Book an Appointment
Qualifications and Experience
Dr. Rosenthal received his medical degree from the Cornell University Medical College, and went on to complete residencies in both Internal Medicine and Neurology, the former in Columbia University affiliated hospitals, and the latter at Mt. Sinai Medical Center. He is board certified by both the American Board of Internal Medicine, and the American Board of Psychiatry and Neurology. He has been in private practice since 1987, and is currently affiliated with both the NYU Hospitals Medical Center and Beth Israel Mount Sinai Hospital. Dr. Rosenthal specializes in adult neurology. His goal as your physician will be to use his wide expertise in neurology to both diagnose and treat you. In his role as a physician he values knowledge, being comprehensive and thorough, sound judgment, common sense, honesty, and empathy. Dr. Rosenthal and his staff look forward to welcoming you to his practice. SCHEDULING NOTICE: (1) Before we can confirm your appointment, you must provide your insurance company name and member ID so that we can confirm our participation in your plan. (2) 24-hour notice is needed to cancel/reschedule an appointment. (3) Our office is not wheelchair accessible. IMPORTANT INSTRUCTIONS FOR NEW PATIENTS: We need you to fully complete the “Check-In” form on ZocDoc.com. Also, bring the following to your appointment: 1) your insurance card, 2) any referral/authorization required by your insurance plan, 3) an active credit card which we keep on file (although you will not be required to use it to pay for your visit copayment, coinsurance or deductible), 4) a list of your medications, and 5) the name, address and phone number of your pharmacy.
Verified Patient Reviews
The doctor was very personable and took the time to review my concerns and address them. I didn’t feel rushed.
Very grateful for this doctor because he listens, he's thorough, he cares, and his advice is helping. His secretary is wonderful too. I highly recommend Dr. Rosenthal.
It was great. Very thoughtful and explained everything.
My visit was great. I had filled out the forms online, there were a few others to complete. Pretty standard stuff. I was seen at my appointment time didn’t have to wait. Dr. Rosenthal was very knowledgeable. He made me feel calm and at ease. He explained everything he was doing each step of the way. Overall great experience would recommend him to friends and family.
The wonderful doctor and staff were very knowledgeable, caring, professional, and organized. The office was very clean and super easy to get to by public transportation.
Professional. Excellent communicator. Would highly recommend.
The doctor was friendly, kind, very knowledgeable and a good communicator. His office staff was awesome: understood my insurance coverage better than I did and explained it to me.
Great doctor, staff, and office. I highly recommend Dr. Rosenthal. The doctor is extremely thorough.
The doctor was great. His staff was lovely and efficient.
During my visit, I found the doctor and his staff to be professional, caring, compassionate, and attentive. Dr. Rosenthal took the time to come and greet me in the waiting room and then saw me on time!! What a wonderful first impression!! The office was clean and well organized. The music in the waiting room was great too. I'm so glad that I listened to my doctor and saw Dr. Rosenthal. I know that I am in good hands and will follow through with Dr. Rosenthal's recommendations. I will also make sure to highly recommend him to anyone needing a neurologist.
Rude, obnoxious, and very unprofessional, as was the receptionist. Solution to my issue that has been causing me pain snd issues for over 4 years was ‘time’ and a vitamin I’m already taking. Pointless visit, will never be going back. Highly recommend going elsewhere. Office was also dirty
Excellent doctor !!!
Extremely thorough and conservative approach that left me feeling well taken care of. Highly recommend, and will be going back.
While I thought Dr. Rosenthal was quite nice, my experience in his office was less than pleasant. His receptionist was quite rude when I arrived to my first visit a few mins late (subway problems) and his office is outdated and a bit dirty. But still decided to give it another try in my follow-up On my second app, tI had an EGG done, in the second room, and there was dust everywhere and a certain smell. I wanted to run out of there, but felt like I shouldn't. I will definitely not be going back.
Dr. Rosental exudes competence and good will. His exam is thorough and straightforward. I would recommend him unconditionally.
Doctor Rosenthal and his staff are very thorough, kind, professional, and punctual. Everything was explained in advance, which I liked a lot. Highly recommended. Definitely coming back when needed.
Incredibly professional and personable!
Genuinelt cares and staff is efficient.
I got to my appointment almost a half hour early. It was still earlier than his staff was expected to arrive. However Dr. Rosenthal jumped right in and performed the role of administration and doctor. It is great when Doctors value your time as well, rather than have me sit and wait for his team to get in to complete the rest of the initial first appointment process. He took care of it, and he was able to still take the necessary time needed to complete his medical analysis of my situation. The end result....I was out quickly and back to work, but even more so I felt comfortable that I was being taken care of.
