What patients are saying
Overall rating
4.21
Average wait time
4.02
Bedside manner
4.21
“Great doctor. Listens well and will answer any questions you have. Waiting time was amazing!! I only waited a few minutes. I would highly recommend Dr. Gary Dicanio!! Office is extremely clean and staff is very friendly!”
Jessica W.June 16, 2025
“The staff and the DR. were very welcoming, knowledgeable and willing to assist with my issues and concerns.”
Sabrina J.June 27, 2023
About Dr. Gary DiCanio
Born in Brooklyn, New York and raised on Long Island, Dr. Gary DiCanio is a typical “baby boomer.” Dr. DiCanio developed an interest in biology and medical science while attending General Douglas McArthur High School in Levittown, NY. After receiving his bachelor’s degree in biology from the State University of NY, Arts and Science at Geneseo, Dr. DiCanio enrolled in the physician assistant program at Long Island University, Brooklyn, NY and worked as a physician assistant at the Health Clinic at Riker’s Island Correctional Institution, Woodhull Hospital and Brookhaven Memorial Hospital. This experience further solidified his passion for practicing medicine and he applied and was accepted in 1989 to medical school at New York College of Osteopathic Medicine, Old Westbury, NY. Dr. DiCanio completed his post medical school training at Peninsula Hospital, Queens, New York, concentrating in family medicine. He then completed training in OBGYN at Catholic Medical Center in Queens, NY. Dr. DiCanio is board certified by the American Osteopathic Board of Family Practice. Today, his focus is exclusively on family medicine with an emphasis on women’s health. He also specializes in the evaluation and treatment of no-fault and workers’ compensation cases. Dr.DiCanio is dedicated to excellence with an emphasis on the holistic approach to patient care. Dr. DiCanio has privileges at South Side Hospital, Bay Shore, NY and Good Samaritan Regional Medical Center, Bay Shore, NY.
*PLEASE NOTE*
Dr. DiCanio is a primary care provider, not a medical specialist, and sees patients for a wide range of general health needs, including check-ups, chronic condition management, sick visits, and minor injuries. For concerns that require specialty or surgical care, Dr. DiCanio can provide an initial evaluation and help coordinate a referral to the appropriate specialist.
Is this doctor in your insurance network?
Enter your insurance carrier and plan
choose insurance
In-network insurances
99% of patients have successfully booked with these insurances
Aetna
BlueCross BlueShield
Cigna
Emblem Health
Medicare
UnitedHealthcare
UnitedHealthcare Oxford
Office location
Education and background
Practice names
Hospital affiliations
- South Shore University Hospital
Education and training
- Medical School - New York Institute of Technology, New York College of Osteopathic Medicine, Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine
- Peninsula Hospital Center, Residency in Family Practice
- The State University of New York (SUNY) (Bachelor's)
Languages spoken
- English
- Spanish
Provider's gender
Male
NPI number
1770665721
Patient reviews
All reviews have been submitted by patients after interacting with the practice.
Overall rating
4.21
Wait time
4.02
Bedside manner
4.21
Your trust is our top concern, so providers can't pay to alter or remove reviews. We also don't publish reviews that contain any private patient health information. Learn more here
154 reviews
Most relevant
The wait was over 2 hours long and i couldn’t wait any longer to be seen. Staff didn’t care about the long wait times.
July 23, 2025Brenin B.Verified patient
I wanted an hour and a half to see the MD. Left prior to being seen
February 24, 2026Anthony B.Verified patient
Dr Dicanio has been my primary care Dr for 4-5 years now. He is thorough, efficient and listens to your problems.
April 15, 2023Duane B.Verified patient
The staff and the DR. were very welcoming, knowledgeable and willing to assist with my issues and concerns.
June 27, 2023Sabrina J.Verified patient
Excellent experience the staff was very friendly and everything went great
More than 1 year agoInitials hidden
Excellent doctor, bed side manner! Girls are great! Fast in and out ! Always polite and friendly!
April 29, 2021Ny Princess H.Verified patient
Friendly staff. Polite and professional all around. I hope to make this my primary doctor.
September 21, 2022Jason P.Verified patient
Very caring to my concern. Willing to help. I’d send anyone to dr dicanio he is a real doctor.
May 7, 2020Wes H.Verified patient
Great staff and doctors, clean efficient and so helpful. I would definitely go back!
February 14, 2023Joann M.Verified patient
Richard was very thorough and I appreciate the bedside manner. ??
December 5, 2023Faith S.Verified patient
It’s a relax environment. Everyone is respectful , knowledgeable and helpful.
