Natalie Koldaro, MA, New York, NY | Psychotherapist

What patients are saying

Overall rating

5.00

Average wait time

5.00

Bedside manner

5.00

“Really good first experience. I felt comfortable from the start and I’ll be visiting again next week!”

Murad A.July 30, 2026

“Natalie is incredibly easy to talk to and brings a positive, uplifting energy that makes therapy something I genuinely look forward to. I always leave our sessions feeling heard, supported, and encouraged.”

CBLess than 1 month ago

About Natalie Koldaro

Focus areas

Adult Psychotherapy

Low Self Esteem

Psychotherapy Intake / Initial Visit

Anxiety

New Patient Visit

Therapy

Family Therapy/ Marriage Therapy

Psychotherapy

Clientele seen

Teenagers (13-17)

Children (<13)

Families

Young adults (18-24)

Seniors (65+)

Couples

Adults (25-64)

Individuals

Treatment approaches

Cognitive Behavioral (CBT)

Psychodynamic

Dialectical (DBT)

Emotionally Focused

Acceptance and Commitment (ACT)

Play Therapy

Identity

Gender

Female

Languages spoken

English, Hebrew

Getting to know Natalie Koldaro

Natalie Koldaro is a compassionate and dedicated mental health counselor who holds a Master’s degree in Mental Health and Wellness Counseling from New York University. She brings a strong clinical foundation paired with a genuine passion for supporting individuals through life’s challenges. Coming from a diverse background, Natalie is culturally competent and intentionally leads each session with curiosity, openness, and respect. She values getting to know each client’s unique story and strives to create a safe, nonjudgmental space where clients feel heard, understood, and empowered. Natalie takes an integrative, person-centered approach to therapy, tailoring her work to meet each client’s individual needs and goals. She incorporates evidence-based practices such as Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) and Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT), while always ensuring that the therapeutic relationship remains collaborative and grounded in trust. Her goal is to help clients build insight, develop practical coping skills, and feel supported every step of the way. Fluent in English and conversational in Spanish, Natalie is able to connect with clients from a variety of backgrounds. She is committed to fostering an inclusive and affirming environment for all individuals.

Is this doctor in your insurance network?

Enter your insurance carrier and plan

choose insurance

In-network insurances

Natalie Koldaro, MA has +46 in-network plans.

Out-of-pocket fees and assistance

Initial session: $150 for 45 minutes

Ongoing session: $150 for 45 minutes

Popular visit reasons

Cognitive-Behavioral Family Therapy

Depression

New Patient Visit

Pre-Move In Couples Counseling

Psychotherapy

Psychotherapy Intake / Initial Visit

Sleep Problems

Young Adult Issues

Cognitive-Behavioral Family Therapy

Depression

New Patient Visit

Pre-Move In Couples Counseling

Office locations

Natalie Koldaro, MA also offers online video visits for patients

Looking Glass Psychology (1 of 2)

271 Madison Ave 17th Fl, New York, NY 10016

Get directions

Looking Glass Psychology (2 of 2)

18 E 41st St 9th Fl, New York, NY 10017

Get directions

1 of 2

Education and background

Practice names

Looking Glass Psychology

Education and training

New York University, Master's in Mental Health Counseling

NPI number

1497547947

Patient reviews

All reviews have been submitted by patients after interacting with the practice.

Overall rating

5.00

Wait time

5.00

Bedside manner

5.00

Your trust is our top concern, so providers can't pay to alter or remove reviews. We also don't publish reviews that contain any private patient health information. Learn more here

5 reviews

Most relevant

Really good first experience. I felt comfortable from the start and I’ll be visiting again next week!

July 30, 2026Murad A.Verified patient

Natalie is an excellent listener. Terrible at letting me avoid my own issues. Highly recommend.

Less than 1 month agoJJ

Natalie is incredibly easy to talk to and brings a positive, uplifting energy that makes therapy something I genuinely look forward to. I always leave our sessions feeling heard, supported, and encouraged.

Less than 1 month agoCB

Working with Natalie was an incredibly positive experience. She is compassionate, authentic, attentive, and created a safe, supportive space where I feel heard and understood. Definitely recommend working with her!

Less than 1 month agoJS

I was a previous patient of Natalie’s and I cannot recommend her to more people!! She is so approachable, kind and attentive to my (many) mental health issues! She helped me overcome my OCD rituals, flight anxiety, and separation anxiety. I recommend her to anyone struggling!!

Less than 1 month agoAF

Frequently asked questions

How soon can I make an appointment with Natalie Koldaro?

Generally, Natalie Koldaro has appointments available on Zocdoc within 1 week. You can see Natalie Koldaro's earliest availability on Zocdoc and make an appointment online.

Is Natalie Koldaro accepting new patients?

Natalie Koldaro generally accepts new patients on Zocdoc. You can see Natalie Koldaro's earliest availability on Zocdoc and schedule an appointment online.

Does Natalie Koldaro accept my insurance?

Choose your insurance plan to verify if Natalie Koldaro is in-network.

Can I make an appointment with Natalie Koldaro online?

Yes, you can make an appointment online with Natalie Koldaro using Zocdoc. It’s simple, secure, and free.

What practice does Natalie Koldaro work with?

Natalie Koldaro works with Looking Glass Psychology.

Where is Natalie Koldaro's office located?

Natalie Koldaro has 3 office locations, including in New York and Smyrna, view full addresses on Natalie Koldaro's profile.

What are common reasons for patients to see Natalie Koldaro?

Natalie Koldaro frequently sees patients for Depression, New Patient Visit, Psychotherapy, Psychotherapy Intake / Initial Visit, and Sleep Problems. You can see other visit reasons for Natalie Koldaro on their profile.

What languages does Natalie Koldaro speak?

Natalie Koldaro speaks English, Spanish, and Hebrew.

How do patients rate Natalie Koldaro in reviews?

5 patients have reviewed Natalie Koldaro. The overall rating for this doctor is 5/5. They have a 5/5 rating for bedside manner and a 5/5 rating for wait time. You can read individual reviews and ratings on their profile.