Efficient and to the point.
Great doctor and staff. Extremely thorough and kind. I highly recommend this office.
Dr. Rosenthal is very thorough and direct, and his office staff is friendly and very helpful! He put me at ease and scans were scheduled for me by his staff for the same day. Great doc!
This was my first appoint with Dr. Rosenthal. He was thorough, friendly, and professional. He took a detailed history, did a general assessment, and performed a test in the office. The office staff was warm and friendly.
The doctor did not even let me explain what is going on with me. I was not able to say if my symptoms where worse sitting or standing. He kept telling me he asks the questions and that is when I can respond. When authorizing a MRI of my brain and I asked why and what do you think is wrong he refused to give me an explanation. He just told me to go get an MRI. My right as a patient is to ask what care and reason you are prescribing me.
It's hard to find doctors today like Dr. Rosenthal. He took his time in his evaluation of me. Ask me questions and really listen. From the front desk to the technician everything runs smoothly and it was a pleasure to visit this office, I highly recommend Dr. Rosenthal.
Thoughtful, thorough, intelligent and prompt. Dr Rosenthal took the time to ask the right questions and listen to my responses. A very good initial visit.
Wonderful doctor and staff. Highly recommend him.
Difficult receptionist and poor bedside manner made me promptly find another neurologist.
The Doc takes his time with you, takes good notes. Seams very analytical and caring
Dr. Rosenthal is excellent, and the wait time is usually very short.
Dr. Rosenthal was very professional and took fast action into grtting me treated. He called a specialist so that I can walk in and had a session eith a specialist on the same day and scheduled for the next test the following day. he was very thorough. Highly recommended.
Very thorough and professional examination. Explained the process clearly, office staff arranged for testing and radiology exams, and scheduled appropriate follow-up appointment. Office staff courteous, friendly, and helpful.
Dr. Rosenthal came highly recommended through my general doctor and now I know why as he is very thorough, knowledgable and leaves no stone unturned. He takes the time to ensure that the patient understands the procedures he's performing and why is is performing them. It doesn't hurt that he is quite personable and has a great sense of humour.
This doctor is clearly very knowledgeable. He is also a great communicator and kind.
I am not a person that likes going to doctors due to their long stretched appointments during to time the doctor and his team on site were quick and thorough. They even set apps for me amin other locations to get checked the very same day. The doctor and his team are down. To earth people who care about what they are doing. I recommend , if you need to see a neurologists, this is your guy.
So happy I found this doctor.
Great doctor and staff. Saw me earlier than my scheduled time and I was even able to get needed testing done the same day. I am impressed and highly recommend this doctor.
I've been seeing Dr. Rosenthal for years and I'm a big fan. His office always runs smoothly, he's personable, efficient, takes the time to listen and it's always a pleasure to see him. I highly recommend.
Very honest, very thorough. Highly recommended.
Great visit with Dr. Rosenthal this morning. He was very thorough and took time to answer all of my questions and walk through my symptoms. He did an exam to assess the specific concerns that I presented with, and had an excellent bedside manner. Additionally, he does NOT seem like the kind of doctor who over-treats patients by sending them to do multiple unnecessary and costly tests, which I really appreciated. Would definitely recommend him to others.
Dr. Rosenthal is terrific. Very friendly and knowledgeable and he communicates clearly. His administrative assistant was also great at her job.
I think he's probably brilliant, but could communicate better. He spends a lot of time looking at results and typing into his computer while you are sitting there staring into space. If you try to speak while he's typing, he'll "shush" you. Doesn't explain why he's doing certain things. He told me something really significant in passing on my second visit that he noticed during the first, but never mentioned. I have one more visit scheduled, so we'll see if I get an answer to my situation. I agree with everyone else that his admin. is awesome!
Great doctor. Gives full attention to patients.
Dr. Rosenthal is professional, kind, and humorous. His friendly yet helpful manner was great.
He was very thorough in his conversation and questions and made sure I was understanding his recommendation. Also very pleasant to talk to.
Doctor Rosenthal was very easy to talk to and took the time to help me convey my symptoms, as they have been rather difficult to articulate. He also made me feel confident that he would help get to the bottom of what my issues are. Defintely check his practice out if you are in search of a good Neurologist!
He was great! Very attentive.
