What patients are saying
Overall rating
4.77
Average wait time
4.44
Bedside manner
4.79
“I've been a pt of Dr. Fagelman's for over 20 years. I met him at St. Vincents Hospital many years ago. He's an internist who I credit for alerting me to an issue which turned out to be prostate cancer! And he's done so much more than that. My longevity w/ him alone should indicate my appreciation for all he's done for me.”
Harland G.March 11, 2026
“I had to wait 45 minutes even though I was on time. They only informed me of not doing travel vaccines in person versus before the appointment via a call.
The NP was quick and helpful though and addressed my needs.”
Initials hiddenLess than 1 month ago
About Dr. Andrew Fagelman
Dr. Andrew Fagelman is board certified by the American Board of Internal Medicine and currently practices at SOHO Health NY. He earned his Doctor of Medicine from the State University of New York, Buffalo. He completed his internship in General Surgery at Maimonides Medical Center and his residency in Internal Medicine at Saint Vincent Catholic Medical Center.
Providing general medical care in the heart of SOHO, Dr. Fagelman offers a full range of services, including sick visits, routine physicals, treatment of chronic medical conditions, and travel counseling for your upcoming trip.
The office accepts most insurance plans.
Is this doctor in your insurance network?
Enter your insurance carrier and plan
choose insurance
In-network insurances
99% of patients have successfully booked with these insurances
Aetna
BlueCross BlueShield
Cigna
Medicare
UnitedHealthcare
UnitedHealthcare Oxford
Areas of expertise
This doctor's experience enhances their expertise in similar cases. Below are the conditions or surgeries they treat most frequently.
Chronic high blood pressure
Coronary Artery Disease
Acute urinary tract infection
Upper respiratory Infection (URI)
Chronic diabetes
Lower back pain
Chronic high blood pressure
Coronary Artery Disease
Acute urinary tract infection
Upper respiratory Infection (URI)
Office location
Dr. Andrew Fagelman, MD also offers online video visits for patients
Education and background
Practice names
Hospital affiliations
- Beth Israel Medical Center - Petrie Division
Board certifications
- American Board of Internal Medicine
Education and training
- Medical School - State University of New York, Buffalo, Doctor of Medicine
- Saint Vincent Catholic Medical Center, Residency in Internal Medicine
- Maimonides Medical Center, Internship in General Surgery
- Baruch College, Master's in Business Administration
Awards and publications
- Journal of Urology - "Efficacy, Safety, and Use of Viagra in Clinical Practice."
- Critical Care Resident of the Year - 2003
Languages spoken
- English
Provider's gender
Male
NPI number
1407999378
Patient reviews
All reviews have been submitted by patients after interacting with the practice.
Overall rating
4.77
Wait time
4.44
Bedside manner
4.79
Your trust is our top concern, so providers can't pay to alter or remove reviews. We also don't publish reviews that contain any private patient health information. Learn more here
8904 reviews
Most relevant
Top notch medical team, all with great bedside manner. Never an unreasonable wait. Very knowledgable. Great Soho location.
January 28, 2026Allison W.Verified patient
Dr. F was awesome. Very informative and made me feel comfy. The entire staff was great as well. Great experience.
February 18, 2026Roman A.Verified patient
Never saw the doctor. Was told they were no longer accepting patients upon arrival after my commute
January 7, 2026Adam S.Verified patient
I love Dr. F and all his staff, but the wait time video appointments have all been frustratingly long.
August 5, 2025Nick A.Verified patientVideo visit
Dr. Fagelman and his team are great. He is often teaching young doctors, who are very eager to help and are detail oriented.
August 13, 2024Initials hidden
Service was fantastic. Listening was persistent. Staff was friendly and kind.
Less than 3 months agoInitials hidden
Totally reasonable wait time. Steps were explained clearly and without condescension. Very pleasant experience.
February 20, 2025Michael B.Verified patient
As always, it is a pleasure to see Dr. Fagelman and be in the competent hands of him and his staff.
