Browse specialties
Chiropractors
Dentists
Dermatologists
Ear, Nose & Throat Doctors
Endocrinologists
Eye Doctors
OBGYNs
Ophthalmologists
Optometrists
Orthopedic Surgeons
Podiatrists
Primary Care Doctors
Psychiatrists
Psychologists
Therapist-Counselors
See all specialties A-Z
Zocdoc
HomeAbout usPressCareersHelp
Contact
service@zocdoc.com855-962-3621
Discover
The Paper Gown: Stories for and about patientsThe Script: Insights for doctorsCommunity StandardsData and privacyVerified reviewsTech BlogNew
Are you a top doctor or health service?
Try Zo, your AI Phone AssistantList your practice on ZocdocLearn about Zocdoc for Health SystemsBecome an EHR partner
Insurance Carriers
Top Specialties
Welcome to Zocdoc!
Book local doctors who take your insurance
Sign up
For providers
Grow your practice
For patients
Zocdoc
HomeAbout usPressCareersHelp
Contact
service@zocdoc.com855-962-3621
Discover
The Paper Gown: Stories for and about patientsThe Script: Insights for doctorsCommunity StandardsData and privacyVerified reviewsTech BlogNew
Are you a top doctor or health service?
Try Zo, your AI Phone AssistantList your practice on ZocdocLearn about Zocdoc for Health SystemsBecome an EHR partner
Insurance Carriers
Top Specialties
HelpList your practice on Zocdoc
Sign up

Find an in-network professional from over 1,000 insurance plans

Add your insurance to see in-network doctors
insurance link for 300
insurance link for 307
insurance link for 323
insurance link for 356
insurance link for 324
See all (1,000+)
315 verified First Health (Coventry Health Care) Psychotherapists in your area
Zocdoc verifies all providers before they can appear in Zocdoc search results. Every provider that appears in search is open to new patients.
In-network providersInsurance logo
Availability last updated 04/10/2026
Availability last updated 04/10/2026

Clarence Sherrod, LPCC

Psychotherapist
4.08
·40 reviews
7 mi · 550 S Cleveland Ave, Ste G5, Westerville, OH 43081
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Also offers video visits · Accepting new patients ·
Read bio
Hi there, I'm Clay. Life is hard, and we have so much to stress and worry about in today’s world. We worry about getting the bills paid, and we're concerned for our and our loved ones' safety and health. We are often overwhelmed by many things, and it’s depressing. Some of us have experienced or are...Click to read more
Next available: Mon, Apr 13

Angela Honaker, LISW

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · Offers video visits ·
Read bio
I am Angie, a Licensed Independent Social Worker and Licensed Independent Chemical Dependency Counselor. I specialize in trauma work, and I’m passionate about helping individuals heal from trauma, build self-esteem, and navigate challenges. My approach My approach is warm, collaborative, and evidenc...Click to read more
Next available: tomorrow

Willard Sheets, LPCC

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · Offers video visits ·
Read bio
Hi there, I'm Willard! Hello. I am Dr. Willard (Will) Sheets. I hold a PhD in Counseling from Ohio University and am a Licensed Professional Clinical Counselor in the state of Ohio with 25 years of experience helping individuals, couples, and families live more fulfilling lives. My approach ...Click to read more
Next available: tomorrow

Amber Plessinger-williams, LISW

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · Offers video visits ·
Read bio
Hi there, I'm Amber! I am a Licensed Independent Social Worker (LISW) based in Greenville, Ohio, working with clients statewide. I hold a Master’s in Social Work from IU Indianapolis, a Bachelor’s from Indiana University East, and an Associate’s from Sinclair Community College. I have worked with ...Click to read more
Next available: tomorrow

Melissa Welch, LISW-S

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · Offers video visits ·
Read bio
Hi there, I'm Melissa! What's been on your mind lately? Where do you feel like you're getting stuck? I'm dedicated to helping you identify and overcome the barriers that have been holding you back. Feeling uncertain is a normal part of the journey- we'll work together to find your path forward. In ...Click to read more
Next available: tomorrow

Tatiana Mitchell, LPCC

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · Offers video visits ·
Next available: tomorrow