Clean office that is very conveniently located near the subway. I was seen right on time and felt that the doctor took his time with me. He was extremely thorough, pleasant and funny. His assistant, Nicole, was also very kind, helpful, and well organized. Great visit from beginning to end. I highly recommend this office.
Dr. Rosenthal is such a wonderful doctor that I can't say enough wonderful things about him. He is brilliant! His assistant, Nicole, is also truly amazing and caring. This kind office and the quality of the care that it gives is such a rare find these days. I'm so glad and fortunate to be a patient here.
This doctor is terrific. His administrative assistant is wonderfully friendly and efficient.
One of my best doctor's visit experiences. Dr. Rosenthal took time to conduct tests, was very thorough and clearly explained to me what I was going through. His assistant, Nicole, was superb!
I was taken right away for my appointment with Dr. Rosenthal who was extremely thorough going over my past medical history and current symptoms for about 20-30 minutes before making recommendations. He gave me several helpful things to do as a follow-up and discussed everything with me in terms of treatment, tests, etc. before I left.
Very personable, great communication and explained everything as he was doing it
He was very professional, quick and to the point. He did not pressure me for a follow up visit but left it open pending results of another problem that needed attention first and could have had an impact on my symptoms
My visit with Dr. Rosenthal was wonderful. He saw me right on time. He discussed a treatment plan that totally made sense and answered all of my questions. I never felt rushed. He is very smart and knows what he's doing. Nicole, his assistant, was very professional and kind. She knows what she's doing too. I really liked that they were transparent about my financial responsibility and she understood how my insurance worked. The office was very clean and organized. I highly recommend this office to anyone seeking a neurologist in NYC.
I arrived at the office 30 minutes early to my appointment. The staff behind the desk was extremely nice and professional and had me filling out paperwork right away. The doctor took me in to his office before my appointment was scheduled to start. Dr. Rosenthal was very kind and very thorough with the examination. He spent ample time with me and I didn't feel rushed at all. He did a great job at explaining next steps and I would definitely recommend him to anyone looking for a neurologist in the city!
Obviously an educated and knowledgeable practitioner. Will not visit anyone else but him.
Fantastic doctor and staff. Dr. Rosenthal genuinely cares about me and my well-being. He explained everything very well, answered all of my questions, and put me at ease. The steps he's taken in my care are logical and always well thought out. I have never encountered any problems with this office like those in the negative reviews. On the contrary, during check-in, I chatted with someone that came from out-of-state to see him because he's well worth the trip and then some. I would give him and his staff 10 stars if I could.
Dr. Rosenthal was extremely professional and should a real concern for my problem.
Very personable and didn't rush anything. Felt like the initial consultation was spot on and looking forward to tracking my migraines and working with him on any treatment changes going forward.
He is really great , he was able to figure out what is my issue. the office also clean and nice , and the people there are so friendly .
He's very thorough and kind! This was my first visit and I felt that everything was taken care of.
I had my first appointment with Dr. Rosenthal this morning. I was immediately impressed with the atmosphere of his office. His assistant is so kind and knowledgeable. Dr. Rosenthal is an excellent neurologist. He was very thorough in his examination and really seemed interested in what I had to say. I am very pleased that my primary care physician referred me to him. I would recommend him to anyone who is thinking of seeing a neurologist. MG
A really nice office. Lots of forms and questions, but totally thorough. Dr. Rosenthal is very personable, puts you at ease and ensures you understand your appointment results. Highly recommend.
Easy to book, fast and simple. Dr. Rosenthal was friendly, clear and professional
He was very thorough and made sure I know what was going on and why he was testing certain things. He's the first neurologist to actually listen to my symptoms and create a treatment plan. I highly recommend!
This doctor is great. He was kind, personable, very knowledgeable and helpful.
Very caring doctor and staff. Always a positive experience. I highly recommend Dr. Rosenthal.
