What patients are saying
Overall rating
4.91
Average wait time
4.57
Bedside manner
4.94
“I was very happy that I was able to get a same day appointment. Dr. Gotlin and his staff were friendly and I am already scheduled for an MRI of my knee. ”
Initials hiddenFebruary 28, 2026
“Dr Matthew is great. He answered all my questions, and was very confident in the diagnostics which calmed me down. ”
Initials hiddenLess than 3 months ago
About Dr. Matthew Gotlin
Dr. Matthew Gotlin is a fellowship-trained orthopedic surgeon who specializes in sports medicine. His clinical focus is the operative and non-operative treatment of athletes of all ages and skill levels. In addition to athletes, he cares for patients who are looking to remain active and healthy. Dr. Gotlin is trained in advanced arthroscopy, complex reconstruction, and cartilage restoration procedures of the hip, knee, ankle, shoulder, and elbow. He also performs joint replacements for arthritis of the hip, knee, and shoulder. In addition, Dr. Gotlin treats fractures of both the upper and lower extremities.
Dr. Gotlin is a Magna Cum Laude graduate from Penn State University’s Eberly College of Science. He completed medical school at the Stony Brook School of Medicine in New York. At Stony Brook he was inducted into the Alpha Omega Alpha Honors Society, recipient of the Stony Brook School of Medicine Academic Merit Award, and recipient of the overall Clinical Excellence award. He then completed his orthopedic surgery residency training at the prestigious NYU Langone Orthopedic Hospital in New York City. He was the recipient of the 2019 Herodicus Award for Best Resident Paper at the AOSSM annual meeting. During his final year of residency he was selected and served as Executive Chief Resident.
After residency, Dr. Gotlin completed a fellowship in Orthopedic Sports Medicine and Arthroscopy at Lenox Hill Hospital in New York City . Dr. Gotlin is currently the team physician for the Harlem Wizards men’s professional basketball team. He has served as an assistant team physician for the NFL’s New York Jets, the NFL scouting combine, and the National Women’s Hockey League’s Metropolitan Riveters.
Dr. Gotlin has published numerous book chapters and scientific papers in peer-reviewed journals. He is a member of the American Orthopedic Society for Sports Medicine, Arthroscopy Association of North America, and the American Association of Orthopaedic Medicine.
Is this doctor in your insurance network?
Enter your insurance carrier and plan
choose insurance
In-network insurances
99% of patients have successfully booked with these insurances
Aetna
BlueCross BlueShield
UnitedHealthcare
UnitedHealthcare Oxford
Office locations
NY Orthopedics - Scarsdale Orthopedics (2 of 6)
2 Overhill Rd, Ste 310, Scarsdale, NY 10583
NY Orthopedics - Lenox Hill Greenwich Village (4 of 6)
200 W 13th St, 6th Fl, New York, NY 10011
1 of 6
Education and background
Practice names
Education and training
- Medical School - State University of New York, Stony Brook, Doctor of Medicine
- NYU Langone Orthopedic Hospital, Residency in Orthopedic Surgery
- Pennsylvania State University (Bachelor's)
- Lenox Hill Hospital, Fellowship in Orthopedic Sports Medicine and Arthroscopy
Professional memberships
- American Orthopaedic Society for Sports Medicine
- American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons
- American Medical Association
Awards and publications
- Dr. Gotlin has been Awarded The 2019 Herodicus Award for Best Resident Paper at the AOSSM Annual Meeting
- Dr. Gotlin has been Awarded Stony Brook School of Medicine- Award for Clinical Excellence
- Dr. Gotlin has been Awarded Stony Brook School of Medicine Academic Merit Award
- Dr. Gotlin has been Awarded Alpha Omega Alpha Honor Society
- Dr. Gotlin has been Awarded Phi Beta Kappa Honors Society
Languages spoken
- English
Provider's gender
Male
NPI number
1891141560
Patient reviews
All reviews have been submitted by patients after interacting with the practice.
Overall rating
4.91
Wait time
4.57
Bedside manner
4.94
Your trust is our top concern, so providers can't pay to alter or remove reviews. We also don't publish reviews that contain any private patient health information. Learn more here
1071 reviews
Most relevant
Dr Matthew is great. He answered all my questions, and was very confident in the diagnostics which calmed me down.