Cynthia Batie, LPCC

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · Offers video visits ·
Read bio
Good for you for reaching out! I would love to meet you and help you on your journey to better mental health! I tell all my Clients they are the bravest people I know, as it takes a lot of courage to reach out for help and start the counseling process! So welcome! My approach I use Cognitive Behavi...Click to read more
Next available: tomorrow

Ashley Clark, LPCC

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · Offers video visits ·
Read bio
Life can throw overwhelming challenges your way, leaving you feeling stuck or drained. I am dedicated to helping individuals navigate these difficult times with evidence-based, empathetic, and personalized care. My approach I dedicate time to truly hear your concerns, fears, and hopes without inter...Click to read more
Next available: tomorrow

Sandy Sickles, LPCC

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · Offers video visits ·
Read bio
My approach to therapy is client-centered, creating a supportive and nonjudgmental space where individuals feel empowered to explore their thoughts and emotions. I integrate Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT), mindfulness, and Motivational Interviewing to help clients develop self-awareness, build c...Click to read more
Next available: tomorrow

Carolyn Martin, LISW

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
5.00
·5 reviews
- Nov 2, 2025 by Kirsten H.Click to read more
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · Offers video visits · Highly recommended · Excellent wait time ·
Read bio
I'm truly grateful you're here. Taking the first step toward therapy and your healing journey is a brave and meaningful decision. I believe in meeting people exactly where they are, and honoring the truth that each person carries unique life experiences and hardships. Through a compassionate, person...Click to read more
Next available: tomorrow

Rhonda Farley, MSW

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · Offers video visits ·
Read bio
Hello, my name is Rhonda Farley, and I am a Licensed Independent Social Worker (LISW) providing services statewide in Ohio via telehealth. I hold a Master’s in Social Work from Walden University. I work with adolescents and adults and specialize in anxiety, depression, ADHD, Autism Spectrum Disorder...Click to read more
Next available: Sun, Apr 12

Christine Heing, LISW-S

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · Offers video visits ·
Read bio
Hi there, I'm Christine! My goal is to make therapy helpful and meaningful to you by taking a collaborative approach that addresses your unique needs and goals. I specialize in working with individuals experiencing symptoms of depression and anxiety. I also specialize in working with people who are...Click to read more
Next available: tomorrow

Robert Heidl, LISW-S

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · Offers video visits ·
Read bio
Hi there, I'm Robert! My name is Rob Heidl. My Ohio license number is I.2002030-SUPV. I help those who are motivated and seeking change within their lives and have a desire to achieve their goals. I am caring, compassionate, and always quick to listen. Working together, we can define and achieve y...Click to read more
Next available: tomorrow

Theresa Pritchard, LISW-S

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
5.00
·7 reviews
The audio and visual on the call were simply excellent. Teresa is both an excellent listener and a good communicator. I felt very comfortable with her and she was actually early for my appointment. I had no idea that mental health could be so much easier than it used to be 20 or 30 years ago. Today ...Click to read more
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · Offers video visits · Highly recommended · Excellent wait time ·
Read bio
Hi there, I'm Theresa! I'm a therapist with over 15 years of experience in community mental health centers, schools, crisis centers, and outpatient therapy offices, working with teens and adults. I use a person-centered approach to therapy where you, the client, are the expert, and I am here to s...Click to read more
Next available: tomorrow

Lisa Portune, LISW

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · Offers video visits ·
Read bio
Hi there, I'm Lisa! I am a Licensed Independent Social Worker with a Master’s in Social Work from the University of Kentucky. I have experience working with adults and teenagers across diverse settings, including child welfare, senior care, and educational advocacy. I’m married, have three adult ...Click to read more
Next available: tomorrow

Mia Maroto, LISW

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · Offers video visits ·
Read bio
Taking care of ourselves is not a luxury; it is a necessity that our society has long disguised as a waste of time. Today, evidence proves that if we reduce stress through self-care, we can increase our overall well-being. My favorite aspect of therapy is helping my clients find what works for them....Click to read more
Next available: tomorrow

Kimberly Murray, LISW-S

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · Offers video visits ·
Next available: Sun, Apr 12

Dr. Arena Mueller, PsyD

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · Offers video visits ·
Read bio
Hi there! Feel free to call me Dr. Mueller or Arena! I'm a clinical psychologist with 20 years of experience helping people cope and recover from a range of challenges including depression, anxiety, trauma, life changes, and substance use. I earned my PsyD in Clinical Psychology from Adler Universit...Click to read more
Next available: Sun, Apr 12