January 19, 2021Saidat M.Verified patient
Very poor environment. Wait was way too long would NOT recommend this doctor
August 3, 2018Lashae K.Verified patient
Staff is very nice and and professional but the wait is too long!
More than 1 year agoInitials hidden
Detailed answers to questions and he listened intently
December 2, 2022Jean S.Verified patient
Great man so understanding. My primary care forever
June 14, 2020Wes H.Verified patient
I was there to get one vaccine and waited 45 minutes to get into a room. The doctor seemed careless and didn’t wash his hands or wear gloves.
June 19, 2025Initials hidden
Great doctor. Listens well and will answer any questions you have. Waiting time was amazing!! I only waited a few minutes. I would highly recommend Dr. Gary Dicanio!! Office is extremely clean and staff is very friendly!
June 16, 2025Jessica W.Verified patient
Very well cared for at the office
Less than 1 year agoInitials hidden
horrible . the doctor would not answer the calls from pharmacy to renew prescription . so i called 10 times , with no answer or call back , set up a appointment on zoc doc , it was confirmed , because no one would answer the phone at office ,when i got to office i was turned away to walk-ins, then told to make another the following week . so now i am left to scramble for a different doctor just to renew prescription. i would NOT recommend and cant under how providers like this are on zoc doc
February 26, 2025Initials hidden
find a different provider , the commutation skills there at horrible ., between doctor and receptionist , doc and patient, they never answer the phone or call back . they over book then when you go with appointment the walk -in come first , they why make appointments ??
February 26, 2025Initials hidden
Wait was long. Staff was wonderful.
More than 1 year agoInitials hidden
I normally see the PA I believe Robert but he was not in so I had no choice but to see this MD. He was over an hour late. He barely checked me and barely spoke to me. The girl in the front is awesome so friendly and acknowledged I was waiting for a long time. I will be back to see Robert but I will not be seeing this MD anytime soon.
More than 1 year agoInitials hidden
I did all necessary online forms and when I got to Dr office not only did they not know I had an appointment BUT THERE WERE NO DOCTORS IN THE OFFICE AT ALL THAT DAY.. COMPLETE WASTE OF TIME
October 23, 2024Initials hidden
Doctor was sloppy, stain on his shirt, not well put together professionally. We had to ask the nurse to take height and weight. They suggested x ray for back pain and although results would be expected in a week or 2 doctor said “see you in a month” just not the care we’re looking for.
July 18, 2024Jaiden T.Verified patient
Good environment and friendly atmosphere.
December 13, 2022Jason P.Verified patient
First appointment, was very happy overall.
October 7, 2022Christopher C.Verified patient
What an absolute burnt out, poor excuse for a Healthcare provider!!! I couldn't even tell you what this guy's face looked like or the color of his eyes. Walked in, sat down & rambled off, "what're you here for today"? and just proceeded to type for 15 minutes.
He never even said hello, introduced himself or looked in my eyes. I walked out looking for Alan Funt as I started to wonder if he had a drinking problem. He was disheveled, unshaven and sporting dirty trousers. He asked me to repeat the zip code to the pharmacy 5x!
No professionalism. No personalization. No compassion. He had all the warmth of 4 unanesthetized route canals.
If I ever do decide to go back I will only exclusively see Roberto the Nurse Practioner.
June 25, 2022Christine K.Verified patient
Dr Dicanio, in his other office, has been my primary care Dr for about 2 years now and I just switched to this lake Grove office due to insurance and what is accepted there. He is a fantastic Dr, and to say my case is complicated is an understatement. He is understanding, compassionate, will do anything and go the extra mile for you. If youre looking for a primary care Dr that is all of the above and you can get an appointment with ease, look no further! Thanks Dr. D for helping me out!
More than 1 year agoInitials hidden
I have been seeing Dr Gary Dicanio for 2 years and am writing my honest review, as I noticed some negative ones recently and I can't figure out why! Dr. Dicanio is efficient, empathetic and willing to work with you and help you in any way he can, with medication, referrals, treatment, and he is one of the best primary care physician I have ever had. I Always get taken within 15 minutes of my appointment time (which is a fair grace period) and I have a VERY complex case, requiring frequent changes in medications and such and he is very patient and willing to work with me despite my case not always being the easiest. If you need a good primary care physician who is friendly, intelligent and helpful he is your guy. 10/10.