Less than 3 months agoInitials hidden
Dr. Gotlin and his P.A. met with me, were friendly and efficient, and gave me a clear plan for an M.R.I. and then treatment.
November 11, 2025Michael D.Verified patient
Dr Gotlin was easy to talk to and was incredibly professional. I would recommend him to anyone.
March 19, 2026Matt T.Verified patient
Dr. Gotlin was professional but proved personal attention. I felt heard and immediately trusted him.
February 13, 2026Laura B.Verified patient
Dr. Gotlin was very professional and friendly. He gave me options about my knee and explained every detail.
November 20, 2025John G.Verified patient
Great phusician. Trust worthy. I respect and admire him very much . I am glad that he serving the Nanuet Community.
May 8, 2025Bhupendra S.Verified patient
Everything and everyone was very friendly, very polite to explain everything
March 30, 2026Olga M.Verified patient
Very personable physician. Well-spoken and communicative. New offices in process of getting organized but generally well run.
July 4, 2024Marianne G.Verified patient
The doctor was very friendly and easy to speak with!! I definitely would recommend him!
December 9, 2025Janet P.Verified patient
Dr Gotlin was very friendly, a good communicator, and flexible to squeeze me in before upcoming travel!
June 25, 2025Devon N.Verified patient
Dr. Gotlin was very friendly, courteous, understanding & knowledgeable.
Explained all aspects of the injury &
surgery..
August 1, 2024Maryann E.Verified patient
The Doctor was very professional, and he takes his time to listen to your concerns.
December 8, 2025Steve L.Verified patient
Excellent doctor. Explained the diagnosis clearly, answered all questions, explained follow up, did not rush me. Great find.
July 6, 2023Leo N.Verified patient
Yes I recommend Dr. Gotlin to friends and family and colleagues and the staff was very helpful and very nice.
September 6, 2024Manuel R.Verified patient
He is an excellent diagnostician and looks to find ways to help you heal without surgery
Less than 1 year agoInitials hidden
The office staff was very professional and friendly.Doctor took time to listen my problem . Very friendly and knowledgeable.
May 15, 2023Ponnamma K.Verified patient
Dr. Gotlin had excellent bedside manner. He was thorough and knowledgeable and answered all my questions! Highly recommend
June 1, 2023Arielle J.Verified patient
Works fast and clearly discusses tire symptoms - takes X-rays and prescribed meds- easy communication through the portal
June 15, 2023Mark M.Verified patient
Dr.Gotlin has been a huge help to me as I work through some arthritis issues in my knees
June 6, 2025William M.Verified patient
The whole experience was a great visit and very good doctor.
February 27, 2026Mia E.Verified patient
Straightforward and clear help with my issue. I would highly recommend.
November 2, 2025Jonathan C.Verified patient
very knowledgeable, good listener explain my situation in clear manner.
and made fells confident I was in good hands.
May 30, 2023Xochitl T.Verified patient
I’m a senior and I found Dr Gotlin well versed and aware of the particular problems of aging joints and old injuries.
June 6, 2023Initials hidden
Doctor was through and took his time answering questions and provide information. He is knowledgeable and friendly.
February 28, 2023Initials hidden
Very kind and knowledgeable doctor, friendly staff. Doctor spent time discussing my injury and expected treatment plan.
September 21, 2022Darlene Y.Verified patient
Very friendly doctor and staff! Highly recommend as a new patient.
December 4, 2025Amaka N.Verified patient
Everything was super quick, easy, and very professional, definitely recommend.
July 14, 2025Shuyu M.Verified patient
Dr. Communicated well and listened to me. Felt comfortable and got the treatment I needed.
January 7, 2025Crystal C.Verified patient
Quick and efficient. Short wait time. Convenient to public transportation. Doctor had good bedside manner.
September 21, 2023Nneka U.Verified patient
Very nice doctor. Answered all my questions with details
January 4, 2026Song Z.Verified patient
He was friendly, listened carefully to what I had to say and respected my level of comfort as he tested for ROM
More than 1 year agoInitials hidden
Dr. Gotlin very knowledgeable and did not rush. I left the office at ease. Great staff and bedside manner.