July 14, 2025Francesco F.Verified patient
Relieved my stresses through clear communication and outlining of what’s going on/ next steps
Less than 1 year agoInitials hidden
Exceedingly caring, kind, competent and cool. Everything you could want in a primary physician.
August 7, 2025Charles A.Verified patient
I would highly recommend anyone to see Doctor Fagelman MD for any medical reason!!
November 15, 2025David M.Verified patient
Great appointment. I got a vaccine but it was otherwise painless. Thanks for listening and keeping me healthy!
October 30, 2024Mackenzie K.Verified patient
Thoughtful and attentive doctor. It would be better if his staff could give an eta on start time for video visits.
More than 1 year agoInitials hiddenVideo visit
I've been with them for decades at this point. Love them and everyone that works there. At this point they're family.
February 5, 2024David V.Verified patient
Always have a positive experience with them! Great bedside manner. They listen AND hear. Won't go anywhere else!
May 31, 2024Carly K.Verified patientVideo visit
Madison from Dr. Fagelman's office was kind, thorough, and made me feel heard. I highly recommend this provider!!
February 7, 2024Carly K.Verified patient
I seriously look forward to coming into Soho Health, they’re so friendly and listen to everything I have to say.
More than 1 year agoLindsay B.Verified patient
I am very happy with my experience, they resolved my concern immediately. Will be referring my own patients to this practice.
February 11, 2022Initials hiddenVideo visit
Doctor Fagelman is a great doctor! He has been my primary care doctor for nearly a decade.
April 9, 2025Jeffrey T.Verified patient
Everyone I interacted with them as wonderful. They are kind, attentive and empathetic. Would highly recommend this practice.
March 11, 2022Shannon B.Verified patient
Always friendly and efficient staff who explain what is happening.
Less than 6 months agoInitials hidden
just moved to NYC and was the first doctor i visited. definitely plan to make my primary doctor. doctor + staff are awesome.
August 31, 2021Initials hidden
My primary doctor because the staff is nice the office is clean and they’re always welcoming.
February 21, 2025Initials hidden
I have had the pleasure of coming to the office for the last 15 years I absolutely love the staff and of course the doctor
February 17, 2022Sergei B.Verified patient
Nice office and staff. Unfortunately I was not seen by the doctor himself.
August 26, 2025Initials hidden
Got to my appointment 15 minutes early and was taken in right away. Very professional and sanitary office. Highly recommend.
March 2, 2020Michael M.Verified patient
Wait time was long (1+ hours from appointment time for an annual checkup), staff was nice.
More than 1 year agoInitials hidden
5 out of 5 experience all around , Dr took the time to listen and answer my questions .
April 3, 2025Allison M.Verified patient
A Great Doctor listen to me I loved that alot understand what I needed help with my medicines Thanks
More than 1 year agoInitials hiddenVideo visit
Great doctor. Caring, attentive, easy to talk to. Will go over all questions and concerns. Would recommend to highly.
November 7, 2022Daniel L.Verified patientVideo visit
Really impressed by the doctor calling me with the results within an hour of getting my x-rays done. The visit was fine too.
December 27, 2013Luis G.Verified patient
he made me feel comfortable and allowed me to tell him what my health issues were and suggested a return visit for results .
March 7, 2012Deborah H.Verified patient
Great first time experience. Staff was nice. Office was clean without feeling too “sterile” or cold. No complaints here!
More than 1 year agoInitials hidden
Caring and knowledgeable doctor, the kind that are part of your life and make you not want to move!
August 21, 2024John M.Verified patientVideo visit
I saw Dr . Fagelman for an annual physical and a sick visit- a very competent internist who knows what he is talking about.
September 25, 2016Charlene L.Verified patient
I love the fact that I changed PCP to DR. FAGELMAN. He better equipped to deal with my medical issues than my last pcp.
October 9, 2021Bridget B.Verified patientVideo visit
The visit was done via FaceTime.
The nurse was really friendly and took her time to explain everything I needed to know.