March 3, 2022Duane B.Verified patient
Took over an hour to be seen mind you there was only 3 people in the waiting room before me and once I was seen there was no questions asked no through consultation was taken and we talked maybe 5 mins he didn’t weigh me or take my height nothing did blood work and said they would call about results instead they just texted me my results and expected me to read the readings as if I work in healthcare
More than 1 year agoInitials hidden
The front desk person I spoke with had THE WORST PERSONALITY AND ATTITUDE for a person working at a medical office. My first appointment was changed for a work day for me, I accepted. The second was cancelled when I got there, by Ms attitude. Needles to say WON'T BE BACK!!!
September 28, 2021Marjorie G.Verified patient
I had an awesome experience. The staff is very friendly and the doctor has the best bedside manner I’ve ever experienced. I felt very comfortable like I had been going there for years.
June 15, 2021Shakira S.Verified patient
He’s a excellent doctor and would recommend him . He has excellent bedside matter , listen’s to his patients needs and is wonderful. Staff is awesome! Love the girls. Overall everything is perfect.
April 3, 2021Ny Princess H.Verified patient
Geat doctor
October 7, 2020Jessie B.Verified patient
Good
More than 1 year agoInitials hidden
He was very nice and willing to help me but they had a power surge as they were trying to send over my script which I really needed. I waited few hrs for system to come back up and never did. They wanted me to come back Thursday and it was Monday and kinda urgent. He wrote a letter for me to go up the block to CityMD which I really appreciated but even with that they were no help. So I had to get on insurance and split doses for few days it really stunk. But oh well at least I know I can go here for help in future
May 4, 2020Wes H.Verified patient
Doc dicanio is great. Office workers horrible a rocks confident and is completely dishonest. Never gives doctor his messages guy yet to complete prior authorization he 2 weeks. Pain medication that is life-threatening
More than 1 year agoInitials hidden
Wait time was too long .
November 13, 2018Hammad B.Verified patient
Wait time was over an hour after they rescheduled my appointment the day before.
Reception/nurses were cold and unwelcoming throughout the entire process.
Doctor was fine, but she sent my prescription to a CVS pharmacy that doesn't exist and with my first and last name backwards.
I called four times to get it fixed and received an attitude from the receptionist every time, claiming that the pharmacy MUST be there.
The issue remained unresolved.
Based off the professionalism of the staff and the wait time, I would not recommend this office.
More than 1 year agoInitials hidden
Less than 3 months agoInitials hidden
Less than 3 months agoInitials hidden
Less than 3 months agoInitials hidden
December 31, 2025Waqar Y.Verified patient
Less than 6 months agoInitials hidden
Less than 6 months agoInitials hidden
October 22, 2025Donna L.Verified patient
October 7, 2025Heather L.Verified patient
Less than 1 year agoInitials hidden
September 17, 2025Damonique B.Verified patient
August 19, 2025Initials hidden
Loading...
How soon can I make an appointment with Dr. Gary DiCanio?
Generally, Dr. Gary DiCanio has appointments available on Zocdoc within 1 week. You can see Dr. DiCanio's earliest availability on Zocdoc and make an appointment online.
Is Dr. Gary DiCanio accepting new patients?
Dr. Gary DiCanio generally accepts new patients on Zocdoc. You can see Dr. DiCanio's earliest availability on Zocdoc and schedule an appointment online.
Does Dr. Gary DiCanio accept my insurance?
Choose your insurance plan to verify if Dr. DiCanio is in-network.
Can I make an appointment with Dr. Gary DiCanio online?
Yes, you can make an appointment online with Dr. DiCanio using Zocdoc. It’s simple, secure, and free.
Which hospital is Dr. Gary DiCanio affiliated with?
Dr. Gary DiCanio is affiliated with South Shore University Hospital.
What practice does Dr. Gary DiCanio work with?
Dr. Gary DiCanio works with Gary DiCanio.
Where is Dr. Gary DiCanio's office located?
Dr. Gary DiCanio's office is located at 105 Medford Ave, Patchogue, NY 11772.
What are common reasons for patients to see Dr. Gary DiCanio?
Dr. Gary DiCanio frequently sees patients for Allergy Consultation, Annual Physical, Foot Consultation, Illness, and Sleep Problems. You can see other visit reasons for Dr. Gary DiCanio on their profile.
What languages does Dr. Gary DiCanio speak?
Dr. Gary DiCanio speaks English and Spanish.
How do patients rate Dr. Gary DiCanio in reviews?
154 patients have reviewed Dr. Gary DiCanio. The overall rating for this doctor is 4.21/5. They have a 4.21/5 rating for bedside manner and a 4.02/5 rating for wait time. You can read individual reviews and ratings on their profile.