Amy Jones, LISW

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
1.00
·1 review
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · Offers video visits ·
Read bio
I am a Licensed Independent Social Worker with over 20 years of experience working with individuals across the lifespan. I hold a Master’s in Social Work from Aurora University and am licensed in the states of Ohio and Kansas. I pride myself on being a Neurodivergent therapist and have always been d...Click to read more
Next available: Sun, Apr 12

Dr. Nancy Grau, PhD

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · Offers video visits ·
Next available: Sun, Apr 12

Jennifer Welch, LPCC

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
5.00
·2 reviews
Friendly, empathetic, and very professional. Set me at ease. - Aug 8, 2025Click to read more
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · Offers video visits · Highly recommended · Excellent wait time ·
Read bio
I would very much like to meet you and see if you feel like we are a good match for your journey. This is a very important process you are about to take on. It might be scary for some, or for some couldn't come quickly enough. Either way, I want you to feel safe, seen, heard, and comfortable being y...Click to read more
Next available: tomorrow

Brigitte Green, LISW

Psychotherapist
4.63
·8 reviews
9 mi · 571 High St, Worthington, OH 43085
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Also offers video visits · Accepting new patients · Excellent wait time ·
Read bio
I believe individuals should drive their own therapy; I focus on a strengths-based approach centered on empowerment and self-determination. I enjoy working with individuals who struggle with depression, anxiety, and trauma. I am passionate about working with first responders, military personnel, and...Click to read more
Next available: Mon, Apr 13

Dr. Samantha Cain, PsyD

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · Offers video visits ·
Read bio
I am a licensed clinical psychologist with a PsyD and a Master's degree in Psychology from The University of Toledo. I believe in utilizing evidence-based therapy to provide the best care to clients. My areas of focus include depression, anxiety, adjustment concerns, generalized stress, obsessive-co...Click to read more
Next available: Sun, Apr 12

Mary Jo Butler Fingerhut, LISW

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · Offers video visits ·
Read bio
Congratulations on overcoming the discomfort in connecting to services that can help to create, re-establish, or reinforce the life you want to live. I strive to provide a safe and supportive environment where you feel comfortable being open and honest in order to have the best possible outcomes. I ...Click to read more
Next available: tomorrow

Tracey Tindall, LISW

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · Offers video visits ·
Read bio
Hi there! I'm Tracey Tindall, a Licensed Independent Social Worker (LISW) based in southwestern Ohio, serving clients statewide via telehealth. I hold a Master's in Social Work from Miami University. I work with adolescents, adults of all ages, families, and couples. My specialties include anxiety, ...Click to read more
Next available: tomorrow

Natalie Policani, LPCC

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · Offers video visits ·
Read bio
I take a warm, empathetic approach to sessions. I work with women and specialize in anxiety, depression, and relationship issues. Each session will be tailored to your unique needs and goals. I welcome you to reach out whenever you feel ready to begin. I am here to provide a safe, nonjudgmental envi...Click to read more
Next available: Mon, Apr 13

Alexandra Brescilli, LISW

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · Offers video visits ·
Read bio
I am a licensed therapist who specializes in supporting women through the postpartum journey as well as adults managing anxiety, depression, and life changes. I offer a compassionate and nonjudgmental space to help you feel understood and empowered. My approach My approach is warm, collaborative, an...Click to read more
Next available: Sun, Apr 12

Merav Auzenne, LPCC

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
5.00
·1 review
- May 4, 2025 by Sandrine V.Click to read more
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · Offers video visits · Highly recommended · Excellent wait time ·
Read bio
I am a Licensed Professional Counselor and a couple therapist who actively listens and remains mindful of each client's individual needs. My approach My therapeutic approach is integrative, incorporating various modalities, including but not limited to cognitive behavioral therapy, psychodynami...Click to read more
Next available: Mon, Apr 13

Kelly Walsh, LISW

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · Offers video visits ·
Read bio
Hi there, I'm Kelly! Thank you for reaching out for help. I am Kelly Walsh, LISW-S. I earned my Master's in Social Work from the University of Kentucky and my Bachelor's from the University of Evansville. I have been in practice since 1993 and bring many years of experience to my work. I practice C...Click to read more
Next available: Mon, Apr 13