I initially went to see this doctor to get a sleeping disorder checked and get my headaches under control. His credentials seemed good so I booked the appointment. Appointment #1: First of all the receptionist had an attitude and noted that I needed to pay 100% for the visit. So I was not happy with it and called my insurance company. My insurance company insisted that I shouldn't have to pay at front because I had enough money in my HSA to cover for my visit and that the doctors office was supposed to file a claim as it's the norm. After at least 30 minutes on the phone with insurance and the receptionist, she finally agreed to let me go without paying and file the claim. This was already a red flag and I should have gone somewhere else, but I didn't. Doctor suggested I got an eeg scan at the office at a future time. Well receptionist refused to book the appointment until they got paid for appointment #1. Appointment #2: it was the day of the eeg scan and see the doctor after. Eeg scan went well and the technician was very polite and nice. My time was pleasant despite of all the cables around my head. As soon as the scan was done I went to the doctors office and he literally spent 1 minute on the results and said no sign of seizures so he moved on. I had to stop him and asked him for next steps as the sleeping disorder was not gone and I needed a solution. He recommended another doctor (which I am so happy I went to see because he is outstanding and the other office is extremely helpful). Because I had another appointment (#3) for a future time, and clearly I was not happy with this doctor. I wanted to cancel it and tried calling so many times, but it was impossible to get someone to answer the phone. I even emailed zocdoc to see if there was another number to call or an email, but they said they didn't have anything else but what I had. I left voicemails, but never received a call back. Now they are charging me $50 for a no show. This is worst office I have ever been to in the city. Doctor might have his medical degree from a fancy school, but his office policies, bed manners and admin workers make this a very unpleasant place. Like they say "You're Only as Strong as your Weakest Link".
The Dr. is kind and well educated, however, he was very quick to schedule countless follow-ups. For one follow-up I was to receive the results of an MRI, for which I asked him if he would have the results being that the MRI was set for a day prior to the follow-up appointment. He assured me that he would. When I got there, he did not have it. He did a simple needle test, which was unnecessary, as nothing had changed, and my insurance was charged. I came in two days later for the results which he did not go over on the computer until I asked him to; he was already saying goodbye and setting up a new followup. (was also charged for picking up results, as he did the little needle test again, as if I couldn'y myself tell him, nothing has changed in the two days since) I must say, I couldn't help but feel like I was simply a pay out. I would not recommend for this reason.
I really enjoyed the visit. The Doctor is very pleasant to talk to and seems very competent.
A first visit. The doctor considered the headaches for which I was consulting him, but also noticed some indications of another problem which he'll follow up with a test and pursue it if necessary. I may not continue with him, though, since his office is not handicapped accessible. But I was very satisfied with the doctor himself.
He is wonderful
WONDERFUL DOCTOR AND STAFF!!!! This was a follow-up visit and I won't go anywhere else. Dr. Rosenthal is extremely thorough, intelligent, professional, compassionate, and kind. He's a gem and I'm so happy that I found him. He has always taken such great care of me and his staff has always been very helpful. I highly recommend Dr. Rosenthal to anyone seeking a Neurologist.
Dr. Rosenthal has always been thorough, professional, caring, patient, and considerate. He always has the right advice and recommendations. I'm following his instructions and I'm already feeling better. Nicole was wonderful, organized, and professional too. I highly recommend this office and will definitely return for my follow up.
Wonderful staff and great experience. Nicole immediately brought me into the doctor's office once I filled out required paperwork. Dr. Rosenthal asked me many questions to help him pin point my concerns. He was informative and left me with information so I could learn more about headaches/migraines. He was very thorough with the examination and I felt very comfortable. Already scheduled follow-up appointments, and I feel confident that with his help I will see relief! Would definitely recommend him to friends & family.
Overall excellent experience. We seem well on the way to dealing with a long-tern chronic problem that no one else has dented. I have complete confidence in Dr. Rosenthal's knowledge and capability, and he is the most respectful and pleasant doctor I have ever seen.
Dr. Rosenthal was warm, efficient and willing to take the time to answer my questions.
He was both friendly and professional and I would strongly recommend him.
Moves faster than the speed of NY!
I was very confident that he will help my issues. He has ordered several tests and a follow up visit already.
Very thorough and professional. And he was considerate of my time.
Great Doctor. Great experience and very knowledgeable and succinct.
Dr Rosenthal is great. He was very patient and thorough. Great doctor!
I was made to feel very comfortable and at ease the moment I walked into the waiting room, and during the examination as well. I would highly recommend Dr. Rosenthal..
He always seems to know just what to say and do. Not many doctors like him around. So thankful and fortunate to have Dr. Rosenthal as my doctor. Very reassuring visit today. Staff is always very helpful, sweet, and professional. I will schedule another visit again soon.
My appointment with Dr.Rosenthal was great! It's always nice to have an appointment with a doctor and feel comfortable. His secretary was very nice and very helpful! Dr. Rosenthal did not rush me out and he answered all my questions. I was extremely pleased with my visit! I will be returning!
Great overall experience from start to finish. Dr. Rosenthal and his staff are great.