May 15, 2020Fanny M.Verified patientVideo visit
Always reassuring and takes the time to answer an of my questions or concerns that are current or in the possible future.
October 15, 2012Eve P.Verified patient
Dr Fagelmans experience, and genuine concern for my well being as his patient over the past 7 years saved my life.
Fact.
More than 1 year agoSteven B.Verified patient
Love this office - highly recommend, especially for Covid testing. I'm sad I'm moving away and it's less convenient.
January 24, 2022Jonathan G.Verified patient
My interaction with Andrew Fagelman, MD was brief as he has a Doctor in Training from a school do most of my assessment.
More than 1 year agoJordan G.Verified patient
I wasn't thrilled with the nurse practitioner but Dr. Fagelman was recommended to me by a former co-worker and was great.
More than 1 year agoInitials hidden
Very clean office, answered all my questions. I think the highlight was them having all the initial forms on an iPad app!
September 26, 2012Ranjan R.Verified patient
Dr. Fagelman and his team are the absolute BEST! I have been seeing him for about 6 years and I love this whole staff!
December 14, 2020Crystal A.Verified patientVideo visit
Dr. Fagelman is very patient, eloquent and thorough. His staff is really friendly and welcoming. Very happy I found him!
September 17, 2019Initials hidden
I didn’t meet with Dr Fagelman himself, but the staff in the office was incredibly competent, patient, and efficient.
August 29, 2021Initials hidden
Great, thorough doctor! Takes his time to understand concerns and offer solutions.
More than 1 year agoInitials hidden
Dr Fagelman took time to discuss things with me and look at the big picture. Very professional and a friendly demeanor.
April 22, 2013Christopher L.Verified patient
Seriously one on the very best physician experiences I have had. Great staff, thoughtful and considered communication,
December 1, 2020Charles R.Verified patient
The team was awesome and made sure I was comfortable. Great practice and extremely clean. Think I found my place in NYC
January 11, 2019Luis S.Verified patient
Loading...
How soon can I make an appointment with Dr. Andrew Fagelman?
Generally, Dr. Andrew Fagelman has appointments available on Zocdoc within 1 week. You can see Dr. Fagelman's earliest availability on Zocdoc and make an appointment online.
Is Dr. Andrew Fagelman accepting new patients?
Dr. Andrew Fagelman generally accepts new patients on Zocdoc. You can see Dr. Fagelman's earliest availability on Zocdoc and schedule an appointment online.
Does Dr. Andrew Fagelman accept my insurance?
Choose your insurance plan to verify if Dr. Fagelman is in-network.
Can I make an appointment with Dr. Andrew Fagelman online?
Yes, you can make an appointment online with Dr. Fagelman using Zocdoc. It’s simple, secure, and free.
Which hospital is Dr. Andrew Fagelman affiliated with?
Dr. Andrew Fagelman is affiliated with Beth Israel Medical Center - Petrie Division.
What practice does Dr. Andrew Fagelman work with?
Dr. Andrew Fagelman works with Soho Health NY.
Where is Dr. Andrew Fagelman's office located?
Dr. Andrew Fagelman has 2 office locations in New York, view full addresses on Dr. Fagelman's profile.
Which board certifications does Dr. Andrew Fagelman have?
Dr. Andrew Fagelman is certified by American Board of Internal Medicine.
What are common reasons for patients to see Dr. Andrew Fagelman?
Dr. Andrew Fagelman frequently sees patients for Allergy Consultation, Annual Physical, Chiropractic Consultation, Foot Consultation, and Illness. You can see other visit reasons for Dr. Andrew Fagelman on their profile.
What languages does Dr. Andrew Fagelman speak?
Dr. Andrew Fagelman speaks English.
How do patients rate Dr. Andrew Fagelman in reviews?
8904 patients have reviewed Dr. Andrew Fagelman. The overall rating for this doctor is 4.77/5. They have a 4.79/5 rating for bedside manner and a 4.44/5 rating for wait time. You can read individual reviews and ratings on their profile.