Shawn Ives, LPCC

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · Offers video visits ·
Read bio
Hi there, I'm Shawn! Entering into therapy is an opportunity to do more than just symptom management, it is an opportunity to take a personal journey towards pursuing a life rich with meaning and purpose, regardless of the obstacles. My approach Therapy will be a shared collaboration that does not...Click to read more
Next available: Mon, Apr 13

Renee Leber, LISW

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · 17 years of experience · Offers video visits ·
Read bio
Hi there, I'm Renee! Seeking a therapist who will support you with warmth, honesty, and a deep respect for your journey? Whether this is your first time exploring therapy or you’re returning after a break, I welcome you to reach out. I intentionally cultivate a relaxed and grounded atmosphere in se...Click to read more
Next available: Mon, Apr 13

Dr. Ann Hetzel, PhD

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · Offers video visits ·
Read bio
My name is Dr. Hetzel. I am honored to meet you! I work gently and supportively to communicate with autistic individuals, LGBTQIA people, elder adults, those who have experienced T/trauma, and who may be diagnosed with Post-traumatic Stress Disorder, as well as individuals who experience anxiety. M...Click to read more
Next available: Mon, Apr 13

Anthony Watt, LPCC

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
5.00
·2 reviews
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · Offers video visits · Highly recommended ·
Read bio
Hi there, I'm Anthony! I am a professional licensed clinical counselor (LPCC) and licensed independent chemical dependency counselor (LICDC) in the state of Ohio. I earned my MEd in Clinical Counseling from Malone University in 2020. With a foundational background in Cross-Cultural Studies, I striv...Click to read more
Next available: Mon, Apr 13

Loretta Buckwalter, LISW

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · Offers video visits ·
Read bio
Hi there, I'm Loretta! I have been in the mental health field for many years, holding a Master’s in Social Work from the University of Cincinnati. My work has included therapy with adults, youths, and the geriatric population. I strive to learn about the client’s concerns and goals while providin...Click to read more
Next available: Mon, Apr 13

Jessica Rockwell, LISW-S

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · Offers video visits ·
Read bio
Are you feeling alone or stuck? I am an experienced licensed independent social worker with over ten years of experience in the mental health field. I have worked in a variety of settings, including outpatient and inpatient settings. I have experience working with relationship issues, self-esteem bu...Click to read more
Next available: Mon, Apr 13

Valerie Capucini, LPCC

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · Offers video visits ·
Read bio
Hi there, I'm Valerie! Hello! My name is Valerie Capucini, and I am a Licensed Professional Clinical Counselor with Supervisor designation in the state of Ohio. I hold a Master’s degree in Clinical Counseling from Heidelberg University and a Bachelor’s degree from The University of Toledo. I am pa...Click to read more
Next available: Sun, Apr 12

Angela Krempasky, LPCC

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · Offers video visits ·
Read bio
I believe prioritizing mental health is important to your well-being and can be a challenging, yet rewarding, first step. I specialize in working with individuals navigating life transitions, anxiety, depression, and trauma. I take a client-centered, collaborative approach, tailoring each session to...Click to read more
Next available: Mon, Apr 13

Cassandra Martin-Weiler, LISW-S

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
5.00
·2 reviews
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · Offers video visits · Highly recommended · Excellent wait time ·
Read bio
Hi there, I'm Cassandra! I am Cassandra Martin-Weiler, a Licensed Independent Social Worker with over 25 years of experience in various therapeutic settings. I hold a Master’s in Social Work from Michigan State University. My approach Depending on the needs of each client, I use various evide...Click to read more
Next available: Sun, Apr 12

Lynda Wick, LPCC

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · Offers video visits ·
Read bio
I am a Licensed Clinical Counselor in the state of Ohio, holding both a Bachelor's and a Master's degree in Counseling from Wright State University. I welcome the opportunity to partner with you as you move through difficult times, providing therapeutic support and guidance. I have worked in the men...Click to read more
Next available: Mon, Apr 13