Dr. Rosenthal was very professional, funny and understanding considering a tricky situation I was facing. His receptionist was very kind as well. I would 100% recommend him to anyone looking for a good neurologist.
Dr. Rosenthal is an excellent Neurologist; he is very professional and thorough in his diagnosis and analysis. He is extremely attentive and detail oriented. Dr. Rosenthal's knowledge and expertise is second to none.
Doc was awesome. First time there and made me feel very welcome. Very thorough visit.
Smart, professional, thorough. Took me on time!
Incredibly thorough and approachable. He has made a big difference in my health.
Dr. Rosenthal went out of his way to help me even though (when all was said and done) it turned out my problem was not the sort of problem he generally deals with. A good diagnostician and a nice man!
Wonderful doctor. He was very thorough, communicated very well, was obviously very knowledgeable and competent, and to top it off, was very personable. I recommend him highly.
He was an extremely knowledge person who effectively communicated his findings.
Great doctor Extremely knowledgeable, friendly, and kind.
I have seen Dr. Rosenthal several times and will continue under his care. He is a humble genius with a very well run office. His secretary is top notch! Dr. Rosenthal answers all of my questions and his secretary always helps to arrange my tests. I love his office's location because its so close to so many subway lines and buses. (Metered parking all over the place too.)
Very thorough. Asked all the right questions. Showed concern and patience to make sure I was receiving the best care possible!
Wonderful MD. Spent a lot of time with me; explained everything thoroughly; smart and friendly too. A great find. Glad to have him on my team.
This was my first visit with Dr. Rosenthal and I'm very satisfied with my visit. He made sure to address all my symptoms and did a thorough analysis. I am definitely going back.
Truly a great doctor. Remarkably competent and a great bedside manner.
Dr. Rosenthal was very friendly, thorough and professional. His staff was very efficient. Expect to provide a credit card on your first visit which was the only thing I was not keen about.
The staff here is very helpful and kind but I felt very rushed during my time with Dr. Rosenthal. I would explain my issue and where I was experiencing pain but it seemed like it was going in one ear and out the other. There was also very little explanation of MRI results and other reasons to what could be causing my pain. He ended up just prescribing me pain killers. I have no doubt he is an intelligent man but the lack of helpful information left me feeling like it was a waste of time.
Always impressed with how this office operates. Clean, neat, organized, on time, courteous, professional....and that's why I keep coming back. This doctor is great.
Very personable and knowledgeable. I had an issue with my arms for 4 months and he was immediately able to pinpoint with the right tests what I needed to do.
I myself am in the healthcare field so I can say with confidence that Dr. Rosenthal was terrific. Very thorough and efficient, I would highly recommend him.
Dr. was very friendly and responsive to my comments and problems. for a first visit, I felt very comfortable and in good hands. - as opposed to feeling like I was with a stranger, which is often the case with a new doctor.
Dr. Rosenthal was, as always, very caring and knowledgeable. His secretary is top notch. She always gets my tests ordered, arranged, and done faster than any other office that I've been to. You don't find medical care like this anywhere else. I wholeheartedly trust Dr. Rosenthal and recommend everyone to him.
Dr. Rosenthal seems incredibly knowledgeable and competent. He was also very attentive and kind. I recommend him highly.
I saw three other neurologists before finding Dr. Rosenthal. He has a calm competent manner which is exactly what I am looking for. He saw the diagnosis from other doctors and explained why they were not accurate, and why the medication they prescribed was not ideal. He knows his stuff, which is exactly what I look for in a specialist. Will continue to see him.
Dr. Rosenthal was very personable, and explained what he was doing every step of the way. He answered all of my questions and was very thorough. His secretary was helpful and lovely to deal with.
Just awful. He doesn't listen and is convinced he knows everything about the brain. Every time I tried to ask him a question he would dismiss me and get annoyed like he thought I was some imbecile who was just going to sit there mutely while he gave me my results. He became really defensive and asked me why I seemed "incredulous" of his answers when he was only repeating the same thing over and over again and not ever answering my questions. Worst of all, he didn't tell me about an abnormality on my MRI for 2 and a half months nor did he put two and two together that said abnormality could be causing my symptoms. Totally unethical and not good at his job. Do not see this man.
He was great. Kind, friendly and very knowledgeable/competent. His administrative assistant was very organized and efficient. Overall, an excellent doctor-patient experience.
Dr Rosenthal was friendly, highly professional, thorough and focused on getting the best health outcomes for me in the most efficient and cost effecitive manner.
