About Dr. Atara Wertentheil
Clientele seen
Young adults (18-24)
Individuals
Adults (25-64)
Seniors (65+)
Treatment approaches
Acceptance and Commitment (ACT)
Cognitive Behavioral (CBT)
Attachment-based
Compassion Focused
Coaching
Culturally Sensitive
Identity
Gender
FemaleLanguages spoken
English
Getting to know Dr. Atara Wertentheil
I’m Dr. Atara Wertentheil, a licensed psychologist and founder of The Prism Practice, a virtual therapy space dedicated to helping individuals and couples build healthier, more secure, and fulfilling relationships. I hold a PhD in Counseling Psychology and an MSEd in Mental Health Counseling, both from Fordham University at Lincoln Center.
With a deep understanding of relationship dynamics, I specialize in:
Individual Therapy – Supporting clients through anxiety, depression, self-esteem, career concerns, and major life transitions.
Couples Therapy – For partners seeking to strengthen communication, rebuild trust, or navigate challenges effectively.
Individual Relationship Counseling – Helping individuals break unhealthy patterns, set boundaries, and cultivate meaningful connections.
Parent Coaching – Offering strategies to support confident, connected, compassionate parenting while balancing personal well-being.
My approach is warm, direct, evidence-based, and tailored to each client's unique needs. Whether you're facing relationship struggles, attachment issues, or life transitions, I’m here to challenge and support you in embracing vulnerability and allowing change to occur. I am passionate about working with you to find meaningful insight, clarity, and effective strategies that help you thrive.
The Prism Practice is fully virtual, allowing you to access expert therapy from the comfort of your home. Book your first session today—we look forward to collaborating with you on your journey.
What should a new client know about working with you?
Our approach at The Prism Practice is warm, interactive, and deeply engaged—Our therapists won’t just sit back and nod. We believe in creating a collaborative space where you feel heard and understood, while also challenging you to step outside your comfort zone and explore the patterns that may be holding you back.
We take an honest and direct approach, offering insights and strategies that help you move forward. Growth often comes from leaning into discomfort, and we’ll gently push you to tolerate the uncertainty and change you may be resisting—because that’s where real transformation happens.
At the same time, we’ll always be empathetic and supportive, helping you navigate difficult emotions at a pace that feels safe and effective.
What is your typical process for working with clients?
Each session is tailored to your needs, but here’s what you can generally expect when working with us:
We’ll check in and ask how you’ve been since our last session, what’s been on your mind, and any updates or challenges that have come up.
We’ll dive deep – Whether we’re exploring relationship patterns, emotional struggles, or life transitions, we’ll help you uncover the underlying thoughts, feelings, and behaviors that may be keeping you stuck.
We’ll be actively engaged – Therapy with us is not just about venting; it’s about insight and action. We’ll ask thought-provoking questions, reflect back themes we notice, and help you reframe unhelpful beliefs.
You’ll be challenged (but supported) – Growth happens through discomfort and embracing vulnerability. We may encourage you to sit with difficult emotions, consider new perspectives, or take small but meaningful risks in your life.
We’ll talk about next steps – Whether it’s practicing a new boundary, trying a mindset shift, or reflecting on an insight, we’ll help you leave each session with something tangible to work on between appointments.
Dr. Atara Wertentheil is not in-network with any insurances
It’s common for mental health providers to be out-of-network. Many insurance plans offer out-of-network coverage, so you may get partially reimbursed. Learn more
Out-of-pocket fees and assistance
Initial session: $250 for 45 minutes
Ongoing session: $250 for 45 minutes
- Sliding scale: Offers lower out-of-pocket fees on an individual basis, typically based on your ability to pay
- Files your insurance claim: You pay the session fee upfront and the provider files the claim for you, so you can get reimbursed directly without worrying about the paperwork
More information on payments and coverage
At The Prism Practice, we believe that accessing quality therapy should be as seamless as possible. While we are an out-of-network provider, we help our clients navigate their mental health benefits with ease.
We assist in checking your out-of-network coverage, so you know what to expect in terms of reimbursement. After each session, we provide a superbill—a detailed receipt that simplifies the process of submitting claims to your insurance for reimbursement.
Need extra support? We can also guide you through the claim submission process, ensuring you have everything you need to maximize your benefits. Our goal is to make high-quality therapy both accessible and stress-free. Let us handle the details so you can focus on your growth and healing.
Education and background
Practice names
Education and training
- Fordham University at Lincoln Center, PhD in Counseling Psychology
- Fordham University at Lincoln Center, MSEd in Mental Health Counseling
Professional memberships
- American Psychological Association
Awards and publications
- BOOK (Available on Amazon.com)- "Empowerment and Healing in Anxious Attachment Recovery: Understand Your Attachment Style, Improve Relationships, Resolve Past Trauma, and Achieve Healthy, Secure Love"
NPI number
1720561061
How soon can I make an appointment with Dr. Atara Wertentheil?
Generally, Dr. Atara Wertentheil has appointments available on Zocdoc within 1 week. You can see Dr. Wertentheil's earliest availability on Zocdoc and make an appointment online.
Is Dr. Atara Wertentheil accepting new patients?
Dr. Atara Wertentheil generally accepts new patients on Zocdoc. You can see Dr. Wertentheil's earliest availability on Zocdoc and schedule an appointment online.
Does Dr. Atara Wertentheil accept my insurance?
Choose your insurance plan to verify if Dr. Wertentheil is in-network.
Can I make an appointment with Dr. Atara Wertentheil online?
Yes, you can make an appointment online with Dr. Wertentheil using Zocdoc. It’s simple, secure, and free.
What practice does Dr. Atara Wertentheil work with?
Dr. Atara Wertentheil works with The Prism Practice.
What are common reasons for patients to see Dr. Atara Wertentheil?
Dr. Atara Wertentheil frequently sees patients for Depression, New Patient Visit, Psychotherapy, Psychotherapy Intake / Initial Visit, and Sleep Problems. You can see other visit reasons for Dr. Atara Wertentheil on their profile.
What languages does Dr. Atara Wertentheil speak?
Dr. Atara Wertentheil speaks English.