Anna Marshall, LISW-S

Psychotherapist (Virtual)
Columbus, OH
In-network · First Health (Coventry Health Care)
Accepting new patients · Offers video visits ·
Read bio
Starting therapy is a brave step, and I’m honored to join your journey. I’m Anna Marshall, a Licensed Clinical Social Worker and Supervisor in Ohio with 20+ years of experience. I help clients navigate anxiety, depression, trauma, and life transitions in a supportive, safe space to build resilience ...Click to read more
Next available: Mon, Apr 13
Calendar Check
1-3 days

Average time it takes to be seen by a provider

Doctor
100k

Verified providers with a 4.8 average rating

Primary Care Physician
15+ years

In the business of finding quality care for patients

Patients trust Zocdoc
Zocdoc is great and so convenient. It always makes my appointments go smoothly as well.
Marta F
My previous eye doctor has just moved away & I needed to be seen fast, so I turned to Zocdoc. Have always found great doctors through it.
Leeanne M
Doctor is great. Great experience using Zocdoc and they even had availability sooner than the provider website
Kaleb M
NPR
New York Times
Yahoo
Self
Verge
Wall Street Journal
Frequently asked questions

How can I make a same-day appointment with a Psychotherapist who takes First Health (Coventry Health Care) insurance?

On average, patients who use Zocdoc can search for a Psychotherapist who takes First Health (Coventry Health Care) insurance, book an appointment, and see the Psychotherapist within 24 hours. Same-day appointments are often available, you can search for real-time availability of Psychotherapists who accept First Health (Coventry Health Care) insurance and make an appointment online.

How can I find a Psychotherapist who takes First Health (Coventry Health Care) insurance?

Zocdoc lets you search specifically for a Psychotherapist who takes First Health (Coventry Health Care) insurance. Just choose your carrier and plan from the drop-down menu at the top of the page. If you’re not sure which plan you have, you can use Zocdoc’s insurance checker to find out.

How can I book an appointment online with a First Health (Coventry Health Care) Psychotherapist?

Zocdoc is a free online service that helps patients find First Health (Coventry Health Care) Psychotherapists and book appointments instantly. You can search for First Health (Coventry Health Care) Psychotherapists by symptom or visit reason. Then, choose your location. Based on that information, you’ll see a list of providers who meet your search criteria, along with their available appointment slots.

How can I find a female Psychotherapist who takes First Health (Coventry Health Care) insurance?

When you search for Psychotherapists on Zocdoc, you can filter your results by gender, in addition to other criteria. That way, you’ll only see Psychotherapists who match your preferences.

How can I find a First Health (Coventry Health Care) Psychotherapist who sees patients after hours?

On Zocdoc, you can search specifically for First Health (Coventry Health Care) Psychotherapists with availability after 5 p.m.

How can I find a top-rated First Health (Coventry Health Care) Psychotherapist?

You can use Zocdoc to find First Health (Coventry Health Care) Psychotherapists who are highly rated by other patients. These ratings are based on verified reviews submitted by real patients. Every time a patient completes an appointment booked on Zocdoc, they’re invited to review their experience. Each review must comply with Zocdoc’s guidelines.

How can I find a video visit with a Psychotherapist online?

Psychotherapists on Zocdoc who see patients through online video visits will have a purple video icon on their profiles. You can also filter your search results to show only Psychotherapists who offer video visits.

Are video visits with a Psychotherapist online covered by First Health (Coventry Health Care)?

Most insurers provide coverage for video visits at the same cost as in-person visits. You can search on Zocdoc specifically for Psychotherapists who accept First Health (Coventry Health Care) for video visits by selecting your carrier and plan from the drop-down menu at the top of the page. We recommend you check with your insurance carrier directly to confirm your coverage and out of pocket costs for video visits.

How can I find a First Health (Coventry Health Care) Psychotherapist who sees patients in the morning or evening?

Zocdoc lets you search specifically for a Psychotherapist who has appointments available before 10:00 am, or after 5:00 pm. Just choose the special hours filter at the top of our search page.

How can I find a First Health (Coventry Health Care) Psychotherapist who sees patients during the weekend?

Zocdoc let's you see real-time availability for First Health (Coventry Health Care) Psychotherapists. Many First Health (Coventry Health Care) Psychotherapists offer appointments on Saturdays and Sundays.

Find doctors

    Zocdoc›Psychotherapists›First Health (Coventry Health Care)