I went to see Dr. Rosenthal for chronic headaches and I wish I had stopped seeing him after my first appointment because I do not feel like he gave me good advice nor did he seem invested in my well-being. His bedside manner could definitely use some work and of the 5 or so appointments I had with him, I often found myself staring blankly into space as he typed notes on his computer without informing me of his opinion. He did not provide me with any alternative options when I expressed concern over the amount of prescription medication he wanted me to take. When I finally decided to switch neurologists, his office would not send over the results of the EEG exam I had taken at his office to the new doctor even though I had signed an authorization release form.
Not warm and fuzzy but very competent, thorough and organized.
Dr. Rosenthal was great. He treated me with respect, listened to me attentively, and was super efficient regarding next steps.
I don't know that I've ever had a better visit to a doctor. I walked in and was greeted by a kind, professional woman. Rather than just shoving the inevitable stack of papers in my face, she introduced herself first and told me what she'd need from me. Proof that a few kind words make a big difference. I saw the doctor almost immediately (when was the last time that happened?!), and he was kind, thoughtful and thorough. He asked a lot of questions AND took the time to listen to the answers. The physical exam was thorough, and he was very careful in ensuring that I felt comfortable throughout. At the end, he told me what he thought the problem was, but scheduled an MRI to rule out anything more serious. I left feeling like I was in the hands of someone thoughtful, competent and proactive. I wholeheartedly recommend him.
it was my first time at this office and i was seen on time. i filled out forms and Dr. Rosenthal asked me questions and listened to what i had to say. He went through everything that i entered on my forms and finally someone who understands the pain in my head. :D The receptionist is very nice, I chatted with her while i filled out my forms. Looking around his office I could tell that Dr. Rosenthal was knowledgable (awards and certifications) and I trust that I am in good hands with him. I recommend this doctor.
Highly recommend. Within 24 hours of booking an appointment I saw Dr Rosenthal, he got me an MRI a couple of hours later on Thanksgiving Eve and then called me that night to give me the diagnosis. Fast, efficient, great service.
Dr. Rosenthal was absolutely terrific. I have extreme medical anxiety and he immediately put me at ease (while I was in the waiting room, even before the consultation began). More importantly, the examination was thorough and you could just tell that he was the consummate professional (i.e., he "knew what he was doing"). Dr. Rosenthal then immediately sent my report to my internist. I approached the appointment with real anxiety - and I could not have asked for a better experience in every respect.
Dr. Rosenthal was absolutely wonderful. He had terrific bedside manner, asked key questions and made me feel so comfortable. I would highly recommend him.
I had a wonderful visit with Dr. Rosenthal. He was very personable and was attentive to my concerns. I will certainly recommend him to others and look forward to my next visit.
Great Doctor, caring, smart, spends time with you, one of the best experiences and top care
Dr. Rosenthal was very professional. He was thorough in asking questions to target the cause of my migraines. I felt that he took his time with my consultation and suggested some reasonable tests. I'll be back to see him next month. I would definitely recommend him.
I saw Dr. Rosenthal for a series of appointments as he was working towards a diagnosis, which unsurprisingly can take a while with neurology. He gave me little to no information and kept sending me back for test after test with no explanation as to why. As others have stated, his demeanor leaves a lot to be desired, and this made the overall experience much more stressful for me. I put up with this for a while, but was put off when his office wanted me to get approval for tests from my insurance company myself (i.e., stay on the phone forever). Most offices do that service for their patients. I would not recommend him.
Dr. Rosenthal was thorough in his examination and questions about my history. He seemed good-humored and I enjoyed speaking with him. The office was impeccably clean, if not modern. My only reservation would be that he seemed as if he were in a bit of a rush to get me out the door, possibly because he was a bit behind schedule this particular day.
He was very nice and put you at ease. Did what he had to, without sending you for unnecessary tests. Made you feel comfortable. I would recommend him.
Dr. Rosenthal is one of the nicest and most patient doctors I have ever met! His clinic is clean and comfortable, his assistant is very friendly and helpful, and Dr. Rosenthal himself is extremely personable and puts you at ease right away. The way in which he took time to meticulously ask questions about my symptoms and perform the initial check-up, speaks volumes of his expertise and experience. I am SO happy I trusted the other reviews and went to see him!!
Dr. Rosenthal was both professional and personable. Exam was very thorough. He explained my problem in detail and how it will be remedied.
My overall experience was wonderful. Dr. Rosenthal is the first doctor I have seen in a long time who actually listened to their patient and came up with a treatment plan. So glad I received a recommendation to see him bc I cannot say enough things. His office manager was also fabulous.
