great experience. Thank you.
March 9, 2025Roy D.Verified patient
Very thorough...explain everything in detail...very friendly staff...best podiatrist I've seen so far
January 27, 2014Aprell W.Verified patient
Very pleasant staff and the doctor was extremely patient and thorough.... Really great appointment.
February 16, 2015Erica V.Verified patient
She saw my spn who is eight and her and her staff were Very caring and made him feel comfortable...
More than 1 year agoInitials hidden
I had a great experience. The Dr and staff are great. Would definitely recommend.
September 7, 2023Gina K.Verified patient
Wendy is very professional and and personable. Office staff is friendly and efficient.
August 15, 2017Robert P.Verified patient
Extremely knowledgeable, patient, caring and professional. What a refreshing experience.
More than 1 year agoInitials hidden
Very happy and pleased with the service I received from Dr. Wendy Siegel and her staff.
January 10, 2013Kathleen K.Verified patient
Everything went very well with the visit and I was completely satisfied with the care.
June 19, 2015Stewart S.Verified patient
Office staff was welcoming. Dr. Siegel put me at ease and answered all my questions.
April 26, 2014Initials hidden
Everyone was pleasant and helpful. Very understanding, an listened to my concerns.
July 22, 2021Adrienne C.Verified patient
Was pleasant not sure why they needed to take xrays
October 11, 2024Walter P.Verified patient
Glad I went. Have a good treatment plan and I expect to have good results.
More than 1 year agoTheodore K.Verified patient
Doctor took her time explain everything. Very thorough
March 28, 2024marie V.Verified patient
Very personable to the point. Helpful . I would recommend her to anyone
More than 1 year agoRosa P.Verified patient
She was very helpful and informative. I will continue to use her.
More than 1 year agoChristinamarie L.Verified patient
She works well with kids and made my daughter very comfortable!
More than 1 year agoAndrea R.Verified patient
She was very thorough and explained everything clearly.
June 12, 2015Dianne F.Verified patient
I liked The Dr and the staff were also very nice
September 15, 2014Victoria G.Verified patient
Dr. Siegel is an amazing Podiatrist! In the distant past had tried a few others, but she absolutely stands out for her very gentle and excelleny technical skill, compassion, and my feet always leave her office in a pain free, happy and more attractive appearance. The office is very clean and pleasant and the rest of her team is also always a pleasure to deal with.
March 27, 2026susan B.Verified patient
Excellent care
March 9, 2026Gina K.Verified patient
Great care, listened to my concrns
November 7, 2025John B.Verified patient
The office is very clean. The staff is very nice. He took me in quickly. Did the x-rays quickly and then I met with the doctor Wendy is a wonderful doctor and she has an excellent bedside manner. I would recommend this to anybody.
March 5, 2025Melissa C.Verified patient
Dr Siegel is friendly and professional, spending the time necessary for routine care and to investigate specific issues by listening to the patient. Very good experience.
February 7, 2025Joanne D.Verified patient
Was very satisfied will recommend
January 24, 2025Michael H.Verified patient
Dr. Siegel was friendly and knowledgeable, and she explained all of my treatment options in detail. My appointment did not feel rushed at all. Her staff was courteous and the office is very clean. Since I was a new patient, I appreciated that Dr. Siegel took the time to review my forms and the reason for my visit prior to the time of my appointment, so we were immediately able to discuss my issues instead of her wasting time by reviewing my intake forms while I was there. Most doctors are notorious for wasting a patient’s time by reviewing their forms upon entering the exam room, in which case we may as well fill out the forms together, and then the appointment is rushed. Dr. Siegel was fully prepared as soon as she walked into the exam room. I would highly recommend her to anyone who is in need of a foot specialist.
January 9, 2025Diana R.Verified patient
I had difficulty finding a podiatrist in my insurance network close to my home.
I travel to Smithtown for other services so I decided to look in that area. Gold Coast podiatry showed an available appointment within a week and luckily on the same day I was going to be in the area so I booked it. With an a half hour, Gold Coast podiatry contacted me to let me know that the time I requested was was not available. I explained that I would be in the area and would it be possible to see Dr Siegel at a different time. Dr. Siegel agreed to see me during her lunchtime.
From the moment I walked in the office, I was greeted with enthusiasm. I Expressed my gratitude for their accommodations. Lori, Joe and Dr. Siegel Were friendly, patient and informative! I will continue to travel an hour each direction to be treated by the expert staff at Gold Coast podiatry!