June 19, 2023Melanie R.Verified patient
First experience with Dr Gotlin and it was great. He was very clear with his assessment and what’s ahead.
June 14, 2023Ricky M.Verified patient
Dr. Gotlin is an excellent listener and takes the time to understand your concerns. I highly recommend him!
January 19, 2023Beth K.Verified patient
Yes I would definitely go back. The doctor was very helpful.
October 31, 2025Mary Ann M.Verified patient
Good exeprience overall. There was a 45-60 minute wait, but the care I received from provider was excellent.
More than 1 year agoInitials hidden
They whole staff treated me well my first time there. Yes I’m going back for follow up.
October 21, 2024Anne Marie B.Verified patient
Very nice and efficient office
Loved the doctor and PA
December 15, 2025Aline R.Verified patient
Very reassuring and confident appraisal with constructive follow-up steps
April 8, 2025Thomas M.Verified patient
Dr. Gotlin and the staff is great. I highly recommend this practice.
May 30, 2025Donna O.Verified patient
Doctor was knowledgeable and provided good feedback. Recommended follow ups to clarify the problem
June 6, 2023Carlton G.Verified patient
Great doctor! Very knowledgeable and helpful with his advice. Would recommend him and would go back.
June 2, 2023Hannah B.Verified patient
Great doctor, very thorough and patient with all questions.
September 8, 2025Shane T.Verified patient
Dr Gotlin is very thorough and takes the time to explain every procedure and answers questions.
August 30, 2023Christopher B.Verified patient
so so good. would recommend for anyone experiencing ortho related issues. very thorough and helpful
April 4, 2023Jaren R.Verified patient
Dr. Gotlin addressed my questions and concerns economically and sympathetically. Highly recommend!
April 3, 2023Stephen M.Verified patient
All was great,but the parking is not validated and tough to find.
Less than 1 year agoInitials hidden
Thorough exam, helpful explanation and very good bedside manner. And prompt (morning appointment).
December 29, 2022Initials hidden
Great service, waiting time very short, and the doctor is great. Highly recommend.
More than 1 year agoInitials hidden
Attentive doctor who diagnosed me without prescribing unnecessary additional testing, scanning.
January 5, 2023Shanti A.Verified patient
Loading...
How soon can I make an appointment with Dr. Matthew Gotlin?
Generally, Dr. Matthew Gotlin has appointments available on Zocdoc within 1 week. You can see Dr. Gotlin's earliest availability on Zocdoc and make an appointment online.
Is Dr. Matthew Gotlin accepting new patients?
Dr. Matthew Gotlin generally accepts new patients on Zocdoc. You can see Dr. Gotlin's earliest availability on Zocdoc and schedule an appointment online.
Does Dr. Matthew Gotlin accept my insurance?
Choose your insurance plan to verify if Dr. Gotlin is in-network.
Can I make an appointment with Dr. Matthew Gotlin online?
Yes, you can make an appointment online with Dr. Gotlin using Zocdoc. It’s simple, secure, and free.
What practice does Dr. Matthew Gotlin work with?
Dr. Matthew Gotlin works with NY Orthopedics.
Where is Dr. Matthew Gotlin's office located?
Dr. Matthew Gotlin has 6 office locations, including in New York, Scarsdale, and Nanuet, view full addresses on Dr. Gotlin's profile.
What are common reasons for patients to see Dr. Matthew Gotlin?
Dr. Matthew Gotlin frequently sees patients for Arthritis, Knee Problems, Orthopedic Consultation, Sports Injury, and Surgery Consultation. You can see other visit reasons for Dr. Matthew Gotlin on their profile.
What languages does Dr. Matthew Gotlin speak?
Dr. Matthew Gotlin speaks English.
How do patients rate Dr. Matthew Gotlin in reviews?
1071 patients have reviewed Dr. Matthew Gotlin. The overall rating for this doctor is 4.91/5. They have a 4.94/5 rating for bedside manner and a 4.57/5 rating for wait time. You can read individual reviews and ratings on their profile.