Was referred by my PCP but made the appt online through zocdoc, which was super easy and confirmed immediately. Office is great- noone ever likes to go to the doctor but its a small office and the secretary and MD were both so friendly and approachable and really made my experience as pleasant as possible! Thank you!
Very attentive and cares about your concerns and questions. I went in for frequent migraines and Dr. Rosenthal explained thoroughly explained all my opinions of treatment. Would definitely recommend him.
After todays visit, I can easily see that Dr. Rosenthal deserves a 5 Star rating!
Dr. Rosenthal was extremely professional. He personally took my medical history and performed a tests that would usually require a second appointment on the spot!
I chose Dr. Rosenthal based on the great reviews he has on ZocDoc and have been to his office 3 times over the past few months. 1) I have never felt rushed; he asks questions about your health/symptoms in detail and then analyzes your responses to fully understand your symptoms and make a diagnosis. 2) He takes the time to explain anything that you have questions about or don’t understand. 3) He sees 1 patient at a time and isn’t going back and forth between exam rooms so you know that you have his undivided attention 4) He doesn’t schedule multiple patients at 10 minute intervals and isn’t rushing you to stay on schedule. I have never had to wait more than 10 minutes in the waiting room. 5) He doesn’t overprescribe medications hoping that 1 of them will work or order unnecessary tests. He really tries to find the root of the problem instead of trying to over-medicate like many other doctors do. Overall, I highly recommend him and find him to be extremely knowledgeable, professional, & personable. Also, the receptionist is great! She is very nice, helpful, and efficient at processing payments and scheduling follow-up appointments. I am very picky about the doctor's that I choose to see and I always look for someone that really has a vested interest in their patients and it’s refreshing to find a doctor like Dr. Rosenthal who isn’t trying to turn his office into an assembly line.
Thorough, knowledgeable, and understanding. Highly recommended
Dr. Rosenthal and his staff are fantastic. I have been working with him as a patient and as a professional for more than 15 years. Always courteous, professional and candid with you and your health concerns. A ++ provider
I arrived early and had about 30 minutes of filling papers out and waiting but my appointment was right on time. Dr Rosenthal was quick, very thorough, and funny!
The staff was extremely efficient and professional. The doctor was very punctual, efficient and cared to explain whether something was to be considered serious or not - this was very helpful and comforting especially when a patient thinks something is wrong: a patient wants to be told the truth. The doctor listened and answered questions related to this aspect of determining whether something is worrisome or not.
Great thorough Doctor! Highly Recommended!
He told me that what other doctors said in the past, wasn't accurate, which didn't bother me, but it was the way he said it. He said I made the right decision by going to him and when I started asking questions about the treatment, he was already pushing me out the door. I wouldn't recommend him.
great and very thorough doctor. nicole is AMAZING!
Dr. Rosenthal was attentive to my questions and needs, thorough in his examination and provided a diagnosis and reading after the exam.
Great bedside manner. Listens. Uses an electronic health record which is the best!
I was surprised at my experience- after reading all of the reviews I expected a positive appointment, however I did not experience such. Dr Rosenthal was more concerned with the insurance process than my migraine pain, and rushed through the evaluation to see the next patient when he heard I had lesser coverage (despite me expressing I would pay the remainder out of pocket). It was disappointing and did not result in a positive treatment plan. Also, on a scheduling note, I had an early appointment in hopes of making it to work on time, but ended up had waiting longer than expected as no office staff was present and the Dr took extra time for personal calls to squeeze in a colleagues child later that day. I will not be returning.
Dr. Rosenthal is obviously top-notch. He is very smart and knowledgeable, communicates extremely well, and is very personable. I recommend him highly.
He is very personable, attentive, direct/ to the point.
Everything was great. Dr. Rosenthal was kind and attentive to my concerns.
Great guy, great doctor. Helped me right away. Was very thorough and is so very friendly. He seemed genuinely excited to be helping me. Amazing to meet a doctor who actually cares about the health of his patients
Very pleased with the doctor.
I thought he was great! Very thorough and knowledgeable. Friendly disposition. His receptionist/assistant was extremely pleasant and helpful.
This is the most thorough doctor that I've ever been to. I've seen him a few times already and won't go anywhere else. I always walk out with my questions answered and his staff is always very nice and helpful.
Dr. Rosenthal was extremely professional. He was able to walk me through my situation and helped me plan for my upcoming treatment. I would recommend him to anyone.