April 15, 2024Jennifer S.Verified patient
Received call from the office several hours before the appointment and readjusted appt time due to ‘conflict in schedule’. Staff was pleasant and polite. Office was clean and welcoming. Dr. Siegel was very pleasant and informed me of what she was doing. Based on initial visit, I would give it a ‘ten’ on a scale of 1-10.
December 19, 2023Arlene D.Verified patient
Dr. Siegel is professional and friendly. She was good at explaining what had to be done and why. The doctor can perform x-rays right in the office, which saves time and a trip to an outside lab. The only qualm might be Zocdoc's issue: the site indicated a 3:00 appointment, which was also emailed and texted to me, but the office said it was 4:00. Then we're asked if we could come in the next day but we couldn't since my wife was in pain. (Oddly, the next day was a Friday; we had stopped by during office hours to drop something off and there was no one there!) They actually squeezed us in earlier between appointments that same day.
Don't use the "text us" link on the website: It pops up an email address so you won't get a timely response.
More than 1 year agoInitials hidden
Dr. Siegel was great. She is down to earth, listens, asks questions. Very personable. All the qualities you want in a dr. I’ll be going back in November for a follow up.
August 29, 2023Linda B.Verified patient
Excellent doctor and staff, highly recommend to anyone in need of a podiatrist. Very thorough, leaves no questions unanswered. Was very relieved after my visit.
August 3, 2023Alesia R.Verified patient
What a wonderful experience! I can’t say enough. The Dr. Is kind, very bright and patient. Took all the time I needed to explain things. The office staff could not have been any nicer. What a wonderful office. I highly, highly recommend.
February 15, 2023Initials hidden
Everyone there are very friendly, the office is very clean and they really go out of their way to help. I would highly recommend them to everyone I know and I will.
September 17, 2022Joe D.Verified patient
I was treated for a painful problem on my foot. The doctor explained what I have and is fixing it with medication and had some removal of the soreness. I found out about my other conditions today that will be treated immediately. All nurses and staff were business like and helpful. I recommend this doctor for you to see for your foot problems.
March 11, 2022Debra H.Verified patient
Highly Highly recommend Dr Siegel. I came in for foot pain and I am already feeling so much better... I suggest you run, not walk to her for help! Her office staff is amazing too. Had a great experience.
October 28, 2021Christine L.Verified patient
Dr. Siegel is highly professional and very friendly…she takes the time to listen to your concerns and provides options to help solve your problem…overall successful visit! Thank you!!
More than 1 year agoInitials hidden
Loading...
How soon can I make an appointment with Dr. Wendy Siegel?
Generally, Dr. Wendy Siegel has appointments available on Zocdoc within 1 week. You can see Dr. Siegel's earliest availability on Zocdoc and make an appointment online.
Is Dr. Wendy Siegel accepting new patients?
Dr. Wendy Siegel generally accepts new patients on Zocdoc. You can see Dr. Siegel's earliest availability on Zocdoc and schedule an appointment online.
Does Dr. Wendy Siegel accept my insurance?
Choose your insurance plan to verify if Dr. Siegel is in-network.
Can I make an appointment with Dr. Wendy Siegel online?
Yes, you can make an appointment online with Dr. Siegel using Zocdoc. It’s simple, secure, and free.
What practice does Dr. Wendy Siegel work with?
Dr. Wendy Siegel works with Gold Coast Podiatry.
Where is Dr. Wendy Siegel's office located?
Dr. Wendy Siegel has 2 office locations in Smithtown, view full addresses on Dr. Siegel's profile.
What are common reasons for patients to see Dr. Wendy Siegel?
Dr. Wendy Siegel frequently sees patients for Foot Consultation, Foot Pain, Foot Problems, Podiatric Care, and X-ray. You can see other visit reasons for Dr. Wendy Siegel on their profile.
What languages does Dr. Wendy Siegel speak?
Dr. Wendy Siegel speaks English, Spanish, and Italian.
How do patients rate Dr. Wendy Siegel in reviews?
178 patients have reviewed Dr. Wendy Siegel. The overall rating for this doctor is 4.84/5. They have a 4.87/5 rating for bedside manner and a 4.63/5 rating for wait time. You can read individual reviews and ratings on their profile.