Dr. Rosenthal has been my neurologist for about ten years and I have always been satisfied with the care he provides. He takes the time to do a thorough history and examination and to ask the right questions and really listen to what I say. He has always provided appropriate treatment and follow-up, include excellent referrals when needed. The office is managed professionally and is calm and efficient. Any wait time is usually minimal; I arrived a few minutes early today and was seen at the scheduled time. Assistance is provided for any insurance issues such as prior approval for tests.
This was my second visit and it was just as pleasant as the first. He saw me immediately, but even if I had to wait it would've been worth it. Dr. Rosenthal addressed all of my questions and concerns. His staff was very kind and helpful in arranging tests for me and sorting out the authorization requirements with my insurance. I will continue my treatment with Dr. Rosenthal and trust him completely. I highly recommend Dr. Rosenthal to anyone else.
Mr. Rosenthal was thorough and patient. I did not feel rushed and he explained everything very clearly. He made me feel extremely comfortable. I would definitely go back.
Very knowledgable and thorough - I was going for an intial consult for headaches. Very personable as well. Highly recommended.
A wonderful doctor. I trust him with my life.
Doctor was very nice and extremely thorough. His staff is awesome and helped to arrange my tests right away which was a relief. The entire experience was a positive one and I'd highly recommend this doctor.
Dr, Rosenthal is excellent. I was very impressed with his manner and knowledge.
Dr. Rosenthal is very personable and immediately made me feel comfortable. He was very detailed and informative. The staff was very friendly and made sure my tests were scheduled within the week. I would highly recommend this doctor.
Simply put, I think Dr. Rosenthal is a great doctor. He is understanding, compassionate, very intellegent and knowledgeable, and he communicates well. I would recommend him to anyone who needs a neurologist.
It was pretty smooth.
my exoerience was excellent on every level.
Dr Rosenthal is thorough, patient, and reassuring, as is his office staff. I was nervous going into this appointment, but he put me at ease. He really listens, and cares about your well being. I would highly recommend reaching out to him if you are in search of a neurologist in NYC.
I have the utmost respect for Doctor Rosenthal. He is everything you look for in a doctor and more. I recommend Neil to anyone. I trust him with my life.
Dr. Rosenthal is an intelligent and honest man. This is the only physician I have ever heard of that reimburses for over charging (they proactively sent a check to me), and I worked in a hospital for years. Great physician!
Impressive doctor. Knows his stuff. Explains things well. Very nice manner.
Very professional and to the point.
Professional, courteous and thorough.
professional and caring. seems liek an outstanding medical expert!
Very positive. Dr. Rosenthal was very clear and professional. I felt in good hands with someone who knew what he was talking about.
Very professional and personable. Explained things well. Would recommend him to a family member.
I was told during the visit that I wasn't answering the Dr. Rosenthal's questions, though I wasn't sure how to quantify recent changes in my symptoms. Although he was very thorough in writing prescriptions and making sure I understood how to take them, I won't be going back.
This was my first time seeing Neil. He and his assistant were super friendly, making me feel welcomed and at home right away. During my visit, Neil walked me through the process, his diagnosis, and next steps. Overall, it was a very pleasant doctor visit and I would highly recommend him to anyone looking for a neurologist.
He was very attentive.
Dr. Neil Rosenthal was very helpful and thorough, and saw me right away! I went in with a variety of odd headache symptoms and he was able to help me, and took the time to ask me many questions and run a series of tests. I would highly recommend him!
Very professional and thorough exam. Dr. Rosenthal is personable and seems very knowledgeable and caring.
The doctor originally asked me for a credit card whereby he could charge me for services without billing me, and asked me to sign a paper giving consent to this. When I objected he relented, but later complained about my insurer, which no doubt squeezes specialists. So the credit card business may be used only with patients who carry my insurance. But it may be helpful to be braced for this request in advance.
Very professional, from Nicolle the receptionist to the Doctor. Ill be back!
Great visit. Doctor Rosenthal was efficient and professional. He was willing to conduct neural testing on my first visit and was incredibly thorough and knowledgeable during the entire examination. He showed genuine care about my pain.
This doctor is really good (thorough, extremely knowledgeable, and friendly). His secretary was also great – very nice and efficient.
Dr. Rosenthal was great. He took his time with me and had really great bedside manor. He made sure to ask a ton of questions so that we can get to the root of my symptoms.
Great doctor, I will continue seeing him for my headache issues. I definitely recommend him!